American Eagle is Federal's budget brand ammo, and is very good quality.
There is another brand called "American" (Or Amerc) which is absolute crap - don't confuse the 2 brands.
FWIW, I bought some of the bad stuff a few years ago - the rim thickness on the .45 Colt ammo varied so much I had to pick through the whole box to find which ones would work in my SAA revolver. Some were so thick they would jam the cylinder.
They are not accurate and not reliable, at least not the stuff I had.
mark