Vote: buy yourself something <$500 and use the rest to pay off the debt.
Budgeting is hard. Believe me, I struggle to get myself within budget most months and don't succeed as often as I should. But I firmly believe that the way to make a budget work is to (1) make it realistic and (2) reserve some money every pay period for fun stuff -- like guns!
IMHO unless you have willpower as strong as the armor on a M1A Abrams MBT, any budget that does not set aside a reasonable amount of money for "fun" stuff will not work. You work hard for your money and you deserve to enjoy the fruits of your labor. If you don't account for that factor, your attempts to budget will be fruitless as you will constantly blow your budget -- and what's the point of having a budget in the first place if you're gonna do that?
But as others have pointed out, debt reduction is a very wise decision. Debt chains you down -- for example, it's much harder to quit your job when you've got a mountain of debt as the Sword of Damocles hanging over you. And if I read your post right, a significant portion of your debt is credit card debt. Unless you got one of those fixed interest cards/deals, you're looking at ~20% APR?
Get rid of that debt fast!
I'm now debt free as well, although I don't own a house or car. It took me ~5 years to pay off all my student loans, which according to my last Dept of Education statement was over $126,000. And that doesn't include my private student loans. But the day I made the last payment, it was like Sisyphus finally pushed the rock to the top of the mountain.
So to reiterate, pay down the debt as fast as you can, but do not set an unrealistic schedule or budget -- because chances are that you won't follow it and the whole concept of a budget goes to waste.
Justin