Howdy
As some of you may have gathered by now, I love S&W revolvers. All except for the Perfected Model. The Perfected Model has to be the dumbest thing Smith ever did, maybe with the exception of the Governor, or what ever they call that ridiculous thing that fires both 45 Colt and 410 shotgun.
But I digress.
I love the little 'lemonsqueezers' I have a few of them. This is a little nickel plated 32 Safety Hammerless, 2nd Model.
Here is a 38 Safety Hammerless, 3rd Model. The grips are worn and the finish is less than perfect, but it still works.
Here are the insides of the 38.
These things are fun to shoot. The grip safety works beautifully. When you hold the gun normally, you depress the safety. You never even know it is there. There was a variation of the 38 Safety Hammerless, 5th Model with a short 2" barrel. These are known to collectors as Bicycle Guns. The idea was you could slip one in your pocket while taking your sweetie for a spin on a couple of those high wheeled, late 19th Century bicycles and protect her from ruffians and ne'er do wells. I don't have a Bicycle Gun in my collection yet, they command a premium.
But the Perfected! Yes, I have read how they were designed so a crook could not reach over the top and unlatch the gun because the side latch had to be pushed forward at the same time. Frankly, I think that is a lot of hooey. Has anybody here ever tried reaching over the top of a Top Break in the hands of a competent shooter and tried to open it up? It ain't as easy as it sounds. As a matter of fact, it requires two hands to open most Top Breaks anyway. One hand to hold the grip and the other hand to pull the latch up and rotate the barrel down. I don't own any Perfecteds because I am not interested in them. But I have handled them and worked the actions. Yes, you have to lift the latch and push the slide release forward at the same time. It's pretty awkward. Not something you want to have to do if you need to reload in a hurry.
The Perfected Model was produced from 1909 until 1920. It was the last Top Break that S&W designed. But if you look closely, the frame was just about the same as the 32 Hand Ejector Model of 1903. A side swing revolver. Same integral trigger guard. Side plate on the right side of the frame, rather than the left. Same internal parts, including the sliding latch to free the cylinder. Very different from the parts inside any other Top Break.
Personally, I think S&W used the same basic frame as the 32 Hand Ejector for the Perfected just because it was easy to do. The parts had already been designed. They stopped producing them in 1920, probably because the Hand Ejector design had proved so practical.
All this is of course just my own opinion.
P.S. I'm pretty sure the Perfected in the photo has had its barrel cut down. They were made with 3 1/4", 4", 5", or 6" barrels, and the front sight was usually integral with the barrel, not pinned in place.