Pick one

It would depend on the requirements. If i could take it and sell it or if i had to keep and shoot it. Or carry it. I like the glock if its my $ and my butt on the line, i like the sig if its cheap/free and for range use. I like sig but i'm not going to carry a 229.

What is a Glock H23 ?

P227 SAS

This isn't even close!

mongoslow

First of all let me thank you for your extraordinarily generous offer! Since I already have, and love, my SIG P229 in 9mm. I would go with the P227 SAS. Many, many years ago I had a Browning BDA in .45 (a SIG P220 by any other name), and it was one of the most accurate and softest shooting .45s I have ever used. Would like to see if the P227 could match or exceed my previous experiences with a SIG in .45 caliber.

I like 45s, and I like Sigs.
So P227.

Sure wish they hadn’t discontinued them.

My 227 Carry needs a mate, and I already have about 4 P-229s, so I'll take the 227 SAS. PM'ing you my FFL info for the shipping. Thanks!

460Shooter said:

I like 45s, and I like Sigs.
So P227.

Sure wish they hadn’t discontinued them.

Click to expand...

Me too. I did manage to grab a LNIB P227 Nitron just as they were discontinued. Great pistol.

229 cause I like .40s....and 229s.....

My first choice would be the ATI... in .45. I have no use for a .40, and no use for a DA/SA auto, so otherwise my vote would be 'none of the above.'

The Sigs can be had in a SAO configuration.

Charlie98 said:

My first choice would be the ATI... in .45. I have no use for a .40, and no use for a DA/SA auto, so otherwise my vote would be 'none of the above.'

Click to expand...

Lucky Derby said:

The Sigs can be had in a SAO configuration.

Click to expand...

TBH, I was trying to be kind. I don't really have any use for a SIG, either... As much as I dislike the Glock, I'd pick it over a SIG.

The SIG P227 is one that I’ve always wanted and it’s out of production so that’s the obvious choice for me.

The 1911 since I don't have one and have always wanted one. The G23 would be my second choice since it is a very good all-around carry gun. If Glock ever releases a Gen 5 G23, then I will be like a fat kid at a buffet.

G23 - not a fan of P22X Sigs being a left handed shooter. The slide lock is too far back on the frame making it useless to a lefty.
Slingshotting the slide or switching hands get old.

Can I PM you my FFL's address...

SIG 227 (I like SIG & 45 ACP)

94045 said:

P227 SAS

This isn't even close!

Click to expand...

Yeah, wish I had picked one up a while back when I had the chance.

Don't care for DA/SA or the non Legion grips, but I bet I could make that one work for me.

mongoslow said:

Amazing at the differences in the poll between here and at Defensive Carry, you guys are more into the ownership , shooting, and use of the gun and have a more electic taste in firearms as there it's all about carry and defensive use, the polls between the 2 sites are nearly polar opposites

Click to expand...

Makes sense given the emphasis of the other forum.

no 9mm?