Your Question: "Can you get Illegal Legal Guns in NYC?"
Answer: According to Michael Bloomberg, Mayor of New York City, it is easy to get illegal legal guns in the city.
The Mayor says that people buy lots of them legally in America and transport them across the border into New York City, where they become illegal guns. Then, the Mayor says, those people peddle them on every street corner of the city. That's probably also the explanation of why New York City is a traffic jam: people must be stopping their cars, trucks, and buses to haggle with the streetside gun peddlers. So in Mayor Bloomberg's view, New York City must be like an enormous gun show but all the sellers have illegal guns.
The Acting Director of the BATFE doesn't understand how what Mayor Bloomberg says could be true, in part because the Bureau is notified when anyone buys more than one handgun within a few days.
I, however, trust Mayor Bloomberg completely: I don't think he would lie. So what I can't figure out is why he doesn't fire the New York City police chief. With so many legal guns becoming illegal guns as soon as they enter the city, he should be able to either have the very big trucks hauling them caught as soon as they enter or have the streetside gun peddlers picked up and spanked.
It's a remarkable thing, though, that the same handgun can be legal before it enters New York City and suddenly become illegal afterwards. It's as if New York City casts a spell over them and turns princes into frogs. Warp.