Couple of Pictures of Black Nitride S&W1911E

Status
Not open for further replies.

AbitNutz

Member
Joined
Dec 28, 2008
Messages
975
As I posted in a previous thread, I decided to get away from the multi colored blue & stainless motif. I chose to go "Black Nitride" by H&M Metal Processing of Akron. The gun is one even shade of black. No blotches or scratches. If you see any marks on the gun, it's oil. It's also hard as can be. I accidently tried to scratch it with a drift punch and failed...If it was blued or still stainless I'd be screwed on the blue and polishing my fingers to the bone on the stainless.

I couldn't be happier. I had to disassemble every pin and screw but the total cost for one lot that included many, many parts...including two barrels was the standard $200.00 single gun price. They didn't loose anything. Even the microscopic ejector and extractor pins or the even smaller set screws for the sights. All were "Black Nitrided" and returned in an oiled plastic container.

It has a Clark 460 Rowland kit, Briley spherical bushing, Wilson barrel link kit, Ed Brown hammer, sear, magwell-mainspring housing, mag release, slide stop, two piece guide rod and Novak Adjustable sights.

phone035.jpg

phone034.jpg

phone033.jpg
 
Last edited:
Very very nice. I really like the looks of this finish. If I need refinishing on one of my blued guns I certainly would look heavy into this option. Overall it sounds as though you have a beautiful gun on your hands with incredible parts.
 
AbitNutz

Great looking gun. If I ever want to get something refinished, other than my favorite hard chrome plating, I will definitely take this black nitride finish under consideration.
 
I like hard chrome as well....a lot. Bob Cogan of Accurate Weapons and plating has had my business for many years.

The reason I didn't go with Hard Chrome was that I wanted a black finish for this gun. Price, hard chrome was twice as much. H&M was pretty much local. I could drive it there.

Cogan has the advantage that you do not have to disassemble the gun yourself. Just mail it and forget it. H&M deals only with guns ready to process. That means OEM's or guns that are completely disassembled. Since this is a metal processing treatment and not a coating...there is no buildup so dimensions don't change.

Contrary to popular belief, you can hard chrome stainless so it is a choice for folks like me that wanted to go with one color on a mixed stainless/blue guns.

You'll never read me knocking hard chrome. I have several and it is a great finish. This time I decided to go with a black finish.
 
I'm gonna likely do my first refinish in a few days/weeks and want the durability of the hard chrome *but* I'd personally rather have the black as it's less "showy" on a carry gun. How does the black nitride hold up compared to hard chrome?

I like that black look....thanks for sharing the pix. How much hardness and abrasion resistance would I be giving up to get black instead of matte/brushed hard chrome, do you know?

VooDoo
 
Thanks for the report OP.

I've spoken with Adam ("Ritt") Rittenberry at H&M and he seems knowledgeable and professional.

Black Nitride, which is Melonite, is as hard or harder than HC and has better corrosion resistance. Melonite's abrasion resistance exceeds HC in my experience.
It is possible to scratch HC, but I've yet to scratch my Melonite guns.

I am a fan of HC and have a number of handguns that have HC finish.

Melonite has proven to require less maintenance and is THE way to go in a black finish
.
 
Agreed...like I say, I dragged a drift punch across the slide while re-installing the front sight. It left a nice scar line that rubbed off with my finger. It's hard. We'll see what happens when the slide starts cycling.

Adam was the guy that took my "Box-O-Parts". I dropped it off on a Friday and it was ready to go Tuesday. I may have hit a scheduled run but I suspect that they have really quick service.
 
I accidently tried to scratch it with a drift punch and failed

You accidentally tried? How does one attempt to do something not on purpose?

Either way, that looks awesome, and I remember when i had my M&P I was very impressed with the Melonite on it.
I might have to get it done on my Colt 1911 one day.
 
Melonite, Tufftride, Nitride, Tenifer: all different trade names for various ferritic nitrocarburizing processes. Most modern carbon steel, and some stainless steel pistols are treated with this process. It is also becoming more common for rifle barrels.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top