Star BM 9mm surplus

Status
Not open for further replies.

H&R Glock

Member
Joined
Jul 30, 2010
Messages
1,589
Location
Michigan
Has anyone else purchased one of these from Classic? I just ordered one. I bought my first one about a year ago and it proved to be solid as a rock and dependable.
I believe this to be an excellent investment. Unfortunately I could not get it with a C&R license, but even with dealer fees this piece should ramp up in value.
It eats all manner of ammo no problem.
 
I have had several of them. Not bad guns at all.

I wouldn't buy one for an investment, just a shooter. The slide is really peened up with import marks.
 
I had one of those several years ago I traded in on a Taurus model 94 22 magnum that I didn't like all that much. I wish I had of kept the Star. It was a good shooter but a little on the heavy side IIRC. But dead nuts reliable.
 
I bought one from AIM last year. I gave it to my sister as a gift. Yet to experience a malfunction after several range visits.
 
No one collects Stars. So, a great think to collect as they are cheap!

Prices sunk a bit when they went out of business 20 years ago and have mostly been only rising with inflation. Some covetous things like the PD have gotten relatively spendy, but that means maybe $500. And I just got one of those in VG+ for under $350. So, solid guns, available dirt cheap sometimes.

I write and collect lots more about them all here: http://star-firearms.com/
 
I have 2, love them. But due to lack of replacement parts don't see them as being investment material. Once broken beyond DIY repair it becomes scrap metal.
 
I bought one locally. Very much a mini 1911 with a few subtle improvements. Sights aren't great, and mine absolutely will not feed a flat point or hollow point bullet, but otherwise great. Looking to get a couple more.
 
I got mine from J&G and it is in fine shape. A bit of bluing rubbed off from holster wear but otherwise in very good + condition. Due to the all-steel construction, it is a joy to shoot. The extra weight compared to a plastic gun really tames it down. I love mine.
 
I have 2, love them. But due to lack of replacement parts don't see them as being investment material. Once broken beyond DIY repair it becomes scrap metal.


I was worried about that also. Gunparts. Numrich makes replacement firing pins and extractors for them now.

And for the price just by a second and use it for parts. I did that, took off the high breakage parts and sold the rest on Ebay. Actually got over $300 for the slide, grips, grip screws etc. Of course I still have the frame. If the other cracks got a replacement for that also
 
Say what? Was that sarcasm (I can't tell)?
In the US, so few collect Stars so they do not command a premium in the market prices for them, above what you would expect for guns of that era and quality, regardless of scarcity. For example, check the prices on the few Colt marked Star imports; same exact gun with some different rollmarks, 10-100x the price. That's a collector's market.

The (factory!) engraved ones are nice if you are into that, but are among the cheapest ways to get into snazzy engraved guns because again, no one really collects Stars, so they have no particular value. I have had people report getting nice engraved guns in the original presentation cases for $20 more than the plain version!
 
I love the guns, but as others have noted, finding parts is a bear. If you can find one in top notch condition, then stuff it in your bugout bag and keep it, great. But to shoot it until you need to replace a part no longer available is ridiculous. The guns still command prices that are unrealistic, because even though they are superb little guns, as far as shooting goes, they tend to be a bit overpriced. If parts were readily available, they would be gems; however, there are just too many parts in a gun that size that can fail. Magazines, magazine springs, recoil springs, etractors. It's like sitting on a ticking time bomb! I wish someone would just buy the tooling and make the gun in stainless steel. It's essentially a 1911 with all the pluses and minuses. It was never made with top notch quality components, but it wasn't junk, either. It sold for what it was worth, but as a used gun, it frequently sells for more than it's worth. A good shooter is a gun that sells for a good price and has plenty of replacement parts. The Star BM meets the first requirement but, alas, not the second. It's a great drawer gun and a nice bugout bag piece, but as a shooter, it's trouble.
 
I was worried about that also. Gunparts. Numrich makes replacement firing pins and extractors for them now.

And for the price just by a second and use it for parts. I did that, took off the high breakage parts and sold the rest on Ebay. Actually got over $300 for the slide, grips, grip screws etc. Of course I still have the frame. If the other cracks got a replacement for that also

Good to know about replacement parts, I didnt know that. Yeah that was why I bought 2 of them.
 
They shoot fine for the money. Shoot it until it breaks beyond reasonable repair. Sell whats left for parts. You'll probably make your money back.
 
"They shoot fine for the money. Shoot it until it breaks beyond reasonable repair. Sell whats left for parts. You'll probably make your money back."


Absolutely. I have a BM and a Super B. My FiL also has a Super B. They averaged about $250 apiece out the door. My two looked barely shot. My FiL's looked unissued. They are all very good shooters. As long as we can get springs and don't dry-fire them, they will probably outlast us. They seemed like no-brainer purchases to me.
 
IME Star BMs are nice, solid, dependable pistols.

I have 2 of the Star BMs that I bought a month apart in 2002. Later, in 2004, after they were long gone, I jumped at the opportunity to buy another pair, together, of discounted "rode-hard-put-away-wet" Star BMs ... which cleaned-up and reblued nicely.

==============
In the late '70s I read about the PDs and really wanted one for a carry piece, but never came across one. :(

Over the course of 3 months in 2005 I managed to find 2 in VG/EXC condition on Gunbroker ($205 & $250) ... so I got to scratch that itch. ;)
 
I know about the parts situation. It's the same for my Star Super B, but flawless performance is so amazing compared to some domestics. My S&W for instance (p22?) I also have a Colt Jr. which is made in Spain! (I choked when I read the engraving) go figure! Who knows about parts for that little 25? Ya pays yer money and ya takes yer chances. :)
 
I bought one in very good condition with an extra mag. about 15 years ago for $220. It’s a great shooter.
I fine that mine likes the 125gr ammo the best.
 
The BM definitely peeks my interest and I haven’t heard much complaints about them.

I like the three Star pistols I own. I have a Model A Super (9mm Largo), along with two Firstar pistols. The Firestars are a M43 (9mm) and a M40 (40S&W).

Right now it’s a toss up between getting a BM or trying to find a Firestar M45 (45acp).
 
This thread is making me revisit my deep regret for selling off my Star PD (which I bought in 1992 around the time Mas Ayoob, Lew Awerbuck and Jeff Cooper among others were all touting) ... yeah, I got more than double what I'd paid for it ... but it was a sweet little .45.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top