Armslist Missing the boat

Status
Not open for further replies.

Tabequache

Member
Joined
Oct 28, 2015
Messages
46
Location
Divide, CO
If you read Armslist's FAQ, they have a lot to say about scams by folks listing (selling) firearms. But they say little about scams or frauds perpetrated by buyers. The only advice Armslist gives, which is good advice in all cases I think, is to sell your firearms locally, in person.

In the last two years, at least four different attempts have been made by so-called buyers (all out of state) who were trying to scam me. Basically, what they try to do is get you to ship a firearm in exchange for payment which is bogus (i.e., a fake cashiers check or money order). The schemes they use are clever, often sending a copy of an FFL license of a local dealer willing to ship the gun. What happens is they send you the bogus payment, you ship the firearm, and then the payment instrument turns out to be worthless.

While I have certainly seen through the scams and not reacted, the attempts were made. In one case the buyer sent a copy of an FFL license from Nevada and copy 'n pasted my local FFL dealer's license number and information on it (much to his surprise) - saying he was the local FFL through which I could ship the firearm. We saw through that scam immediately and reported it to the BATFE, but my FFL received calls from gun sellers for 6 months afterward because the buyer apparently pulled the same scheme elsewhere.

Here are some signs to look for if you're suspicious of someone (not local) offering to buy a firearm that you've post for sale via Armslist:

1) They appear not to have read your posting; ask whether the firearm is still available; what the condition is(?) - even though this was part of your posting narrative;

2) Sometimes the sentence structure and grammar in their email is peculiar, like it was translated or written by someone who doesn't speak English;

3) Their emails are always lengthy, explaining how they will conduct a transaction with you;

4) They offer you full price, no dickering, plus shipping and want to send you a cashier's check or money order in advance;

5) They may say they can't personally accept the firearm (if you maintain that you only sell locally), but they have a local third party who will take the firearm on their behalf (could indicate organized collusion); and/or

6) They may send you an bogus FFL license with a ship-to address (as in the case described above).

All to say, "be careful" who you sell to using Armslist. I have reported these episodes to Armslist, but haven't really seen any reaction. They maintain a non-participation strategy regarding transactions. My advice (if you use Armslist) is only sell locally, in person and (I suggest) only for cash.

Notwithstanding these incidents, I have bought and sold several firearms over recent years in the Colorado Springs area, after selling or seeing guns on Armslist, to some very honest folks and have never had a problem with "local and legal" transactions. But when considering a transaction with long-distance buyers, you take your chances these days. I hopes this helps someone; sorry for the lengthy post.
 
I generally limit Armslist deals to FTF, but I have done the type of deal you describe with both buyer and seller being honest. I was buying a handgun from the other side of the state and I didn't have the time to drive there so I just sent him a check and he sent the gun to my FFL. Normally I wouldn't have been okay with that but everything about his communications was normal and the name on his email address matched a facebook account of a 3 gunner in the area and I figured I could trust him. Worked out and I got a sweet Glock, but not something I would do generally.
 
Sold and purchased several firearms via ArmsList throughout the years. I'm about to sell off 3 to 4 more to fund other purchases. Never had an issue. I get low ballers and others who come off a little shady, but they don't typically cause me any issues. I read their email, click delete, and forget about them seconds later. Soon than later, I get an interested buyer, we meet up, and make the transaction. I only do FTF cash and bill period.
 
I generally limit Armslist deals to FTF, but I have done the type of deal you describe with both buyer and seller being honest. I was buying a handgun from the other side of the state and I didn't have the time to drive there so I just sent him a check and he sent the gun to my FFL. Normally I wouldn't have been okay with that but everything about his communications was normal and the name on his email address matched a facebook account of a 3 gunner in the area and I figured I could trust him. Worked out and I got a sweet Glock, but not something I would do generally.
Lol, I do the same thing. I Google their email address, search them on social media sights, etc. Then will communicate on the phone to get a feel for them.
 
There is nothing Armslist can do to verify/certify a buyer or seller, they only have the same information that you have available on the person. How are they to determine if the seller/buyer is legit? Even e-bay makes no claims or promises on users of their services. I once bought a maintenance manual for a motorcycle I owned and after waiting over a month for the item I contacted e-bay's complaint dept about it. They wouldn't do anything when I demanded my money back, just said to wait. I'd already waited over a month and e-bay never said how long I was to wait or what they considered a sufficient wait time. I finally got the manual after 2 months.

As stated above, only sell FTF. I just sold a gun on Armslist and did it FTF with no problems, got my asking price in cash. If you take a form of payment other than cash let the buyer know that you won't ship until the payment clears the issuing bank/post office, not your bank. Problem solved, actually no problem doing it this way.
 
I've been using Armslist to buy and sell guns for years and have never had a scammer contact me. I don't bother to write "FTF only" on my ads either.

Now Craigslist on the other hand, I can expect at least one scammer to contact me whenever I try to sell something.
 
I listed once on Armslist. That was all I needed to convince me not to do it again. A prospective buyer, in state but 100 miles away, informed me I had to sell him the pistol. I had clearly stated in the ad that I would need a concealed carry permit and a DL for the transaction. He told me that by state law I had to sell him the pistol without seeing a CPL. He insisted and got down right belligerent.

The guy was a gangbanger and couldn't pass a NICS. I'm pretty sure a lot of felons use Armslist to find someone who will sell them a firearm. In this state it's now illegal to transfer without a FFL so that must have done away with a lot of FTF sales via Armslist.
 
Last edited:
So many threads about armslist...I’ve made a couple, too.

Rule #1 Personal security with online but local selling: know who’s on the other end of the email before meeting. Name, number and google it.

I had a rude felon not long ago try to badger me. Normally I would delete and carry on, but the combination of this guy’s tone and my thin skin led me to call the police.

Rule #2 Cash, mostly in $100s, before the gun leaves my possession. Yes, I’ll ship, but only after I’ve converted the money order to cash.

Rule #3 Dont feed the trolls. There are people who love to harass people online. Flagging ads because you sell too much, or won’t take their low offer, or whatever. Don’t respond, which will give them your email address, name, etc. Just delete.
 
How do you get a physical location for an email address? Just this week, I was dealing with a guy about his Armslist ad. The listing indicated he was nearby. When he learned I was close & we could do a deal FTF, communication ended. I tried to find out where he really was located ( figuring he was a scammer ), but couldn't figure out how.

Tuckerdog1
 
Goes without saying,,,, They send you the payment, you confirm payment, then you ship.
Even in addition to this make sure the check actually clears in your account and let the buyer know you are waiting till it does to ship.

What happens is they send a bogus cashier's check etc and person takes it to the bank who cashes it and gives you the money. 5-10 days later you hear from the bank the check was returned and you are out the money

I generally avoid Armslist and stick to more local sites like Pennswoods in my area to sell. I have bought one and sold two on Armslist ftf with no issues.

Most of my buying and selling is done on forums. You still have to be careful with newer members without feedback and realize anything can happen but I have never been burned. The feedback system some sites use is really useful and I will only buy something if it is well vetted. Even then I still never use PayPal f&f so I have recourse if needed. I don't mind paying the extra fee for peace of mind if I use Paypal
 
Even in addition to this make sure the check actually clears in your account and let the buyer know you are waiting till it does to ship.

What happens is they send a bogus cashier's check etc and person takes it to the bank who cashes it and gives you the money. 5-10 days later you hear from the bank the check was returned and you are out the money

I generally avoid Armslist and stick to more local sites like Pennswoods in my area to sell. I have bought one and sold two on Armslist ftf with no issues.

Most of my buying and selling is done on forums. You still have to be careful with newer members without feedback and realize anything can happen but I have never been burned. The feedback system some sites use is really useful and I will only buy something if it is well vetted. Even then I still never use PayPal f&f so I have recourse if needed. I don't mind paying the extra fee for peace of mind if I use Paypal
Banks I've always dealt with will put a hold on the funds until everything is verified and before allowing me to cash out. This usually take about 2-3 business days. If anything is wrong with the check, it'll usually will come to fruition during the holding period. I've never heard of a bank coming back several days later.

In any event, I'd only accept money orders, and not personal checks. The buyer can't claim that the check was stolen or file a claim against the check afterwards.
 
Everything was normal (like at a gun show) in all 12 Armslist transactions. Each was FTF/in person, daytime etc. If you don't have both really good intuition and common sense, and your communications are vague and wishy washy, avoid Armslist.

*** "out of state":......There was only a single odd e-mail responder, and the very brief, unusual writing style indicated some real Impatience.
It was in regard to my ad for a WW2 Mauser Hsc handgun. He asked no questions about matching parts, wanted no extra photo, and Most Of All, asked whether I would ship it to a Florida FFL. This ignored my terms, which are always very firm.

I knew that this was strange and it kind of irritated me. A milsurp friend knew it wasn't right. Any cashier's check etc would have bounced.

Don't misunderstand this. I've had almost no chances to find interest at local guns shows for any guns I've carried around. About the only exception was last Saturday, a very used CZ PO1.

In stark contrast (Very stark) to some reports out there, Armslist has been a Dynamite resource--there is nothing else Local which could produce a fraction of my deals--and local people who accept your price simply want to sell or buy another gun, often a milsurp, seldom seen in gun shops (my two beautiful EG Makarovs, Yugo Mauser etc).
 
Last edited:
Even in addition to this make sure the check actually clears in your account and let the buyer know you are waiting till it does to ship.

What happens is they send a bogus cashier's check etc and person takes it to the bank who cashes it and gives you the money. 5-10 days later you hear from the bank the check was returned and you are out the money

I generally avoid Armslist and stick to more local sites like Pennswoods in my area to sell. I have bought one and sold two on Armslist ftf with no issues.

Most of my buying and selling is done on forums. You still have to be careful with newer members without feedback and realize anything can happen but I have never been burned. The feedback system some sites use is really useful and I will only buy something if it is well vetted. Even then I still never use PayPal f&f so I have recourse if needed. I don't mind paying the extra fee for peace of mind if I use Paypal

Paypal doesn’t allow gun sales. You can use them, but if there’s a problem I wouldn’t count on them resolving it for you.
 
Paypal doesn’t allow gun sales. You can use them, but if there’s a problem I wouldn’t count on them resolving it for you.
Yea... I've heard of them freezing funds and canceling accounts over it. I've only done it once, but that was with a long time forum member with excellent pics and communication, and Market Place rating.
 
Paypal doesn’t allow gun sales. You can use them, but if there’s a problem I wouldn’t count on them resolving it for you.
parts and accessories are fine. I dont put much info in, but others that have been burned on things like optics and parts have filed disputes and won
 
Banks I've always dealt with will put a hold on the funds until everything is verified and before allowing me to cash out. This usually take about 2-3 business days. If anything is wrong with the check, it'll usually will come to fruition during the holding period. I've never heard of a bank coming back several days later.

In any event, I'd only accept money orders, and not personal checks. The buyer can't claim that the check was stolen or file a claim against the check afterwards.
I worked at a bank right after college and funds were released the next day. Scammers used to run a scam on college students were they would offer them a "job" and send like a $2500 check to them. They would then contact them immediately and say they only meant to send $500 and ask them to deposit the check, keep $500 and send 2k back. The funds would clear the next day and they would send the 2k back. When the check is returned a few days later they are now out the 2k and the scammer has it. They would also encourage them to deposit the check in an atm or by phone with a picture. I stopped this a few times when the checks were actually brought in, but also had to deal the ones who got scammed. College kids can be gullible
 
The one you are posting about has been going one for awhile. The deal with it is the payment bounces after 10 days or so. I don't understand why the guy doesn't clean up the English so it sounds better. They run the same thing on craigslist.

The ones I have noticed on Armslist lately have been ones more appearing to be fishing for information. I had one where a guy is selling a
Arsenal (Bulgaria) SLR-107CR AK47 $650.
I emailed the guy and never got a response the emailed again. The second time I got " Where are you located, how would you like to complete this transaction?"
Like a dummy I responded. Never heard back.
My own opinion is it is someone or a group getting information on people who are on Armslist. They get your IP they get a lot of information on you.

I also had to sell a lot of guns at one time due to loss of a job. Every time I posted a gun for sale the same guy offered to buy it within 5 minutes of posting. And I mean every single time. I sold him one gun, but he posted it for sale at a higher price the very same day. Never responded or sold him anything ever again.
He had a very unique way he listed and put pictures of guns he sold and hasn't posted in a long time. Always wondered if he got a visit from ATF? I am sure they watch Armslist. I know for a fact they keep track of Gunbroker.
 
I listed once on Armslist. That was all I needed to convince me not to do it again. A prospective buyer, in state but 100 miles away, informed me I had to sell him the pistol. I had clearly stated in the ad that I would need a concealed carry permit and a DL for the transaction. He told me that by state law I had to sell him the pistol without seeing a CPL. He insisted and got down right belligerent.

The guy was a gangbanger and couldn't pass a NICS. I'm pretty sure a lot of felons use Armslist to find someone who will sell them a firearm. In this state it's now illegal to transfer without a FFL so that must have done away with a lot of FTF sales via Armslist.

I had one like this. He wasn't a gangbanger, but I think he was a few French fries short of his Happy Meal. I met him in person and he seemed a little weird, but a lot of gun people, honestly, are a little weird. He had a goofy drop holster and vest with him, and he claimed he was looking to buy my gun (Beretta 92) as a new duty pistol and that he worked for DHS. I started to smell a rat, because I don't believe any federal LE purchase their own duty pistols (lots of local agencies, of course, do just that). Then he said he had forgotten his permit to carry at home. I said no big deal, you're in town, we can just meet up later when you have it.

Later on I got a whacko e-mail saying that he had decided not to go through with the purchase because I didn't know that as a "federal law enforcement officer" he didn't have to abide by Minnesota's purchase requirements for handguns.

I sent him a polite e-mail back calling him a dirty and inept liar.
 
Yeesh.

I was thinking of dipping my toes in the armslist game to try and move a few guns to finance a new .308 AR.

But maybe not.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top