Adjudication withheld causing me problems with CCW permit

Status
Not open for further replies.

docc30

Member
Joined
Feb 27, 2009
Messages
3
I'm sorry if this is long, but I wanted to give all the information I could.

Facts:

In 1991 I went through a divorce in Florida. My ex-wife filed battery charges against me. The case went before a judge and the I pleaded nolo contendere and adjudication was withheld. I served four months probation and paid a fine. I moved to Virginia in 1996. Since 2000 I have purchased two long guns and a handgun from gun shops and have always passed the background checks. This week I applied for a CCW and when I went to be fingerprinted was told by the deputy that I do not have the rights to even own firearms because of the violence against women's act http://www.letswrap.com/legal/firearms.htm

My Story about the above case:

My ex was mad at me because I would not sign over everything to her and her boyfriend. She needed leverage, so filed charges after I moved out of the house. The summons was sent to my former address and was not given to me. I was picked up on a bench warrant for being a fugitive from justice. That charge was dropped.

My attorney told me that battery was impossible to defend against because evidence was not needed and it was her word against mine. Also, I drew a judge that was unfriendly to someone facing this charge. This judge was actually removed from the bench for judicial misconduct a few years later. I took my lawyer's advice and pleaded no contest. I served probation, paid my fine, and have not been in any trouble before or since. My former attorney can be of no assistance since he was indicted for embezzlement of an elderly person's estate.

My problem:

At this point I do not care if I get the CCW or not. I do not want to lose my rights to own firearms.

Research:

From everything I can find, Adjudication Withheld with a plea of no contest in Florida means that I have not been convincted of a crime and can truthfully say that.

Florida would allow me a CCW since three years have passed. http://licgweb.doacs.state.fl.us/weapons/eligible.html

I have ordered a copy of what is left of the decision in the battery case. The original file was destroyed in 1996. I have went online and paid for the Florida criminal records check, and it came back with everything stated in the facts section of my post.

Questions:

Where do I go from here? Has anyone else had this problem, and if so how was it resolved? I was so upset about this that I could not sleep last night. I have given all this information to the Sheriff, but I don't think that's going to help. He's supposed to call me back sometime in the next week. Should I even talk to him, or should I just get an attorney that I really can't afford?

Thank you for taking the time to read this.

Michael
 
My attorney told me that battery was impossible to defend against because evidence was not needed and it was her word against mine.

Well, that's nonsence as "he said/she said" is not automatically resolved in the complainants favor. Sounds like you had a very bad lawyer, or misunderstood what he/she said, or just didn't want to pay to defend the charge. I have seen this exact scenario, and have seen the judge's staff laugh at the charges when it follows a divorce proceeding (that's such a common, cheap ploy everyone recognizes it and ignores it). Sounds like you fell pray to some bad legal advice, or you put yourself in a bad situation by ducking the service.

If you agreed to that domestic abuse case and signed off on it ("nolo contendre" does not equal "not guilty"), I don't see how you have a way out besides hiring a very expensive attorney to go back to challenge the case on the grounds the judge was dismissed. This will be long and expensive. And likely fail. Lesson: Don't sign your name to a plea that isn't true. Once you sign it, you make it true.
 
Paying wasn't a issue. I paid the lawyer $2500 to defend this charge alone (I looked it up last night). And I definitely wasn't ducking anything. My address changed because it had to, but my employment stayed the same. I followed the legal advice given to me by my lawyer, assuming that he knew more about the law than I did. I never spoke in court, he did. The prosecutor wanted to do a pre-trial intervention, but I was told that didn't happen at my ex's insistance.

What I can't figure out is that if in Florida I can say truthfully that I was never convicted of a crime, and the federal law states convicted, where the problem is. Maybe I'm over-simplifying the situation, but I just don't get it.
 
Michael, the bottom line is that you have a sticky, real life, serious legal problem. You're not going to get it fixed, if it even can be fixed, on the Internet. And your local sheriff isn't going to be much help, because that's not his job.

I'm afraid you need a qualified local lawyer.
 
/\ agreed. This is a tricky situation that only a qualified attorney can handle.
 
I posted here first because it was suggested by a friend who is a member. Thanks for taking the time to reply.

I have a call into an attorney in Florida, since he will be more familiar with Florida law. I'll just wait for him to get back to me before I do anything.
 
Contact a lawyer, try to find one that is familiar with Lautenberg. You may be facing some very bad news as for your right to keep and bear arms.

Let us know how it turns out.
 
Unfortunately, you are probably out of luck. Pleading NC to a domestic battery charge means that you cannot own firearms. Sorry. 18USC922
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top