Rock island GI spec 1911

Status
Not open for further replies.

MilesR

Member
Joined
Oct 31, 2019
Messages
72
A friend of mine is in desperate need of money and is willing to sell his Rock Island GI 1911 45acp. The thing is stock with only 1 box of 50 FMJ fired through it. He's asking $250.

Would this be a good buy?
I've read there CS is top notch, does it have a lifetime warranty and would it apply to me?

Any opinions would be welcome. I dont have a 1911 yet so this would be my first.
 
Last edited:
If a 1911 is something you want, that's a great way to get into one. You are not likely to find a better value out there. My Rock Island has been a lot of fun and runs fine.
 
As Sovblocgunfan said, that's a buddy deal. I'd go for it. RIA makes a decent 1911, and they are generally dependable, and easy to repair and find parts for.
 
I appreciate the input everyone. They're going for approx $430 new where I live. Anyone know what there warranty is on these?
I have wanted a 1911 so think I'm gonna let him know tommorow I'll buy it from him. I checked out some reviews that look very favorable.
 
I've never owned a Rock Island, but from everything I've read, I'd snatch it up at that price. They're supposed to be great guns for the price. That being said, if I had a buddy that I knew was in need of $ and offering that good of a deal, I'd offer him the right of first refusal if I ever decided to sell, too.
 
A buddy of mine had one and I did some mods on it (new hammer, beavertail grip safety, extended slide release, extended thumb safety), and was very impressed with the overall fit and finish of the gun.
 
In a way your buddy's is better than new, since he's shot it a little bit and you know it doesn't have any obvious problems. RIA's CS has a good reputation. I don't think that they would know that you're not the original owner, or if that even matters.

The design has had the bugs worked out of it for about 100 years now. If his pistol is working fine now, chances are very good that it will continue to do so.

Wow, it looks like I way off in my previous price estimate. I was looking at things for another thread, and it looks like $400 OTD NiB is pretty typical. The buddy price is better than I'd realized.

I have had several RIA's. One had some issues and they fixed it for free (it was a limited-edition model that they didn't make many of). The other two are standard models and have worked perfectly.

If you can see the small GI sights well enough to shoot it effectively, jump one it!

This one was a little over $350 OTD brand-new including shipping and FFL. I got it instead of the GI model because my middle-aged eyes don't work well with those little sights.

My RIA's have worked well with every kind of after-market magazine I've tried them with. The mags are widely available and inexpensive, so you won't have any trouble finding or affording them.

 
Last edited:
unless its a complete p.o.s. and or has hand some kitchen table gunsmithing to the internals.... I'd buy it at that price.
 
That would be a good deal on an entry level 1911, and easy to flip if you later decide its not for you. I messed with one that belonged to a friend, it performed like a typical "arms room" issue pistol from "back in the day".
 
That is a Deal!

gtPckYj.jpg

bYTfb5t.jpg

Mine shot high and the slide opened hard and fast. While it functioned each shot, I was worried about peening. I sent it back to the factory, for free! It only cost me the price of a box, and they sent it back and it shoots to point of aim and the hard recoil issue is gone.

wLLy0k1.jpg

This is a bare bones 1911 and I like the configuration. I consider carrying a 1911 cocked and locked dangerous because I have had the safety bump off. So have many others. And, it is easy to bump extended safeties on/off accidentally. Happens all the time. The pistol was designed, and carried, round in the chamber, hammer down. The only reasonably safe way to lower the hammer is to pull the trigger with one hand, and place the middle finger of the other hand, for me left hand, between the hammer and frame. I pull the trigger, the hammer is released but it is blocked by the middle finger. I pull the middle finger slowly out, lowering the hammer slowly, using the forefinger behind the hammer spur to control the process more positively. When I get the hammer to half cock, my middle finger is totally withdrawn, and it is a simple matter of lowering the hammer completely down, slowly, with the forefinger.

Once the hammer is down, the only way to fire the gun is by dropping it on its muzzle. The mechanism has a short, rebounding firing pin that will not contact the primer unless it is hit hard by the hammer. A high enough drop will create enough inertia that the firing pin will over come the spring tension. For a series 70 action, this is true whether the hammer is down, or the piece is cocked and locked. Once the hammer is down, the long hammer spur and out of the way grip safety tang allow quick thumb cocking, either by the support hand or the shooting hand. The early pre A1 1911's had a very wide hammer spur and the grip safety did not have a tang, all features to make it easy to thumb cock the pistol.

The pistol only has a safety because the horse cavalry needed a way to make the pistol safe with one hand. If the horse went bonkers, the rider could convulsively grab the trigger and fire the weapon. The safety allowed the rider to make the piece safe with one hand. Assuming he did not fall off the horse before putting the safety on. I knew a gunsmith who was in the pre WW2 horse cavalry. A bud of his fell off his horse during saber practice. His sword was attached to his wrist by the sword knot. Bud had released the sword, but still, it was attached to his wrist, and did not go far. As he fell, the sword reversed, rotated, the point got under the arm pit of the falling rider. The man was impaled when he and his sword hit the ground. He died, and it was not uncommon for men to be hurt, or shots fired, when riders lost control of their horses.

Until then the troop trails, John Browning's 45 Automatic designs did not have a thumb safety. Now how did John Browning carry this 45 Automatic?

usZsCzE.jpg

The pistol has been heavily modified, starting in the 1950's with the Leatherslap crowd, to make the pistol fast to shoot in quick draw games. Walk and draw Cowboy games were all the rage, you could easily identify evil doers as they wore black cowboy hats. And it was well established in movies and TV, that the first man to clear leather always won the gunfight. Hence the long, extended safeties, (which bump off, and on easily!) and beavertails (which are comfortable), and small hammers. These modifications make condition two carry difficult, but the original A1 configuration, which the RIA GI follows, makes condition two easy. Just don't lower the hammer with the thumb of the shooting hand. Lots of accidental discharges have occurred when the hammer slipped off the thumb. Use two hands to lower the hammer.
 
I believe RIA does have good customer service, as I’ve read in other places.

But forget that. It’s a 1911. It can all be fixed, no matter what. And it’s your buddy. Even if it were the worst gun you could think of, I’d be willing to help a buddy out.

Help him out, and as others have said, give him a buddy deal too.
 
He's gonna be moving out of state in a few weeks hence in desperate need of cash. After reading everyone's response I talked with my wife and checking to see what these things go for . We've decided to give him and his family $325 for it. Its gonna leave me alittle tight on cash as I wasnt planning on buying another handgun just yet but seems like It would be highway robbery for me to only give him $250. He definitely hasn't modified it or messed with it. He only bought it maybe a month ago and shot it when we went to the range together last week.
The only thing I think I'm gonna do with it besides shoot it is maybe change out the grips.
Thanks to everyone for there input. Other than a 9mm shield and a 637 smith revolver this will be my first 1911.
 
You will love the G.I. spec Rock Island. This is mine in 9 MM. It has one of the best triggers of all of my 1911 pistols. The only thing I changed was the grips. I found a set of these Dan Eagle grips on Amazon, and they dressed up the gun really nice. They are also a bit thicker, and really help because I have large hands.

jzQGeNj.jpg
 
He's gonna be moving out of state in a few weeks hence in desperate need of cash. After reading everyone's response I talked with my wife and checking to see what these things go for . We've decided to give him and his family $325 for it. Its gonna leave me alittle tight on cash as I wasnt planning on buying another handgun just yet but seems like It would be highway robbery for me to only give him $250.....
Good for you. I'm sure he'll appreciate a little extra cash, and you still get a good deal.
 
That was kind of the OP to give more than the asking price. He showed himself to be a good friend.

Here is my 9mm RIA Citadel that I paid around $300 for used. (Keep in mind the LGS gives me a "preferred customer" price, especially if it's been in the case for a while.) It's a good shooter that's given me no problems.

 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top