I don't have a single .357 rifle. I have three lever guns in 45 Colt. The Rossi is the lightest and least accurate. Quantify that with it is more than accurate enough. I hate the safety so I removed it. Hated the sights so I removed them too. It is smooth, although I did take it apart and polished those parts that touched. Does eject well when it's below zero. I take it out to shoot the most.
I have a Uberti 1873. The heaviest and most accurate of my three 45 Colt Rifles. It is the smoothest by far. No mods and I get scared taking it out that I might be a scratch on it. Best fit and finish and workmanship.
1894 Marlin. I like this rifle. It is made a Remington. Got it in 2018. Not as smooth as the other two. It is more accurate than the Rossi and not as much as the 1873. Again keep in mind that the degrees of differences in accuracy are minor. I hate the freaking bar code on the receiver. Fit is better than my Marlin Made 1895. Especially metal to wood. The bluing isn't.
My Dad has a Henry Golden Boy. He has never shot it. I have. No side loading. It wouldn't feed some of my reloads, they were too long, but the same rounds did feed on all my other 45 Colt rifles, plus a pistol. Pretty rifle. I don't like the lack of history for them. But it is nice and then some. Seemed heavier than my 1873.
The Rossi goes out most often so I would say by that, it is my favorite. I did take the opportunity to fix the things I didn't like about it. Keep in mind I have 45 Colt and not .357 rifles.