First off, congrats on your first deer. Nothing like filling a freezer for the on-coming year. We just got an elk over the weekend and are after another one next weekend. And lets not even start to rag on the 30-30. That is a proven deer killing cartridge. Not a thing wrong with that suggestion
Now get some pics up!!!
Second, I guess I dont see the big deal about using hollow points for close range lung shots. Should get great expansion right in the boiler room...not a bad thing. Let's remember that lung shots are usually not DRT, you may have to follow a blood trail. Animals are tough and they go aways sometimes. Yeah soft points would have been better, but it doesn't make him
wrong to shoot a couple deer with hollow points. If they were Berger VLD's nobody would complain, because hey they're expensive so they must be ok. Just because people do stuff differently than
you, doesn't make it wrong. There are lots or right ways to kill deer. Everybody always thinks the only right way to do it is they way they do it, which is aggravating when you make a post about a good hunting trip and everybody criticizes you for it because they would have done it differently.
I shot a bull elk last year with soft points out of my 30-06 at 200 yards, which I'm sure nobody is going to argue whether or not that was ethical. He was standing still and I had a rest. Anyway, I hit him thru both lungs and exited the other side, and he ran 200-300 yards before he died. No blood trail either. He had a neat hole right thru both lungs, which is what you get from soft point bullets, and he still went aways. The important thing is following the tracks or blood trail until you find the animal. People who should get criticized are the ones who don't go look for blood after an animal doesn't fall, which happens all the time. He followed a blood trail to a dead deer, that's the important part of his story. Not saying an bad advice was given, but it could have been worded more friendly. Most people don't like being
told what to do by strangers, even on the internet. That's what I think.