Demitrios,
You have a lot of mis-conceptions about what constitutes a "real" 1911.
I bought a Rock Island Armory 1911-A1 that's more original to the old models than almost any Colt and far cheaper
COLT just re-released the 70 Series last year. It is a real as it gets. That RI is cheaper but it is also made from a much weaker casting and made overseas. I didn't think either of those "spec's" were in JMB's blue prints.
I then bought a Dan Wesson Razorback-10 that is anything but similar to what Colt designed and comparable in price
Spiffy looking - but still made out of a casting and still an overseas owned company (althou they do at least build them here). MSRP on the CZ/DW is listed at nearly 1200.00, a bit more than a 70 Series, WW1 repro, Combat Elite.... in fact almost every current COLT model except the Special Combat Govt Model. COLT originated the 10mm in a 1911 platform. In fact that platform was the 80 Series Delta Elite.... who's not staying true to the original now? COLT is again building the Delta Elite and it cost less than the DW.
In my opinion for the money you spend on a Colt you can put your money elsewhere and get a better gun
What you should say is "for the same $$$ you can get a different gun", because neither RI or DW is even in the same ball park as COLT when it comes to the basic foundation of building a 1911. They can put all the silly nostalgia inducing roll marks on the slide they want or polish that stainless steel casting up till it gleams in the display case and advertise in the gun rags how its got "ED BROWN" grip safeties (ill fitted as heck I might add) to try and divert from the fact that they skimped where it matters the most. If you put a million dollars worth of parts into a turd - in the end all you have is a really expensive turd....
STI only offers (1) pistol under $1200. It's an Armscor/RI casting with a bunch of spiffy looking STI parts hung off it. Again stuffing a million dollars in a turd.
Your can to build a Caspian frame/slide from the ground up to the level of quality of a COLT for less or the same $$$ ??
Perceived value is almost everything and it comes from "received value". No one wants to sell their COLT/RI/DW/Baer ect - but "how much it's worth" in the long run is the only real measure you have of it's perceived value. COLT wins that hands down against every other 1911 in the world because it's got EVERYTHING going for it. People know the name, people know the history, people know its made from a forging, people know it will work when needed, people know it will last several lifetimes, people know if they get hard up for $$$ someday it'll bring fair value to almost anyone they can sell/trade it to.
I'll say it again DW/RI/ect are good guns. Some are cheap, some are expensive because of all the spiffy parts - but they are not a COLT. If those companies attempted to build what COLT offers (American made/owned with Forged Frames/Slides) they would (rightfully) charge a small fortune. Go buy a gun from the one company you mentioned that does offer that quality (STI) and see what it cost you.
When you buy a COLT you get EVERYTHING that goes along with owning a COLT. At one time I think the owners/managers/workers of COLT forgot that (and it rightfully almost put them out of business). I believe the current owners/managers/workers of COLT know EXACTLY what that means. You get your $$$$ worth with a COLT, because you have to. COLT has too much riding on the sale of their guns. You can't exactly run the COLT name in the ground building junk and put a different roll stamp on them next week like those overseas builders can. I'm not saying those companies will - but ARMSCOR does offer the same gun under about 5 different roll stamps already.... IMO it's best to buy from the company that has the most to lose if they sell you a POS.
"Quality" is all in how you define it. You will never get $1200 "quality" for $500. You will never get "COLT" quality out of a DW or RI but, obviously you can get a DW or RI quality for the price (and sometime more than the price) of a COLT.
Will