I have a rifle with an aluminum receiver and the anodizing was more red/orange than black. Researching online there were the options of dismantling the gun and have the part anodized (very costly), painting it with matt black Hi-temp paint (a little on the short-life span) or using Birchwood Casey Aluminum Black (time consuming). I did a quick clean and apply of blacking solution and wasn't happy at all. Then I tried sanding off the old anodizing (to bare aluminum) on a test spot and doing the clean and solution steps. After about 4 light applications, I had a nice black aluminum finish. It's a bit of slow work to sand (multiple grits) and apply at least 4 cycles of cleaning and solution but I have 2 sides of the receiver done. It's not quite the same as the anodized part but a lot better than it was.