Book Review: Mas Ayoob's "StressFire"

Status
Not open for further replies.

roo_ster

Member
Joined
Oct 2, 2003
Messages
3,352
Location
USA
I went to the gun show as a favor to a buddy, not intending to do anything but help him sell his Knoxx Sidewinder & two mags, when I stumbled on three tomes I have been meaning to acquire:
StressFire
StressFire II (Shotgun)
No Second Place Winner (Bill Jordan)


My Background
I am not a guy with "decades of experience in military, law enforcement, etc." I spent a few years at Ft Benning playing Foolish Ranger Games at the behest of Uncle Sam and on your dollars. I expended a LOT of ordnance and dollars training. Thing is, most of it was with a rifle & carbine and very little with pistols. Also, the emphasis and objectives were different from those that armed civilians (LEO or otherwise) would find most likely. I have worked to rectify that situation since leaving Uncle Sam's payroll, but I am always on the look out for enlightenment when it comes to keeping my self & family safe & sound.


Mini-Review
StreeFire is MA's 1984 book detailing, wonder of wonders, his StressFire approach to gunfighting. The emphasis is on simplicity of technique and harnessing the body's reaction to fight-or-flight level stress. My purpose is not to pan it if it does not fit my preconception or pump it if it is in line with MY One True Technique. Rather, I aim to give a brief synopsis and comment on the SF approach and contemporary applicability.

SF does pan a few older, preceding techniques, but is pretty tolerant toward Cooper & post-Cooper developments. Although it emphasizes the basic SF Isosceles, it incorporates Weaver and quasi-Weaver holds/stances as well as some modified unarmed martial arts techniques/principles. SF gives short shrift to various competition-derived techniques, but, in my experience, contemporary IPSC/IDPA competition seems to have incorporated many of SF's principles, deliberately or otherwise, making the critiques less valid.

As important as particular techniques is SF's emphasis on mindset and stress. It is assumed that stress at the time of a life-threatening situation will cause particular reactions to the participants. The SF approach seeks to use that as an advantage rather than as something to fight through. To both acclimate one to the expected stress and to gain an advantage from the effects, SF suggests maximizing one's perception of what is at stake, even on the square range. This is done by wagers, self-imposed monetary penalties for poor performance, and many other means to raise the stakes and stress while training with one's firearms.

The book is spare and not overly wordy and the illustrations do just that: illustrate execution of SF technique. It is an easy read and the lack of PC is refreshing.


What I Got Out of It
The technique was sound and entirely defensible and would make a solid base, were one to master it. The technique, however, was probably third on my (personal) list of What I Got Out Of Reading StressFire. Second-place, was a refresher on the effects of life/death, fight-or-flight stress on your person. The most important bit I gleaned out of SF was to make my trips to the range count and to up the stress level when there. Blasting rounds downrange is fun, but time and ammunition is too hard-bought and my skills too atrophied and perishable to make that the sole objective.


Conclusion
Well-worth the retail price. I would recommend it as a step after learning basic gun handling skills or as a refresher for those (like myself) who have let their skills slip. A ratio of 10:1 dry fire practice at home to range time would bring a good return on one's time investment.


Market For Classic Gunny Books
Before I finish, let me expound upon the market for these books as well as other classic gunfighting, reloading, shooting, etc. books. I am a dyed-in-the-wool cheapskate, when it comes to books. If it isn't half-price off, I am not interested (with VERY few exceptions). I have haunted used book stores, abebooks.com, ebay, etc. and you just can't find these classics at less than retail. You're lucky if you pay only retail. That is the market reality.
 
Let's see, 1984. Kinda ancient history in some ways. A lot of things have happened since then, a lot of evolution has taken place. Thought, training and techniques have come a long way in some ways.

In 1984, 1st SFOD-D was 5 years old, having gone active in 1979. In 1984 I was working alongside a few of the folks who had been part of Blue Light, the internal 5th SFG antiterrorist establishment set up as an interim force for the two years COL Beckwith had asked for to get his organization on its feet. A lot of those Blue Light folks had history in MACV-SOG, and had incorporated their training, skills and experience into the training program they set up at Mott Lake, with a lot of AT-specific stuff added.

My point is, this was the literal bleeding edge of small arms tactics at the time, and there was a LOT of emphasis on the pistol. It is the nature of things that over time the 'oil spot' spreads, and these tactics and techniques have become a larger part of the training world beyond the double chain-link fences and guard shacks on twisty turny access roads.

But that wasn't so much the case in 1984. And still the techniques demonstrated in StressFire can pretty much hold their own. Not a lot of us are ever going to be called on to deliver skill levels equivalent to the 'kickers and shooters' who do it for a living, of course. But that shouldn't keep any of us from striving to attain a level of training and ability that makes us more than a match for any predator we encounter in the course of our normal lives.

StressFire is indeed a classic, a foundational book in the school of gunfighting. There are some people for whom some- or maybe even many- of the specific techniques included are not going to work well. But developing a personal repertoire of handgun skills means exposing yourself to a lot of material, and choosing/practicing/employing what what works best for you. Ayoob broke some new ground in 1984 with StressFire for cops and armed citizens, and its importance shouldn't be ignored just because a couple of decades have gone by since it first hit print.

Good review, jfruser. Thanks for posting it.

lpl/nc
 
Mas is one of my favorite gun writers. IMHO, everyone who has a CCW should read In The Gravest Extreme. Others by Ayoob:


Armed and Alive (1979)
Ayoob Files: The Book (1995)
Ayoob on Firearms (year unknown)
Fundamentals of Modern Police Impact Weapons (1996)
Gun Digest Book of SIG-Sauer: A Complete Look at SIG-Sauer Pistols (2004)
Gunproof Your Children / Handgun Primer (1986)
Handgun Primer (1986)
Hit The White Part (1986) (on bowling pin shooting)
In The Gravest Extreme (1980)
LFI Handgun Safety (year unknown)
Physio-Psychological Aspects of Violent Encounters (year unknown)
Police Survival Shooting (How Close is too Close) (year unknown)
Post Shooting Trauma (year unknown)
The Complete Book of Handguns (1998–2001)
The Experts Speak Out: The Police View of Gun Control (1981)
The Gun Digest Book of Combat Handgunnery (with Chuck Taylor, 2002)
The Semi-Automatic Pistol in Police Service and Self Defense (1987)
The Stressfire series, three volumes: Handgun (1986), Shotgun (1992), Rifle (year unknown)
The Truth About Self-Protection (1983)
 
Agree, and good review.

Lee, it sounds like you and I were running in similar circles back in the late 70' and early 80's. An interesting time when we squids learned how to walk on dirt and the blanketheads learned how to swim. We both already knew how to fly.

In our line of work back then, the pistol was extremely important. It was often the first thing you poked over the roof of a building you just scaled, or a boat you just boarded. Small and far more wieldy than even the sub Uzis and MP5s of the time, we learned to trust our lives to the skill, confidence and competence we'd gained with our sidearms.

On a traditional battlefield, your sidearm wasn't for much. But we never saw traditional battlefields. Wasn't our theatre of operations.

I've always enjoyed Mas' writings and have never failed to recommend them. Earlier in the year, I had made a comment regard Mr. Ayoob based upon erroneous information. It opened up a dialogue between Mr. Ayoob and myself and my respect for the man only increased.

http://www.thefiringline.com/forums/showthread.php?t=284241

Mas Ayoob is definitely on our side, the side of law and order, and the side of peaceful co-existence through strength, training and preparedness.

Jeff
 
Tex,

I wouldn't consider what I was doing as "running." Unless running a library counts :D .

lpl/nc (hey, Special Forces soldiers have homework when they're in school too)
 
How about the idea you should let people shoot at a target a few feet to your right or left, just so you will be able to "stay calm" under fire?
:uhoh:
 
How about the idea you should let people shoot at a target a few feet to your right or left, just so you will be able to "stay calm" under fire?

__________________

Not on my watch, Harley.:)

Fellas, thanks for the kind words. Glad you found the book useful.
 
having read all of MA's books and branching out from there, i can only say i have a lot of respect for the man's insight and ability to share important knowledge.

thanks!
 
Mas's books and courses should be the starting point for anyone interested in defensive shooting.

Before one knows how to shoot defensively, one needs to know when to shoot defensively.
 
I have read a couple of them. Pretty darn readable on top of the good information.
 
Massad Ayoob,

Thanks for answering my post, many may get it, while more will not:)

I agree with the post about your book that was written back in the early 80's "In The Gravest Extreme"... One of several I read and feel all who carry, for whatever reason should read. "All" being the common denominator here.

It is a classic. The time frame was perfect, pre Glock. Need to update it and keep it in every location, as a personal service to the public that admires you.

The "Onion Field" story was a tragic event, one I knew very well...

This review is good, so I thought I would add it here:

http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m1510/is_n77/ai_12919685

Personal responsibility (self) is overlooked so much in our society, you are one who seems to understand that much more than others who play in the same sandbox ;)

Regards,
Gary A. Brewer
 
I've read "Stressfire" several times, and also find "In the Gravest Extreme" to be the overall best book on the role of the gun in self defense. I've given my son, a college student majoring in Homeland Security, copies of both "Stressfire" and "In the Gravest Extreme."

Thanks to jfruser for a well written review, and thanks to Mr. Ayoob for years of contribution to both the law enforcement community and the average citizen.
 
Thanks DrBoomBoom for your comments to clarify something, I might have missed.

I have applied the techs of the book "Stress fire" for so long it is like I must have invented it :D Why I like the idea of Glock 17's and Hi Cap mags:)

I was retired from LEO, before the book was written :D

http://www.nononsenseselfdefense.com/NNSDstressfire1full.htm

The book is 21 years old...As other things in that era, we have left a lot of it and gone into a different time and place. Both of the books have been mentioned by DrBoomBoom and should be in ones library for sure.

The information is good, to be able to think it, you have to live it, and to live it, "is not stress free" :uhoh: Once you become what the book "Stress Fire" talks about "Stress" the situation that might occur is much easier to handle, for sure, and to make sure you handled it correctly you should read the book "In the Gravest Extreme first...After all it was written "First".

http://www.gunsholstersandgear.com/...a-gun-for-home-protection-or-concealed-carry/

Again thanks to Massad for answering me.


Regards.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top