"I dont think any of them could screw with Henry Morgan, Bart Roberts, or Blackbeard."
Actually, I wouldn't bet one way of the other. One person's evil is as good as anothers, regardless of the time.
It's OK to carry a highly romanticized notion of pirates, but it is important to remember that they were still bloodthirsty murderers and thieves.
It's also to important to note that practically ALL of the pirates of the "Golden Era" of piracy had fairly short careers (in terms of time, not achievement.) A vast majority of them met a bloody end or were hanged for their crimes.
What is even more interesting is that most pirate ships operated as democracies-- electing the captain. There are ships that had as many as 18 captains in a 12 month period of time.
We can romanticize them, but there isn't anything redeemable in their character or morality. And I certainly wouldn't want to be one-- captain or crew. Malnutrition, Disease, Illness, Filth, and then a very bad death are all part of the job description.
Confirmation of this can be seen in the fact that when Blackbeard blockaided the city of Charleston, SC he demanded in exchange for hostages a small box of medicine to treat STD's.
I watch the Hilter, I mean History Channel, too
John