I’m in the market for a Commander length 1911 in .45ACP. I have (2) 1911s from Kimber (a 5” Stainless & a 3” Ultra CDP) & would seriously consider a Pro Carry, but I’d like to go with a true Commander-length 4.25” barrel. I’d also prefer an alloy frame.
From what I can see, my options are pretty much as follows:
All 3 seem to be about the same street price – mid to high $700s. The Colt has a SS slide & ambi safeties. The S&W has a scandium frame & an external extractor. The Para has their new Power Extractor. All 3 manufacturers offer a Lifetime Service policy; I don’t know what Colt & Para are like to work with but S&W is pretty good. I know the Para has a FLGR, I don’t know about the Smith.
Are there any suggestions on which to go with? I have S&W guns, my older revolvers are of better quality than the newer models but I know little of the 1911 guns. I have a Mustang Pocket Lite, it is the only experience I have with Colt. I have no experience at all with Para.
What would you (or did you) go with? Or, am I being silly wanting the extra ¼” in barrel length & consider a Kimber & SA?
From what I can see, my options are pretty much as follows:
- Para LTC
- Colt Lightweight Commander
- S&W SW1911PD
All 3 seem to be about the same street price – mid to high $700s. The Colt has a SS slide & ambi safeties. The S&W has a scandium frame & an external extractor. The Para has their new Power Extractor. All 3 manufacturers offer a Lifetime Service policy; I don’t know what Colt & Para are like to work with but S&W is pretty good. I know the Para has a FLGR, I don’t know about the Smith.
Are there any suggestions on which to go with? I have S&W guns, my older revolvers are of better quality than the newer models but I know little of the 1911 guns. I have a Mustang Pocket Lite, it is the only experience I have with Colt. I have no experience at all with Para.
What would you (or did you) go with? Or, am I being silly wanting the extra ¼” in barrel length & consider a Kimber & SA?