NAVY JOE wrote:
"I don't particularly buy the whole extra slide mass thing, it's only .70" longer than the 17 and is cut out. I don't see the liability of the gaping hole in the top either, that area is covered by a holster and I imagine that as intricate as that hunk of plastic is you could fill it up with mud and still not have a problem. Is it possible to limp wrist a 9mm? Never seen a G34 do that, never been able to get one to despite trying."
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
I should have been a bit more clear on the limpwrist behavior here. This only happens when you shoot light loads in the pistol. For thos of you not familiar with USPSA shooting, you only have to make a minimum "power factor" for your ammunition.
For those of us who reload, that means you can load as light as you want, as long as it is above this set minimum power factor. I do exactly this, in loading lighter, for less recoil, for more rapid follow up shots.
The risk, of course, is that the light load, coupled with a less than stiff wrist, will result in short cycling of the pistol upon recoil. I am certain that if I used nothing but mil-spec ball ammo, or loaded to SAAMI (or even NATO) specs, my limp wrist problems would be non-existant.
By the way, I own a G17 and G17L as well as the G34. Only the 17L and 34 seem prone to the limp wrist issue with my lighter-than-SAAMI loads.