Ecleticism in reloading tools...

Status
Not open for further replies.
It’s sad that when someone mentions Lee it becomes a religious war.

True. I don't understand the need on some people's part to bash one manufacturer in favor of another. It seems to stem from a desire to know your choice is the "best." I started out with a Lee Challenger press and use their deluxe die sets, and I get excellent results when I pay attention. Never have I felt the need to switch manufacturers, 'cause I don't fix what ain't broke. Heck, use what you like and leave the other guy to his choice.
 
:uhoh:Eclecticism, that is... :uhoh:
Like most reloaders that have been hobyists for more than just a few years, my collection of reloading tools varies widely in operations and manufacturers. I have presses from RCBS, Lee, Mec and Herters.
Priming tools from Lee, RCBS, Lachmiller and Lyman. Case trimmers from Lyman, RCBS and Lee. Case prep tools from RCBS, Lyman and Lee. Dies from RCBS, Pacific, Lee, Redding and Lyman. And on, and on....

For a long time, I used a Lachmiller priming press. It worked great and gave wonderful feel for getting the primers fully seated. It was mounted on a block of oak and lifted the priming ram when the lever was lowered with an eccentric cam. Problem was, you had to handle each primer individually and place it in the little hole for the ram. Tedious beyond description after the first 50 cases or so.
Then I discovered the Lee Auto Prime hand priming tools and began using them almost exclusively just because I didn't like the RCBS press mounted priming tool, either. They were inexpensive enough that I had one each for large primers and small primers. The levers had a habit of breaking and I replaced them at least three times over the 25 years or so that I used them.
Then I bought a RCBS hand priming tool because Arthur Rightuss was making the Lee tools so painful to use. I loved it dearly, too, except for the hassle of changing from large to small priming configuration.
Then along came the RCBS Universal Hand Priming Tool. Yay!! Had to have one! It works great with one minor issue: The coil spring that retains the jaws in the frame has a habit of popping off and flying across the shop about every other time I use it. It's not a big deal, just a damn nuisance. Again, there is also the hassle to change out between large and small primers. It is too expensive to warrant having one for each primer type.

Now Lee has married my beloved Lachmiller with the Lee Auto Prime and calls it the Lee Auto Bench Prime. I cautiously bought one for, IIRC, $23 and mounted it on a small block of oak. I used it the first time, after having to loosen the screws holding the two halves of the cast pewter tool housing together, and declared to my beloved 'the manual priming tool has finally been perfected!' (She gave me a look that convinced me she was certain I had lost my mind and needed to be restrained.) It has the multiple primer reservoir and auto feed of the RCBS and Lee hand priming tools and the leverage and feel of the Lachmiller. I really like this little tool!
The Lee Auto Bench Prime is cheap enough that I am going to buy a second one just so I don't have to swap out between large and small priming tasks. Which is far easier than any of the hand priming tools I have used.

You can say what you want about Lee's stuff, but the tools that I have used of theirs have been very functional. They might leave a little bit to be desired for fit and finish, but they do work! I definitely recommend this tool to anyone that reloads metallic cartridges!

Jut my two cents.... :thumbup:
does the lee auto bench prime have the same feel as the lee auto prime? i am getting tired of wearing gloves when i prime cases. but, i like the tactile nature of the hand primer.

murf
 
does the lee auto bench prime have the same feel as the lee auto prime? i am getting tired of wearing gloves when i prime cases. but, i like the tactile nature of the hand primer.

murf
I, too, like the feel the hand priming tools give. It's just that my arthritis makes the hand tools very uncomfortable and some days down right painful.

I find the bench prime not quite as sensitive in the feel department, IMHO, but still very easy to know when the primer is fully seated. I find the feel of the primer starting into the pocket isn't quite as easily felt. Arthur doesn't get nearly as upset at me, either.
 
my dad had the lachmiller bench priming tool and i used it as a teenager. i can't, for the life of me, remember back that far.

my hands hurt after twenty squeezes on the lee handle and would like something a bit less stressing. thanks for the insight. i'll look into the lee product.

murf
 
I too have a mixed bag of reloading tools and supplies. I am more of a what is the best tool or the best value tool that will do what I need it to do. I have a mix of presses; Lee, Pacific, Dillon. Again task specific, single stage for precision rifle loads and the Square Deal or the LCT for handgun and plinking ammo. I like the Lee dies for most of my handgun, RCBS for most general rifle, and use a mix of Forster and Redding for precision rifle. The bench accessories are likewise a mix with RCBS, Lyman, Frankford Arsenal, Hornady and others all mixed together depending on the task and what I thought would work best and could find the best price on. I guess I just like the eclectic mix of brands and it seems to work for me and all the brands give me great service in the task I use them for. I try not to bash someone else's choice as their task, budget, or niche the product works in my be different from mine. I think all of the major brands make decent stuff these days.
 
I am 67, the Arthur brothers have moved in on my hands & fingers. I started with the RCBS Hand Primer, it broke, so I went to the LGS, they had the Universal RCBS Hand Primer, it doesn't use shell holders like the previous Primer. The only changes is Large or Small, even that is easy to change. I really like feeling the primer when it seats, you can actually feel it. Easy for these Arthritic Hands. Since the first RCBS Prime broke, I contacted RCBS Tech Spt, 3 days later, I received all of the upgrade pieces, it i a shame that it is still "Put Up", cause I like the Universal much better.

Just my $0.02
dg
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top