Why didn't the APS priming system catch on?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Haha! Just 3? There might be 6 on all the reloading forums.

You guys are hilarious. Full of it, but hilarious.

Green machine, piggy back and I believe one other that was a dedicated progressive, all pretty much failed to catch on mostly because they were fussy as hell(read in the archives, there is very little boasting, mostly moaning about them in very few threads). Reloaders don't forget, I read here and at TFL and a couple other places like arfcom, the RCBS 2000 guys are very scarce.

Might be two reasons: 1. Pro 2K guys rarely ever have any problems with the press, so they don't have to post here often, whining about their press breaking, out of sync, or having blown a hole in the ceiling of their reloading room with their tube priming system. 2. They get sick of a few Dillon owners who think its cool to put down anything except Dillon. I'm one of the few willing put up with it.

It is going to take at least one more redesign before they catch up, I suspect. It has nothing to do with APS, they are flawed because almost everything that happens on the press is in the same place.

You don't know what you're talking about.... station 1 sizes, station 2 primes, expands, and charges, station 3 feed bullets automatically, station four seats and station 5 crimps.....whoa, that's just like on a Dillon 650! Surprise. Its no different than any other 5 station press. I don't think you've ever seen one work. In the same place? That'd be the Rock Chucker, sir.

People that shoot competitively aren't going to build their own case feeding mechanisms nor mess with loading strips when they can load tubes at the bench faster than they can use them and the Dillon case feed system is excellent.

At least those who can't build their own won't. We don't "mess" with strips, we buy them ready to load.....what we don't have to mess with is loading dangerous tubes. Now if I was a competitor I might like a Dillon, but It'd be a 1050. I agree that the Dillon 650 set up for one caliber is fast enough .... at least until they blow a hole in the ceiling with a whole tube of primers going off. RCBS does make a bullet feeder that speeds up the Pro 2K similarly to the case-fed 650. But when its time to change calibers.....the 650 is not so fast. In fact it's slower than any other press. But like you say, it's a nice press for competitors who load one caliber a night. But for people like me who want to load 2 or 3 calibers in an evening, it flat sucks. You can help it some if you have the money to buy a caliber change kit with a separate powder measure for every caliber you load.

Folks that do a lot of comp shooting load up 3k rounds in a short afternoon on a 650 with almost no effort, comparatively. The RCBS is every bit as expensive as a 650 but significantly slower. That is the bottom line. When and if they build a better mouse trap they will sell like hot cakes.

Yes the Pro 2000 is expensive....but at least you get a strong cast iron press that won't do this aluminum trick:

brokenDillon2.gif

or this one:

brokenDillon1.gif

And APS primer systems don't do this either:
attachment.php

but hey Dillon will replace all the (press) parts destroyed.....wear safety glasses....you'll have to sue them to get your glass eye. :)
 
Last edited:
I like the idea of the primer strips. It's the main reason I even considered the Pro 2000. But the press being as expensive as it is and the fact that the pre loaded strips aren't too common (which would add to the cost to get the strip loader) turnede away from it. That and not having the ability to have a case feeder. Two years later I still don't have a case feeder on my LNLAP, but I have the option, and one of these days I'll either buy one or attempt to build one.
 
Admittedly, the APS system would not be easy to adapt to other currently available presses. Probably a total redesign of the press would be required.
That is probably true. Most other press manufacturers probably won't rush to the drawing boards to redesign their presses and retool to accomodate the APS system after the patent expires. But, I won't be surprised when other manufacturers introduce press mounted and/or bench mounted APS priming tools. Nor will I be surprised when primer manufacturers other than CCI start marketing their primers in APS strips.

I don't have to wait for that day, though. I'm one of the 4 (or is it 6?) Pro 2000 owners on the planet. :D
 
So its official then...being a pro2000 user myself all 8 of us are here in one thread. Talk about a small world :neener:

I dont want to burst anyones bubble & believe me I completely agree about the APS system being a safer priming setup...but dont think that ONLY one primer will light off when crushed. This was solely user error (read MY FAULT)
Running a batch of .223 and a crimped primer case got thru when I first got my press. Instead of backing off when I felt some resistance the knuckle dragger in me floored it, so to speak & crushed a primer, setting off 4 or 5 in the strip.
It IS possible. Still much safer than an entire tube going off though. I learned to reload in `92 so I knew better than to force it...just a dumb*** mistake.

IMG00228-20120122-0931.gif
 
Last edited:
Ouch! LOL! As someone said, "you can't fix stupid"......to bad all of us are at times.:D Don't feel bad, my most recent stupid moment cost me $5,000 at an autobody shop. (a wall sideswiped me:rolleyes:)

Thanks for the picture.....there you have it, a worse case scenario with forcing a primer using APS....4 or 5 versus 100.

Very Curious though...... What brand of primers? Was there any damage to the APS mechanism? Tell us the rest of the story. Scare your wife?:)

I have done the same thing (put an already primed case in station 2 and tried to prime it).....luckily I wasn't in one of my hurry, hurry, impatient moods that day, so it was a non-event. Yes, it was also when I first got the press.

So its official then...being a pro2000 user myself all 8 of us are here in one thread. Talk about a small world

Not even close....Peter Eick isn't even here....a few months ago he passed his 300,000 loads mark on his Pro 2000 (non-Dillon pistol competitor). The last six months, I've had P.M.'s from a dozen or so more Pro 2000 newbies, asking about my home-made $50 case feeder. Wouldn't it be nice if we could have a place to go where we are not harassed and run over by the dinosaur herd.
 
Last edited:
I have never boomed a primer, but man I have crammed them every way you can imagine into a case. Side way, Upside down.

I have been using a RCBS bench top strip primer for two years now. Never going back to tubes.
Another benefit.
When the rush on components came. CCI primers in the strips were the last to run out.
I got to stock up a bit. Soooo shhhhhhhh we dont want every one to know.
 
Don't feel bad, my most recent stupid moment cost me $5,000 at an autobody shop. (a wall sideswiped me:roll eyes:)

Sideswipe, heck. I had a wall flat get in the way. I was grading the area in front of the barn and backed into it with the box blade. Took the wife six years to see the dents in the sheet metal siding though.:)

I have done the same thing (put an already primed case in station 2 and tried to prime it).....luckily I wasn't in one of my hurry, hurry, impatient moods that day, so it was a non-event. Yes, it was also when I first got the press.

With my Hornady L-N-L and Dillon SDBs, I prime off the press. No big deal inserting an empty case back in at the front of the process.

Last summer when I added the Pro2000 and started priming on the Pro2000, I had to change my mind set. When a case is removed from the press like for check weighing a powder charge, I have to put it aside until I am done with the unprimed cases.

Obviously you cannot prime a primed case but also the strip advances whether you prime a case or not when cycling the press.

Once in a while i can teach this old dog new tricks.
 
Last summer when I added the Pro2000 and started priming on the Pro2000, I had to change my mind set. When a case is removed from the press like for check weighing a powder charge, I have to put it aside until I am done with the unprimed cases.

Obviously you cannot prime a primed case but also the strip advances whether you prime a case or not when cycling the press.

Once in a while i can teach this old dog new tricks.

I ran in to the same thing, so I decided the press needed a way to take the primer system off line to allow for such things....I was amazed how simple it was to make it happen. In the link below click on the second sub link (red underlined title):

Simple RCBS Mods
 
Last edited:
So its official then...being a pro2000 user myself all 8 of us are here in one thread. Talk about a small world.


Come on, just 3 more and the Pro2000 users will run out of fingers!!:) :) :) =3
 
HTML:
Obviously you cannot prime a primed case but also the strip advances whether you prime a case or not when cycling the press.

Chuck, The APS strip only advances if you push the lever (Pro2000) forward to prime. I've sized 300 cases at a time with a half-used APS strip still in the press. The strip never moved.
 
Very Curious though...... What brand of primers? Was there any damage to the APS mechanism? Tell us the rest of the story. Scare your wife?

Win SR
Other than a scarred strip that serves to this day as a reminder no damage.
It didnt scare her so much as make her peak around the corner and ask what the eff was that? ;)

Really no more to the story. I simply overlooked a bunch of lake city brass that wasnt reamed/swaged & tried to jam a fresh wsr in there. Like I said, it was totally my fault. I even thought "back off" when I felt some resistance but my priming hand seemed to think it knew better.
FYI: it was a single "BANG" when they went off.

And yeah like others I've managed to bugger up a few over the years...seating sideways even upside down once (the primers, not me)in both my pro2k and an rcbs auto bench primer (tube style)but never had one touch off.
I still think its a great system and like A Pause for the Coz said. When everything else ran out PV still had aps strips:neener:
 
HTML:
Obviously you cannot prime a primed case but also the strip advances whether you prime a case or not when cycling the press.

Chuck, The APS strip only advances if you push the lever (Pro2000) forward to prime. I've sized 300 cases at a time with a half-used APS strip still in the press. The strip never moved.

I will have to check that out. I know the strip advances on the up stroke. It has been difficult to get that part of my scan because something else is going on at the same time.

But something during priming operation may trigger the advancement of the strip.

GW Staar's modification locks out the advancement feature entirely.

Thanks
 
HTML:
Obviously you cannot prime a primed case but also the strip advances whether you prime a case or not when cycling the press.

Chuck, The APS strip only advances if you push the lever (Pro2000) forward to prime. I've sized 300 cases at a time with a half-used APS strip still in the press. The strip never moved.
Same here. If you cycle the press without a case in the priming station, a primer will be pushed up out of the strip by the priming rod, but if nothing carries that primer away it stays there and the APS strip doesn't advance, no matter how many times you cycle the press. I did a double take the first time I noticed it. I haven't investigated the inner workings of the Pro 2000 priming system, so I don't know if it's rocket science or voodoo, but it knows when to advance and when not to.
 
If only I had known that back when I bought my LNL..... I might have still bought the LNL but I would have definitely given the Pro 2000 more consideration. Who knows, I might have gone green.

I was surprised when I opened the Pro2000 box to find a strip loader. Now I have two as I have been experimenting with APS hand primers for a couple years.

I think I will modify one with some of GW Staar's strip loader modifications.

I bought my L-N-L first and am very pleased with it. The Pro2000 is used to do tasks that I do not do on the L-N-L, primarily loading some rifle cartridges. I do not prime on my other progressives but wanted to see if the RCBS APS system would be better (it is). I like that I can see the strip advance and I know a primer is in position to be seated.

I do not like the concept of storing dies in the tool head. It just does not fit with my system, not that it is not a reasonable way to do things so I screw the dies in and out of the RCBS press like a single stage.

Besides blue clashing with the decor in my reloading room, the tool head is one of the reasons I also originally passed on the Dillon 650 in favor of the L-N-L.

I use progressive presses a little different than many folks. Volume output is a by product for my purposes. I still reload way more ammunition than I can shoot.
 
I guess I am number nine. Here is my RCBS next to my Dillon 550.
Does this make me #'s 10 and 11, since I have two? :D

IMG_0542.gif

Yep, that's a Hornady powder measure on the second Pro2K in the background. I only use my LnL for case prep (note there's no primer tube on it), and the second Uniflow was down because the plastic hopper was busted in transit (you can see the rest of the Uniflow upside down on the bench).

Today, I'll be adding a Dillon 1050 to the mix (where in the heck I'm going to put it is anyone's guess) - so I'll have all three: red, green, and blue. Oh, the carnage that will ensue!
 
Tom.....you have the right idea.....and obviously the funds available to go with it! Congratulations!:D

Nice man cave.
 
Thanks, GW. I got the 1050 set up today - it claimed the spot previously occupied by the turret press. In playing around with it, I had to do something I haven't done in a long time.... peck at primers with a pickup tube.

Oh! The AGONY!! :D

Truth be told - it wasn't too bad. But I sure did miss the convenience of all my APS primer strips. I hate the fact that I can't see the primers at all during the loading operation, and have to wait until I box up the loaded rounds to make sure no primers got flipped.
 
If I had one, I'd have a new project.....to try to build a mod to convert it to APS.....but that's me.....:)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top