EDC knife for a young man-gift ideas

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yep
Plenty of units do not issue knives, and trust soldiers to bring their own based on preference. I know people who have brought swords, machetes, and axes to country. The only stand alone knife I saw get semi-issue was a Gerber sheepsfoot knife. I happily traded this junk away.

https://www.gerbergear.com/Knives/Folding/EZ-Out-DPSF_22-01648G

Standard issue all purpose tool was Gerber 600 multi tool with blunt nose pliers. I somehow would get these issued to me all the time. I always kept one set unopened in case they asked for it back. Otherwise they always broke on me. I preferred my Leatherman Wave on durability alone.

https://www.gerbergear.com/Multi-Tools/One-Hand-Opening/MP600_07520
Yep. Gerber is crap. You're right about the trekker. I just checked and it' "available to purchase through efense Logistics (has an NSN), but isn't a standard issue item.
 
I have lost many knives, more in my youth.
Personally, for a young man I wouldn't spend a whole lot.
 
I have lost many knives, more in my youth.
Personally, for a young man I wouldn't spend a whole lot.

That was always standard advice int he Boy Scout program. I bought my son a SAK Evo with a locking blade when he was about 10-after scout summer camp. Sure enough, he lost it. Two days ago I learned that his mom took it away from him when got back home and then she lost it.
 
Opinel #8 in stainless. It's light enough for pocket carry without a clip. It's inexpensive enough to replace when it's lost. It won't rust as easily as a carbon steel one or a Case in CV. It's awesome.

Case slipjoints are still probably my favorite for gifting, but they generally cost between $50 and $100. I can't advise gifting one to someone for an every day carry knife if they're not already in the habit of looking after their knife on a daily basis. I would say all the same things about most Victorinox SAK's with the exceptions noted below.

The Classic SD is affordable and indeed a classic but with minimal knife utility. I prefer the Rally because the Phillips driver is better than those cute little scissors. The Recruit is where the knife is actually big enough to have some practical cutting power, but for about the same price or even less, the Opinel is a better knife. The Pioneer is the SAK that starts to offer a truly good alternative to the Opinel, but at twice the price. As a multi-tool, it's clearly superior. I'd still probably prefer the Opinel's blade.
 
Opinel #8 in stainless. It's light enough for pocket carry without a clip. It's inexpensive enough to replace when it's lost. It won't rust as easily as a carbon steel one or a Case in CV. It's awesome.

Case slipjoints are still probably my favorite for gifting, but they generally cost between $50 and $100. I can't advise gifting one to someone for an every day carry knife if they're not already in the habit of looking after their knife on a daily basis. I would say all the same things about most Victorinox SAK's with the exceptions noted below.

The Classic SD is affordable and indeed a classic but with minimal knife utility. I prefer the Rally because the Phillips driver is better than those cute little scissors. The Recruit is where the knife is actually big enough to have some practical cutting power, but for about the same price or even less, the Opinel is a better knife. The Pioneer is the SAK that starts to offer a truly good alternative to the Opinel, but at twice the price. As a multi-tool, it's clearly superior. I'd still probably prefer the Opinel's blade.

Alox Pioneer is on my short list at the moment. I'm surprised at the lack of love for the SAK here.
 
I bought all of my kids SWKs (usually the Explorer or the Fieldmaster), when they were in their early teens. Still have them and have put them to good use on many occasions.
 
That Boker Sodbuster (the larger one) really caught my eye... The sharpest actual folding knife I've ever owned (and still do - it's been carefully stored now for some years....) was a Henckels (the exact same pattern and size but with a carbon steel blade and a cherry wood handle.... ). I carried it on the street with my duty gear (one of the pouches on a double mag pouch was its home). It was a real workhorse meant for emergency cutting of seatbelts, and other restraints as well as a last ditch cutter that you could score bone with..... Henckels (like Boker a German outfit) long ago quit making folding knives but that blade style, in a thin carbon steel blade would cut almost surgically... Nothing I've ever owned (Benchmade, Al Mar, Forschner....) could compare to it....
 
Quite a few used Henckels' folding knives on Ebay.

When I lived in Westchester Co. NY, both Henckels and Wusthof had their corp. headquarters there and I was able to stock up on fine kitchen knives quite inexpensively at their yearly blowout sales.
 
you should seriously consider an Opinel since the beech models can be had for less than $25 and all of them are very light
 
The saw is unuseful. A palm-wide knife blade can cut up to wrist-thick branches easily enough -- cutting at an oblique angle like a beaver, not perpendicular obviously. For anything that thick or thicker, a hatchet, axe or saw is preferred. For a saw, a Bahco Laplander would be my minimum. I typically use a 14" folding pruning saw or a Sven Saw -- great to keep in the 4x4, but not an EDC pocket item. Also, saws are not as good a gift as a knife.
 
I'm surprised at the lack of love for the SAK here.

There are many of us that carry SAKs (I carry a 20 year old Master Craftsman), but their lack of a lock is a problem as well.

Perhaps the better question we should be asking is, what will he do with the knife? Sounds like a suburban/city kid. If he hasn't had a pocket knife since he came back from Scout camp then he may not have any interest in one. If that's the case, simple becomes important and a lock doubly so (at least from my experience). The recommendation of the stainless Opinels could be just the ticket if he's not a hiker, but the locks are manual and would require him to take that action on his own.
 
...he may not have any interest in one.[EDC Knife]

Oh he doesn't have any interest in one. Ask him what we wants for his birthday, he'll tell you a list of 50 video game titles on 4 different gaming systems. (And I plan to get him a gift card to Game Stop.) But my theme for his 18th birthday is adulthood. I'm prepping him with things every man should have. What he does with it is an entirely different discussion.

On a related side note, I'm also starting an IRA account for him, co-signing a credit card, registering him to vote and for the draft. It's going to be a busy day.

But you're right the SAK and the lock. I much much prefer a locking blade, hence the reason I own one of the very few SAKs with a locking blade. I do see the value in that, so, on that note, I think my short list is:

SAK Alox Pioneer, Buck 055, Kershaw Leek, Leatherman Skeletool.

I left off the Opinel because it's not USA made. SAKs are the only imported knives I've ever owned, and USA made was part of my original list of qualities I was looking for.
 
Oh he doesn't have any interest in one. Ask him what we wants for his birthday, he'll tell you a list of 50 video game titles on 4 different gaming systems. (And I plan to get him a gift card to Game Stop.) But my theme for his 18th birthday is adulthood. I'm prepping him with things every man should have....

Right on. I've done the same thing with my nephews. One is about to turn 18 and the other is 20. They visited with their parents for a weekend this summer and I sent them home with knives, zippo lighters and fountain pens. Of course, I tried to get them to go shooting while they were here, but they weren't really interested. I've previously given them things like a hatchet or tomahawk, and wristwatches, analog ones. Do kids even know how to read those anymore, or do they just ask Siri/Google/Alexa what time it is? I would have given them tools, but I know they just take their Hyundai to Jiffy Lube and there are Mexicans that come mow their lawn. I'd give them straight razors like I used to use, but I know they wouldn't use them, and at this point I'd rather they just follow my example and grow a beard.

Some day I will give them a gun, probably a revolver, whether they want it or not. I wouldn't give them one at their present age without the opportunity to train them but at some point, they'll have to take that responsibility for themselves. I see myself as kind of like Ames Jainchill.
 
use to be a time when a Buck knife was the best sort of pocket knife you could give as a gift. since this is not a tactical carry knife conversation I suggest the Buck knife.
Buck stagnated. They failed to keep pace with the market. Almost 40 years ago, Spyderco introduced their first knife, the Worker. It had a fine tipped blade, and was marketed as a work knife, not a tactical knife, even though it featured the one hand opening hole and had a pocket clip for easier carry. Let's be honest, we carry folding knives because they're convenient. A good quality paring knife or a bird & trout type fixed blade would be great for most EDC tasks, but even in a good sheath they're less convenient to carry than a folder. Since I'm carrying a folder for convenience, why would I give up features like a pocket clip and one hand opening that make the knife more convenient to carry, and easier to use?

Are the Buck 112 Slim Ranger Select and 110 Slim Select suddenly tactical knives because they added thumb studs and pocket clips to them? Ohh, and they come in bright, friendly colors like red, blue, and yellow now in addition to boring black. Or is the black plastic handled one the tactical one because of the color?
 
Since I'm carrying a folder for convenience, why would I give up features like a pocket clip and one hand opening that make the knife more convenient to carry, and easier to use?

Genius. That statement just bumped the Buck off my short list. Thanks for the perspective.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top