AR15 configurable float tubes: JP VTAC vs. YHM

[usp_fan]

Title pretty much says it. I'm looking at adding a forearm kit to my 18" barreled AR and don't need four full length rails. So I'm looking at kits that give you a tube and the option to attach rails where you need/want them. JP has the neat looking VTAC and YHM has their version. Each is more affordable than the PRI offering.

Any experience or oppinions would be appreciated. Pics attached: pic 1 is the JP. Pic 2 is YHM