Like Eb1 I first shot one at the age of ten. They've been a lifelong addiction for me, but at the same time I can understand how many of the younger folks don't see what's so special about them. It's like the guys who like double-action revolvers or Browning Hi-Powers, I owned both on at least two occasions and sold them off just because I couldn't get "into" them. I've had brief love affairs with other guns, but I keep getting drawn back to Old Slabsides. My EDC is a 5" Colt, and I find it's actually easier for me to carry than a Glock or Walther simply because it's so flat and smooth-sided.
For the OP, I suggest getting a GI-pattern Colt or Springfield. It'll feel like you're shooting some history, and never know it may finally grow on you. I've personally never cared much for the semi-custom ones. Yes they tend to shoot better than a "mil-spec" 1911, but they don't have the same soul.