Surprising finding

Status
Not open for further replies.

Keith G

Member
Joined
Nov 3, 2018
Messages
318
New to reloading (75 rounds in.) Loaded up 25 rounds of 3.8 grains of Trail Boss behind a coated 158 grain LSWC in 38 special and found them very accurate at 25 yards. So I was excited to load up the “Holy Grail” of 3.5 grains of Bullseye behind the same bullet. Surprised to see the grouping open up significantly. Maybe it was just me, I’ll have to do further testing, but the TB shot more to POA and grouped tighter.

Taylor’s & Co. Drifter in 357 Magnum SAA. 5.5” barrel.
 
Last edited:
This is one reason why a charge range is given for powder/bullet combinations. What your gun likes many not shoot well in mind and the reverse.

According to Alliant that 3.5gr load is the current max. Reduce it by 10% and work back up to 3.5gr, you should find an accurate load along the way.
 
Just loaded up 15 rounds with 3.2 grains of Bullseye and 15 rounds with 4.0 grains of TB. I’ll test them side by side tomorrow and see how it goes.
 
Not surprising that's reloading, you just got lucky and found a great load for your gun first try. That tb load may not be as good for someone else with the same pistol even.
Welcome to reloading.

Isn't that the truth! I've gotten lucky over the years and found some very accurate loads on the first try. In my guns. When others say they like it too, then it means I found something a little more special.

I've never tried Trail Boss, I don't load many light loads but I do load a light load in .327FM, and it is very accurate at 25yds with the bullet I'm using. I think a pound of Trail Boss may be in order with this load. Just for the fun of it.
 
I agree it is amazing how much difference the right load can make in a gun. I take every gun I buy that I plan on keeping and find the best load for it depending on how it will be used the majority of the time. In my 40+ years of loading for revolvers, I've found that the correct bullet usually makes more of a difference than the powder. With exceptions of course. FWIW, here is how I start and I usually get to the final tweaking faster this way. For .38/.357 target loads, I have narrowed down my starting bullets to 3. I use 148gr LHBWC (don't think I've ever seen a .38 that wouldn't shoot this bullet at least decent) with 2.8-3gr Bulleseye, 130gr TCFP HYTek coated with 5.0gr of Universal and 158gr TCFP HyTek Coated also with 5.0gr Universal. What I've found in the past, is a lot of revolvers will like light bullets and some heavier bullets. Once I get a feel of what a gun will like better, then I start tweaking. One thing that has helped me greatly is most of my daily shooters are stainless for ease of cleaning mostly. Also I have a Weaver no drill scope mount that along with a Red Dot Tube helps take the guess work out of my ability and eyesight. Once I find a combination that will shoot around 1" at 25 yards, then I move to 50 and 75 yards which is the limit to my backyard range. Of course you will see a much bigger change at longer ranges when changing bullet and or powder. I've also found that 800-1000fps to be all of the velocity needed to shoot good groups even at 75 yards. Just because you are shooting over 25 yards, you don't need a ball busting magnum load. Of course beyond 25 yards the HBWC is pretty much useless. Everybody that reloads has their own pet powders and I would never try to tell someone what I use is better than theirs. I probably have at least 15 handgun powders in my loading building but for 95% of my shooting these days, it is limited to 5. Bullseye for HBWC. Universal and HS-6 for medium and +P .38 loads and H110 and 2400 for Magnum Hunting loads. I love to shoot and to me the fun of shooting is loading to wring out the utmost accuracy of a gun. Knowing what load is the most accurate in a particular gun sure is a lot more fun than shooting at a steel plate and wondering where your misses are going. AT least when I shoot, I know the misses are caused by me and not the wrong ammo.
 
14AB41DA-5ED8-4DCB-92FE-3DBDEA70F802.jpeg E3DC0D4F-259A-461A-A10E-72F855D8FE05.jpeg Ok, so dropping the Bullseye load from 3.5 to 3.2 tightened the group up quite a bit for that powder. Increasing the Trail Boss load from 3.8 to 4.0 opened the group up a fair bit for that powder. This whole hand loading thing is “fun”.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top