ConditionOne
Member
This is my first post, I'm a new member. I've been a viewer of the forum for a long time, but never really felt like I had something new to say until now.
I've been shooting for ~20 years, and in that time I have had many encounters with gunsmiths. Everything from basic jobs (like firearms refinishing and sight installation) to more complex work (like custom 1911 work). I've asked around for references in the case of local 'smiths, and researched online in the case of several nationally-known gunsmiths.
Every experience - without exception - has been a disappointment. Some examples:
- Missed deadlines...and I don't mean by a day or a week, but by months. In one case I had a nationally known 1911 smith who exceeded his estimate for work by over a year.
- Shoddy work...new sights not installed correctly, refinishing work that's subpar, trigger jobs that don't come close to delivering what was promised.
- Exceeding quoted price estimates, a practice that simply isn't tolerated in other lines of work seems to be fairly routine in the world of gunsmithing.
Are there fewer competent gunsmiths today? Are decent 'smiths so backlogged with work that anyone who can perform work in a timely manner must not be very good?
I feel like I've always done my part to be a good customer...researching reputations prior to getting work done, getting work orders and quotes in writing, not needlessly bending the ear or constantly calling/emailing and asking about the progress of my work, etc. But I am really disappointed in the ability of the gunsmiths I've dealt with to deliver what they promise when they promise in a competent manner.
They say you can have work done well, on time, or at reasonable cost...just pick any two. Well, I'd be happy with that arrangement, but I can't seem to find someone to deliver even two out of three.
My answer, unfortunately (and I hate to say this because I think we need good gunsmiths) is to gravitate towards platforms that don't require gunsmithing skills. For example, I feel perfectly comfortable doing whatever needs to be done to one of my Glocks or M&Ps. On the other hand, I'm not at all comfortable milling in a dovetail on a 1911 slide. So for me, the future is likely to include platforms where I feel comfortable "rolling my own."
I guess a good gunsmith is like a good barber or a good mechanic...if you find one, don't let them go! Unfortunately for me I haven't found that person, and I'm not willing to spend more dollars trying to find what I'm afraid may no longer exist.
<end rant>
I've been shooting for ~20 years, and in that time I have had many encounters with gunsmiths. Everything from basic jobs (like firearms refinishing and sight installation) to more complex work (like custom 1911 work). I've asked around for references in the case of local 'smiths, and researched online in the case of several nationally-known gunsmiths.
Every experience - without exception - has been a disappointment. Some examples:
- Missed deadlines...and I don't mean by a day or a week, but by months. In one case I had a nationally known 1911 smith who exceeded his estimate for work by over a year.
- Shoddy work...new sights not installed correctly, refinishing work that's subpar, trigger jobs that don't come close to delivering what was promised.
- Exceeding quoted price estimates, a practice that simply isn't tolerated in other lines of work seems to be fairly routine in the world of gunsmithing.
Are there fewer competent gunsmiths today? Are decent 'smiths so backlogged with work that anyone who can perform work in a timely manner must not be very good?
I feel like I've always done my part to be a good customer...researching reputations prior to getting work done, getting work orders and quotes in writing, not needlessly bending the ear or constantly calling/emailing and asking about the progress of my work, etc. But I am really disappointed in the ability of the gunsmiths I've dealt with to deliver what they promise when they promise in a competent manner.
They say you can have work done well, on time, or at reasonable cost...just pick any two. Well, I'd be happy with that arrangement, but I can't seem to find someone to deliver even two out of three.
My answer, unfortunately (and I hate to say this because I think we need good gunsmiths) is to gravitate towards platforms that don't require gunsmithing skills. For example, I feel perfectly comfortable doing whatever needs to be done to one of my Glocks or M&Ps. On the other hand, I'm not at all comfortable milling in a dovetail on a 1911 slide. So for me, the future is likely to include platforms where I feel comfortable "rolling my own."
I guess a good gunsmith is like a good barber or a good mechanic...if you find one, don't let them go! Unfortunately for me I haven't found that person, and I'm not willing to spend more dollars trying to find what I'm afraid may no longer exist.
<end rant>