Since my experience is somewhat limited, and the ground rules you laid out said to only list what I actually have experience with, my lists will be short.
UNDERPRICED:
1) Makarov: Not a great caliber, and the ergonomics stink, but it is well made.
2)CZ75BD (9mm): A fantastic value for a full-size gun. Accurate, reliable, and good ergonomics.
OVERPRICED:
1) Colt Python: I'm glad I bought mine new for about $450 back in 1987. It's a sweet gun, but definitely not worth $750+. This is a case of a reputation building to mythic proportions.
2)Kahr MK40: Accurate, but heavy. I sold mine.
PRICED ABOUT RIGHT:
1)S&W 642: A great little carry revolver. It conceals when nothing else will.
2)Glock 26: No, I don't mean new; I bought mine used (barely) for $399. They go for $509 new here, which is a bit high.
3)S&W 617 (10 shot): Yeah, it's expensive, but it's worth it. I haven't ever found a gun that is as much fun to shoot.
DAL
UNDERPRICED:
1) Makarov: Not a great caliber, and the ergonomics stink, but it is well made.
2)CZ75BD (9mm): A fantastic value for a full-size gun. Accurate, reliable, and good ergonomics.
OVERPRICED:
1) Colt Python: I'm glad I bought mine new for about $450 back in 1987. It's a sweet gun, but definitely not worth $750+. This is a case of a reputation building to mythic proportions.
2)Kahr MK40: Accurate, but heavy. I sold mine.
PRICED ABOUT RIGHT:
1)S&W 642: A great little carry revolver. It conceals when nothing else will.
2)Glock 26: No, I don't mean new; I bought mine used (barely) for $399. They go for $509 new here, which is a bit high.
3)S&W 617 (10 shot): Yeah, it's expensive, but it's worth it. I haven't ever found a gun that is as much fun to shoot.
DAL