Forster 3 in 1, what say you.

Status
Not open for further replies.

Furncliff

Member
Joined
Dec 10, 2005
Messages
2,217
Location
Western Slope of Colorado
An M1 Carbine is waiting for me at my FFL, I've been looking forward to having one for a while. I'm ordering reloading equipment and want to get your advice on the Forster 3 in 1 that fits on the Forster Original. This would cost me about double what pilots, collets and a de-burring tool would be. I figure the labor savings will be worth it. This will be the only rifle caliber I reload for.

I already have the Forster Original, bought it at a tag sale $12.00.
 
Last edited:
If you have pilots and collets or whatever the Foster uses, why do you need the 3+1?

Unless you plan on prepping thousands of cases, just deburr chamfer with a hand tool especially if it is your only caliber.

I have a 3/1 for 223 on my RCBS but not for the 30 carbine, don't shoot that much of it. It does save time and I am lazy!
 
Rule 3 thanks for the reply, I don't have the correct pilot and collets, or a deburr/chmafer tool. Just a way to partially justify the purchase of the 3 in 1. I just had my second knee replaced and it reminds me that all my joints are reaching their TBO, so there's a savings in that regard.
 
Well I can feel you pain, I just had my second shoulder rotator cuff and other assorted spurs and tendons done.;)

Does these Forster use a shell holder? You would need that also, I guess it comes with the pilot?? Check on that.

It is up to you it is an very good part but expensive,and good only for the 30 cal, it is carbide so should last forever. A simple deburring tool is cheap.

http://www.midwayusa.com/product/789334/le-wilson-chamfer-and-deburring-tool-17-to-45-caliber

http://www.midwayusa.com/product/364181/forster-chamfer-and-deburring-tool-17-to-45-caliber
 
Furncliff, funny, I literally just walked in from the garage, where I was ..... trimming 30 Carbine cases with a Forster Original and ..... a 3-in-1 trimmer attachment.

I seem to do episodic batch reloading with the 30 carbine (own two rifles, shoot occasionally but when I do, I am not shy about emptying up to 5 or 6 boxes' worth of it). It's been a while since I trimmed the cases.

But for me, the 3-in-1 is worth it. If you plan to 1) shoot a reasonably large amount of that caliber and 2) you plan to reload it for a few years at least, I'd say it's well worth it.

I will soon start using the 3-in-1 to trim 30-06 cases for Garand reloading. Unfortunately the 3-in-1 requires a longer base than the standard Original one, so I just bought one of those.

The efficiency of that one brief operation using the 3-in-1 (I use a power drill and the power attachment) that trims, deburs, and chamfers all at once really does add up. I set my calipers to my "max" case length that I want for 30 Carbine (usually 1.289), quickly check each case against that. Those that pass go into the "ready" bin, the others get the quick trim and then into that bin. I can prep a lot of brass in very little time that way.

Forster, like every other reloading equipment company I've dealt with so far, has been very good with support. I have a batch of never-used Lake City 30 Carbine brass of which a few cases had smaller-than-spec internal diameter. One of them got stuck on the 3-in-1 pilot. Sent it in along with a few other cases from that batch, Forster examined everything, removed the stuck case, and advised about the internal diameter issue. I belled all the LC cases after resizing, using the press charging die, and no more stuck cases (I expect the cases to be normal after one loading and firing).
 
If you are processing more that 100 cases at a time there is nothing like the 3in1 Forster trimmer. One step and the case is ready to load. It's amazing!!! Like said above, the 30-06 needs the longer trimmer but the .223 and .308 fit fine.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top