• You are using the old High Contrast theme. We have installed a new dark theme for you, called UI.X. This will work better with the new upgrade of our software. You can select it at the bottom of any page.

Flitz on a old blue gun? just a thought

Mark_Mark

Member
Joined
Jan 9, 2021
Messages
18,165
Would you Flitz polish a old 1900’s blued gun? or keep it original ? it’s only $150 but works

68E9781E-DF70-408D-8248-C76DA243E640.jpeg
 
Collectors prefer original patina. I had a WW1 1911 that a guy had had refinished. Because of that I paid about 25% of what it'd be worth if he hadn't refinished it.
 
I would keep it as it is. A 1900 vintage gun could be worth a lot more, if not maybe tomorrow. What gave you the idea it is only $150?
I paid $150 a week ago… they have 2 more Smith in better condition $175 and $200 respectively. They made millions of these, thought if I Flitz polish it, it might be a cool BBQ gun
 
I've tried waxing guns with Renaissance Wax. Seems Renaissance Wax works great on leather holsters but wasn't worth the time for me on guns to do it twice. A cotton cloth an a few drops of good gun oil.
 
Looks nice for the age. I wouldn't mess with the finish. If you have rust on the finish, which I don't see I would us a Big 45 pad. It will remove rust bu not he actual finish or blueing. GREAT product. Get it here from the original manufacturer.
 
Parkerized Colt with 27K through it. Carried frequently in a leather holster over five years (no Kydex). Soft cotton cloth with a quality gun oil after each use.

2OlWsm4h.jpg
 
Looks nice for the age. I wouldn't mess with the finish. If you have rust on the finish, which I don't see I would us a Big 45 pad. It will remove rust bu not he actual finish or blueing. GREAT product. Get it here from the original manufacturer.
that’s pad is impressive
 
I've tried waxing guns with Renaissance Wax. Seems Renaissance Wax works great on leather holsters but wasn't worth the time for me on guns to do it twice. A cotton cloth an a few drops of good gun oil.
I use Renaissance wax for protection on blued and stainless firearms. It's not a cleaner. My issue with oil is it can dry and get gummy when guns are in storage.
I've never tried Renaissance, though it gets good reviews here on THR. I use Mother's... the shipping fee is a lot cheaper at Autozone.
Not sure what variety of "Mother"s" you're using. Mag and Aluminum Polish is mildly abrasive. I use it sparingly on stainless and with great care on blued. Renaissance is not abrasive, mostly a protectant. Do not use it on semi auto slides. Ask me how I know that is a bad idea.
 
I just clean the forcing cone and cylinder front with Hoppe's. The crud is going to return as soon as you shoot it again. Johnson's paste wax has been my exterior protector since the late '60's and has eliminated any rust issues. Not saying you should change your procedures, only stating what has worked for me for a very long time.
 
Last edited:
I just clean the forcing cone and cylinder front with Hoppe's. The crud is going to return as soon as you shoot it again. Johnson's paste wax has been my exterior protector since the late '60's and has eliminated any rust issues. Not saying you should change your procedures, only atating what has worked for me for a very long time.
Never tried Gun Wax before!
 
I use Renaissance wax for protection on blued and stainless firearms. It's not a cleaner. My issue with oil is it can dry and get gummy when guns are in storage.

Not sure what variety of "Mother"s" you're using. Mag and Aluminum Polish is mildly abrasive. I use it sparingly on stainless and with great care on blued. Renaissance is not abrasive, mostly a protectant. Do not use it on semi auto slides. Ask me how I know that is a bad idea.
I use Renaissance wax for protection on blued and stainless firearms. It's not a cleaner. My issue with oil is it can dry and get gummy when guns are in storage.

Not sure what variety of "Mother"s" you're using. Mag and Aluminum Polish is mildly abrasive. I use it sparingly on stainless and with great care on blued. Renaissance is not abrasive, mostly a protectant. Do not use it on semi auto slides. Ask me how I know that is a bad idea.
Oils do do get dry and gummy when the guns are in storage. That's I reason I changed from oil to grease as a lube years ago.
 
Those grips are glaringly, obviously not original to the gun. They look almost new while the rest of the gun obviously isn't. Do with it whatever you want. It's your gun.
They made millions of these,
No, they made thousands.
they have 2 more Smith in better condition $175 and $200 respectively.
Two more like that one? In better condition? You better find a way to snap them up tomorrow.
 
Many years back while working as a patrol officer I had a partner that was truly OCD relative to the cleanliness of his duty weapon.........in those days the polish used for our nickeled guns was semi chrome..........works well, but just like flitz its mildly abrasive..........well, good buddy traded off his nickeled piece and acquired a nice #27........blued, applied his same obsessive routine to that S&W and in relatively short order found he was really thinning the blue! Course that find resulted in a new carry piece, but that was always his compulsion anyway.

Moral being that those polishes WILL wear away finish....good for touch ups on occasion (holster scratches of minor nature) but you should tread lightly in applying them.
 
Back
Top