Loosedhorse
member
So, you mean that a high-velocity penetrating missile to the brain represents the same mechanism of injury as a punch to the jaw causing no bone fracture?You're incorrect. The mechanism is direct trauma to the brain.
Hmmm. Obviously not a student of good abdominal blows and their effects. Perhaps you also believe that when a man is incapacitated by a solid blow to the testes, it's because he hits his head (cranium) when he falls?The boxer falls down and either hits is head or his head violently moves from the impactYou're saying that the incapacitation produced by a good boxer's body punch is due to "blood loss"? Or you haven't addressed that question?
And in any case, unless the wound-tract-only theory says I shouldn't use the 125gr HP in .357 that the Evan Marshall recommends, what difference does it make?
I've read Marshall and Sanow, I've read MacPherson. One says the .38 Special FBI load shouldn't have worked, one says the 9mm ISP load shouldn't have. But both worked. And today, you can load Gold Dot or DPX with either. Big debate!