A deer hunting story....

Status
Not open for further replies.

RoostRider

Member
Joined
Mar 28, 2008
Messages
670
I just gotta say.... My apologies to those who pack a handgun when rifle hunting.... I used to be one of those guys who thought it was nearly laughable to carry a handgun when hunting with a rifle (I have hunted with a handgun before)... It just didn't add up.... why bother carrying a side arm when also carrying a high powered rifle?

Well, this is my story from deer hunting this year...

I was hunting 120 acres of some friends land in far northern MN this year, I'll call it 'the land'. I help out with the things around the land and the couple shacks, and they let me hunt. I like the arrangement, and I have my own little shack on the land (small but really nice).

I know the land and the area around it pretty well, and I am comfortable hunting alone there. There are several great blinds and stands on the 120 that they own, but there is also ~800 acres of nearly landlocked public land just behind the property to the south. The only way into this mass of public land is through a small gravel pit, just south of the land on the road. It gets very little hunting pressure.

Wolves had moved in and the deer weren’t moving on the land much. One of our hunters had a wolf on his gut pile within an hour after the kill…. In broad daylight just the day before… As a result, I decided to go hunt the public land near the gravel pit.

At about 5:05 I hear a gunshot nearby from the north..... "hmmmm.... that has to be from the land" I have to think... I wait there until after dark and see nothing. After dark I pack up my stuff and head back to the land. It is a decent walk back to the gravel pit, and a short drive back to the land from there. It is well dark before I get back.

When I get there, no one is around. I assume they are gutting/tracking a deer. I go out to the first blind and sure enough, my buddy is hanging out the window. "I got a big doe at the end of the field" he says confidently. "I shot her and she limped into the woods".

It had been maybe an hour since he shot by this time, and we decided to go find this deer now. I drove my truck to near where he said she was standing when he shot her and left the lights on the field so we could see. I grabbed a flashlight off my belt of gear that I left in the truck. About this time some of the other hunters came along and started looking with us.

One of the others was a kid of about 14 who is a little wild, but basically a good kid. He's gone through some tough times lately and being a part of this seemed like an important thing to him, so we were all glad to have him along, despite his being the least experienced and youngest hunter of our group.

We were finding NOTHING... No trace at all of this deer.... my friend stuck to his confirmation that he hit this deer (a good 200 yd + shot just at dark with a rifle he admitted he sighted in at 25 yds.... DOH!)... He is an experienced hunter, and I trusted his judgment about the shot as we ventured slightly deeper and deeper into the swamp south of the land trying to find any sign at all....

Every once in a while, the kid would holler "There's blood here", and we would pile over there to find.... nothing... and every once in a while "I can smell him"... *sheesh*... then where is 'he' kid? It's a wounded doe we're looking for...

We got out kind of far into the deep thicket of swamp brush and finally decided we needed to go back to the field and re-orient.... about this time, the kid hollers "he's right over here!!!" his headlamp bouncing through the brush as he runs towards our lights... "A big buck just snorted in my face!!" he hollers... we kind of dismiss this cause, well, he's been wrong every other time so far... lol...

We walk back out to the field and meet the others, the best light coming from my truck still idling with the lights on... We all start looking around again... just then my friends dog shows up... she must have heard us out there from the shack and run out to see what was going on... well, my friend tells me to put the dog in the truck, so I leave the window down and put her in there.

As we are walking around the dog leaps out the window and comes over to us.... then disappears into the woods... we keep looking until we are about to decide to leave and come back with better lights... then we hear the dog out in the woods barking.. knowing this to be odd my friend calls his dog back and eventually she comes... but she darts back off into the woods again, right through the thickest deepest brush in the swamp... obliged to at very least get the dog, and thinking shes on this deer, we follow in haste... keeping up with the dog is difficult with nothing but a headlamp in the thicket.. my friend keeps calling her back as we chase her and every once in a while she stops and waits just long enough for us to see her white tail jump off over the branches in the distance...

The dog runs right past the spots where the kid was saying he could smell the deer, and right past where he says it snorted in his face... DOH!!... eventually we catch up to the dog, and the big doe... pitch black, uptight dog, uptight large doe, one kid, two adults..... the doe has been gut shot and is having a hard time even standing, much less running any further... the dog is running around the doe barking and upsetting her even more... the does guts are hanging out past her knees… she couldn’t run any more if she wanted to… and she didn’t look like she wanted to anymore…

My friend gets his dog by the collar and tells me to shoot the deer...

ummmm.... I didn't bring a gun.... didn't you?.... no?.... he looks at me and says “I thought you carried that little .38 everywhere?”…. hmmmm... so did I… lol

The kid starts suggesting we cut the deers throat... which seems like a bad idea.... big does have large powerful legs with sharp hoves and sharp teeth... I would not put it past a wild animal to do anything in that situation....

My friend decides to go back and get a gun... good idea.... and take the kid and dog with him.... more good ideas.... leaving me alone in the dark with nothing but a headlamp in the wolf infested woods with a deer that smells like a fresh gut pile!!!... hmmmm... good idea???...

As soon as the dog, kid, lights, and noise were gone, the deer settled back down in front of me and lay down…. I sat down nearby with my headlamp on her and tried to be calm.. we settled in as I thought about wolves and she was just relieved that most of that was over…

I waited a long time… noticing that we were out pretty far… I couldn’t hear the guys in the field, couldn’t see any lights anywhere, couldn’t keep my mind off of hungry wolves….

Eventually I hear whistling, and whistle back…. Again and again until I can see lights coming through the woods… they get up to me… it is my friend and another of the adult hunters… they brought my .308 from the truck… at this point my friend says “You do got bullets don’t you?”…. ummmm…. Yeah, I do!!!

I put the deer down with one of them holding a light on her while I took a cranium shot. She kicked a few times and it was time to finish the gutting he started with the gun. 10 minutes later she is gutted and we are ready to drag….

Now is the time to mention that we hunt just miles north of a very large iron mine. The ferrous content of the soil is high enough that a compass is only ‘fairly accurate most of the time’. It’s really really dark out… stars are not an option under this kind of cover… My friend checks his compass and it indicates to him that we should head back in a direction 50-60 deg right of where they were coming from when I noticed them coming in with the lights… I tell him so… he is sure his compass is more right than I am and we head off dragging this large doe behind us through the thick…

After dragging for what seems forever we finally convince my friend that he might be wrong, but not that he is for sure… so he heads off into the woods content that he will find us after he finds the truck… he disappears for long enough that the other guy and I are discussing building a fire while we wait… my friend took my gun… again… wolves come to mind… fresh guts… unarmed fools… WHERE’S THAT .38 again??? Had I carried that we would have been out of the woods an hour ago or more... and I would have felt pretty safe the whole time.... *sigh*

A while later we hear the horn on the truck… then the headlights just barely through the woods… all the other guys had decided, "well, they got the deer and will be draging it back once he gets there with the gun"... so they shut off my truck, turned off the lights, and went back to the shack.... lol.... we drag this doe to the field and load her up…. She is a very large doe…

2 hours later we were eating some tasty grilled back straps and telling the story just as I told it to you here….

Man that was fun….. and that kid has a TRUE hunting story that NO ONE will believe... heck, I wouldn't if I hadn't been there.... what a ride...
 
Last edited:
Great story RR. Call me spooky, but I don't like to be alone in the woods even in broad daylight without some type of weapon ,even if its only a sharp knife.
 
Sounds like the "kid" has a great future as a deer hunter. I too have used my nose to find a wounded/dead deer after the blood ran out. Works best in the dark with the lights turned off.....just tell him not to walk in the blood after he finds it.
 
Yeah, that kid might be destined to hunting greatness... if he ever settles down enough to be able to sit still in a stand.... lol...

There were several embarrassing 'uh-oh's' in this story, not the least of which was the error of ignoring 'the kid'.... not sure how a guy can hunt his whole life and still make stupid mistakes like that, but I still manage....
 
I always carry my 9mm when hunting on my family's 200 acres. Been doing it for years and it still gets spooky at night when I'm filling the feeders or in the mornings when walking to the stand. A predator can be on you before you have time to swing your rifle around and get it in your sights. Great Story! thanks for sharing.
 
It is good that you all were determined to find the deer. In all the years of hunting we only lost one. The fellow I was with made a hasty shot, we spent most of the day looking for it. At first a small blood trail then nothing.
Down in Texas you have to watch out for the snakes and coyotes, plus the occasional rabbit!!
 
Yeah, this is also the area where I bear hunt lately. It dawned on me too, while sitting next to the live gut pile, and with the weather being so warm, that bears might not be down for the year yet either.... It was getting above 50deg every day, and I had seen bear scat earlier in the day... given that bear season was over, I never even bothered to see how fresh it was....

For some reason, I think I would rather confront a bear unarmed than a pack of hungry wolves though... at least the bear would probably make it quick if he decided to do me in... and I know he probably wouldn't, given I would be the thing darting off into the woods AWAY from the food a little faster than the headlamp should allow...

peyton said:
It is good that you all were determined to find the deer.

Well now, that's most of the adventure... yeah, the sun goes down pretty early in deer season around here, if you can't/won't track at night you have no purpose shooting after 4pm.
 
Great story! I agree that a sidearm is a very useful tool when deer hunting. A rifle is not very convenient if you have to track through woods, scrub and swamp. Especially a nice, expensive, scoped rifle.

At the opposite end of the spectrum of having rounds but no gun...one of my relatives this year shot a nice buck - right in the hind leg. This was probably about 30-50 miles south of where you were hunting.

He let it settle and then tracked it near where I was driving through deep woods. I heard the deer, settled down on a log and then heard "BOOM!", "BOOM!" from what sounded like about 50 yards away.

I gave it 15 minutes and walked over. He was standing over the deer, still kicking. I pulled out my .44 sidearm to put it down, but then it stopped moving.

I later figured out that he had hit it twice out of 4 shots. One hit the hind leg, one missed - about an hour before we ran into each other. He then sat to let it settle. He tracked it quite a ways towards me. He jumped it and shot twice near me - one shot breaking off an antler tine, one shot missing.

He later admitted that he had brought only four cartridges. He took his last two shots and came upon the deer just minutes before I did. He had disabled it with the antler shot, and proceeded to cut its throat. He had stepped back from the buck and that's what I walked upon. Hilarious.

I helped him gut it and wondered why the gutting had such a large slash at the throat, until he finally told us all the real story.

A final thought on this topic...if you CAN legally carry a sidearm in the hunting woods. Why wouldn't you?? Just be safe!
 
I've chosen to carry a .22 pistol in my pack while hunting with a large caliber rifle. There's so many things that a .22 pistol seems good for while hunting or in the woods in general. A head shot would finish a deer, for sure.
 
I've chosen to carry a .22 pistol in my pack while hunting with a large caliber rifle. There's so many things that a .22 pistol seems good for while hunting or in the woods in general. A head shot would finish a deer, for sure.



While a .22 may work for a coup de gras on a deer, it may not be legal. I know it isn't in Wisconsin....not for a LEGAL gun or bow kill. A deer finished off with a caliber not legal for hunting them is just as illegal as using said caliber for the first shot.


Ain't tryin' to be a dick, just hate to see someone to get busted for doin' somethin' foolish.
 
Not sure how that all plays into it buck, as far as MN goes the same rules apply I think.... I had to wonder that as I put that last round into that doe that night.... it was past legal shooting hours for hunting... but there is no way I was going to let that deer sit there like that till morning.... so I figured my choices were pretty slim.... shoot it, or slash it's throat, or try to break it's neck (yeah right... lol)... of all of those options, only the shooting it is legal ever, so...? what do you do? you gotta do something....
 
Buck,
That's a reasonable point. I carry it for all sorts of reasons: small game hunting in survival, the ability to distress signal repeatedly, firestarting from the powder, etc.
 
Pistol woulda been nice, I'm just glad you had the dog and didn't lose the deer. What kind of dog is it if you don't mind my asking? Are tracking dogs legal up there?
 
While a .22 may work for a coup de gras on a deer, it may not be legal. I know it isn't in Wisconsin....not for a LEGAL gun or bow kill. A deer finished off with a caliber not legal for hunting them is just as illegal as using said caliber for the first shot.


Ain't tryin' to be a dick, just hate to see someone to get busted for doin' somethin' foolish.

Isn't shooting a deer at night illegal as well? At that point, I don't think that the caliber matters, but that argument only works at night.
 
Not sure about where the OP is, but you can finish a wounded deer in Texas at night. I usually make sure the Game Warden is apprised of the situation before we start the track just to avoid misunderstandings though.
 
The dog was a mutt.... but a good one....

Running dogs on deer here is illegal, but you should note that it was not our intent to track with the dog, it escaped from the truck and took it upon itself.... there was no way we were going to ignore that the dog had found the deer.... same goes for shooting it at night, not sure of the legalities, but I was not about to let a deer suffer all night, or go to waste....
 
RockinU said:
I will never understand why it is illegal to use a dog to recover wounded deer anywhere...just such a waste.

I think the reasoning is that figuring out who is tracking wounded deer and who are just tracking deer would be difficult at best.

It would be much better if people could just be trusted wouldn't it? *sigh*
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top