usmarine0352_2005
member
- Joined
- Oct 21, 2005
- Messages
- 2,796
.
(This is with under the premise that we get a positive outcome out of McDonald v. Chicago.)
Now, most likely we won't be getting an outcome on what level of scrutiny is applied, that is for another day. But simply saying that it is ruled that the 2nd Amendment applies to the states.......
What is the more important victory:
1.) Heller v. DC
2.) McDonald v. Chicago
It is sort of what came first situation, the chicken or the egg.
Yes, Heller affirmed that the 2nd Amendment gives the people the right to keep and bear arms....in a Federal Enclave.
If McDonald affirms that the 2nd Amendment applies to the states that is also extremely valuable.
What are your thoughts?
(This is with under the premise that we get a positive outcome out of McDonald v. Chicago.)
Now, most likely we won't be getting an outcome on what level of scrutiny is applied, that is for another day. But simply saying that it is ruled that the 2nd Amendment applies to the states.......
What is the more important victory:
1.) Heller v. DC
2.) McDonald v. Chicago
It is sort of what came first situation, the chicken or the egg.
Yes, Heller affirmed that the 2nd Amendment gives the people the right to keep and bear arms....in a Federal Enclave.
If McDonald affirms that the 2nd Amendment applies to the states that is also extremely valuable.
What are your thoughts?