I'm torn between purchasing a new Ruger black hawk SA revolver in these two calibers. I do reload so that will help with keeping myself supplied with ammunition. I find that I keep leaning more toward the .44 SPL as it is more efficient in that it don't consume as much powder as the .41 mag. However the .44 SPl will still be able to push a 250gr Keith bullet to 1200 fps safely. That load has put down a lot of animals in the past with out any problems either. I also like the fact that there is a much better assortment of bullets in .44 caliber.
On the other hand I really like the .41 magnum. My S&W M58 is very accurate but it sucks when all that is available is full power hunting loads. The other thing I don't like is that while the .41 mag is one of my favorite cartridges, the lack of bullet selection sucks as well. However it too has put down a lot of big animals. There are no flies on either of these cartridges they're both great but I'm just stuck. So lets have a discussion what would you all get between these two and why.
On the other hand I really like the .41 magnum. My S&W M58 is very accurate but it sucks when all that is available is full power hunting loads. The other thing I don't like is that while the .41 mag is one of my favorite cartridges, the lack of bullet selection sucks as well. However it too has put down a lot of big animals. There are no flies on either of these cartridges they're both great but I'm just stuck. So lets have a discussion what would you all get between these two and why.