To me, "All around" means it has to be able to at least be capable of doing everything I ask in a handgun:
1) concealed carry comfortably with a lethal load
2) plink for fun with a cheap ammo
3) defend against scary game that may threaten me or my horses where we travel
The only gun I own that can do all that easily is a 2.5" K frame S&W .357. Ergonomic, friendly sights (rr/wo adjustable), all steel, and handles everything from 2.7gr of unique under a 148gr WC for fun, to a 180gr bear load from Double Tap. These are limits I can live within.
If I reduce the "comfortably" portion of requirement #1, a 4" 686 or a 3.5" 27 becomes more likely.
Like Snapping Twig, I also have a 3" .44 magnum and those are very versatile, too, just not very concealable. If I take concealed and "cheap ammo" out, then it's the 629 3".
Decisions, Decisions, Decisions...