How did they get mangled as such? Looks like there's marks on the bullets and neck as well...
That top one has me wanting a closer look, but I suspect both would be fine so long as they chamber easily. That said, there's plenty of times I've been burned when I went against the gut feeling, and if it only costs $2 to be absolutely sure you don't have a catastrophic failure (from these rounds, at least), it sounds like a deal to me.