I'll start this off by saying on deer size game I don't think there will be a lick of difference between a 30-30 and a 7.62x39, but on tougher animals where heavier bullets start to make more sense with more sectional density for penetration (123gr SST = .183 vs 170gr Nosler Partition = .256) can start really having an effect.
There is no doubt that 7.62x39 as compared to 30-30 in
lighter weight bullets will close the gap on the two cartridges. However, in many if not all of these types of comparisons where the case with the greater volume starts exceeding the other is when heavier and heavier bullets are compared. I have a feeling if one gave as much emphasis on loading the 30-30 with 160gr-180gr bullets to peak performance (as is being done with handloads of the 7.62x39 in 123gr offerings to achieve 2,600fps) one would start to see where the 30-30 would take over on energies when shooting heavy bullets. The combustion chamber size starts to have an effect, especially when bullets start protruding down into the powder area. Much like when comparing something like the 280AI compared to the 7mmRM, in the 140gr class of bullets the difference between the two is negligible, start getting into the 175gr class of bullets and the spread starts widening between the two as the extra case capacity of the 7mmRM starts paying dividends.
This is the case with many comparisons where there is a case volume difference between the two cartridges in question.
- 30-30 holds about 45 grains of H2O
- 7.62x39 holds about 31-32 grains of H2O
30-30 Winchester
- Winchester 170gr Power Points = 2,200fps, 1,827 ft/lbs. (no barrel length specs)
- Hornady 160 gr. FTX = 2,400fps, 2,046 ft/lbs. (test barrel length 24")
- Federal Premium 170gr Nosler Partition = 2,200, 1,800 ft./lbs. (no barrel length specs)
- Handload 160-180gr (curious to know what one can achieve with a bolt action
- Handload 130gr bullets and I bet they will be close (albeit slightly faster) to the velocities listed below in the handloads for the 7.62x39
7.62x39
- Hornady 123gr SST = 2,350fps, 1,508ft/lbs. (no barrel length specs)
- Federal Fusion 123gr bonded = 2,350fps, 1,510ft/lbs. (no barrel length specs)
- Handload 123gr Hornady SST = 2,500 fps, 1,707 ft/lbs. (16" barrel)
And all of this coming from a person who really likes the 7.62x39, I think it's a very underrated cartridge to be sure. The reputation the x39 was built on provides a false narrative as to what can be achieved, it really has received and lives under a shadow of performance from loose tolerance rifles.