Theohazard
Member
I think we all can agree that handguns and long guns each have their places in a home-defense role; they're not mutually exclusive. But the OP asked specifically about handguns.
I think we all can agree that handguns and long guns each have their places in a home-defense role
They don't make the 17L anymore (at least not at the moment), but the 34 is basically the same thing but with a slightly shorter slide. Though if he finds a used 17L that would be a good choice too.
Once you get into "huge size is okay," why not opt for a compact carbine using your preferred cartridge?
I will say my top recommendation for an HD weapon is a military-style rifle (i.e. AK or AR-15 platform) and my next recommendation is a semi-automatic shotgun.
I'd choose any Glock in 9mm since you already have the G-26. With todays better bullets you gain little or nothing with 40 or 45. This way you only have to stock one caliber, and the longer G-19 or G-17 mags work in the G-26.
The lack of ammo is a temporary thing, and except for 22's, is over. 9mm will always be cheaper and easier to find. The answer is to stock up on ammo when available.
A concealable handgun is ideal for the first situation. It should be accessible to you on your way to the door. It allows you to deal with potentially suspicious people safely and discretely.
I like the idea of having a free hand for shepherding/holding my toddler, holding a phone, etc. I already have an AR and an 18.5" shotgun in the big safe, but the little pistol safe on the top shelf of my closet is quicker and easier to access at night, or any time.
ah just break down and buy a open gun 20 or more rounds of 9mm pushed right next to .357 mag ballistics. Upside? Power, capacity, control. Downside? Super load and flash in the face. Oh and they like to run about the 3k price range.
What I didn't like was not being able to feel when the trigger reset at all, something I think is cool about the Glock trigger. Gives me instinctive feedback for when I can press again. I know you can get the Apex trigger upgrades for the M&P that gives it a noticeable reset, but I'm not sure if this is worth the cost or possible legal ramifications. This might be a small thing, but if I'm gonna make the investment, might as well get as close to ideal as I can.
Under my pillow is a .357 snub K frame