S&B is great for genuine scattergun applications. As in "to whom it may concern." As in at night when there is nothing out there but hostiles and you can't see what you're shooting at anyway and don't care what you hit. As in... well, I hope you get the picture. Some folks WANT their shotgun to throw 20" patterns at ten or fifteen yards. That's OK by me, I just hope I am nowhere in the beaten zone when they let loose.
Personally I want all my pellets to land where I aim them, in the middle of a target I can see and identify. Therefore S&B would be the last load I would choose to use in normal ordinary HD applications. I do prefer buckshot over slugs for ordinary use on soft targets, a compact pattern of heavy buckshot does more damage than a slug and is more likely to be as much of an instant stopper as anything that can be fired from a handheld weapon. But I want _tight_ patterns to obtain the desired results.
I recently tested some low recoil Fiocchi 9-pellet 00 buck loads with nickle plated pellets. These loads patterned to within 10- 15" out of several different guns at 25 yards, acceptable performance in my book. At retail they sold for $6.95 for a box of ten and are among the softest recoiling buckshot loads I have ever fired.
There are other loads that will perform as well or better as the Fiocchi and that can be found at reasonable prices if you shop around. Experimenting is always in order to determine what loads a given shotgun barrel patterns well, it is pretty much unavoidable.
If you want tight patterns you will be looking for 1) pellets of a hard lead alloy, and/or 2) pellets plated with copper, nickle, etc. to help them avoid deformation in the bore and choke 3) shells loaded with buffer/grex to help protect pellets better 4) reduced recoil loads, as they generally pattern better 5) wad designs that are effective at cushioning/controlling/containing/protecting pellets as they travel through the bore of the gun that fires them. Those are generally the factors that help produce reliable tight patterns. They are all features not present in S&B's loads... so if you want open patterns, that's an almost guaranteed way to get them.
lpl/nc