• You are using the old High Contrast theme. We have installed a new dark theme for you, called UI.X. This will work better with the new upgrade of our software. You can select it at the bottom of any page.

Grave or foxhole, version 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Political correctness can be good as well as bad, and barring a takeover of the US (also far-fetched, though the Mexicans are getting in plenty of free practice) I don't see the world's only superpower committing wholesale mass murder on its own citizens anytime soon.

It's not that the image itself isn't poignant, it's just that the message reaches a lot more people, who will probably remember it far better and look upon it more favorably, if it deals with ordinary self-defense scenarios instead of the concept of having to go for the e-tool and hunker down for a firefight.

This just isn't something that speaks to the everyman.
 
Botched SWAT raids are one thing, but I think that genocide in the US is a wee bit far-fetched.
That depends on your definition of genocide. Private prisons are a quickly growing industry. When lots of prisoners starts to be seen as an asset instead of a burden to society, people will be looking for more ways get them, instead of ways to reduce them. This will mean stricter sentencing, more felonies, and little incentive to reduce the problem.
When in prisons people are housed in a place where the majority have hepatitis, many have HIV, and a large percent other pathogens and anyone entering is more likely to leave with one or more than not...

Combine the two, is that not a subtle genocide.

What about when having an arm is illegal or subjects you to laws that could cause you to enter that enviroment?

Genocides don't always happen obviously. In fact even in Nazi Germany most were simply worked to death, not killed outright until near the end of the war. What if thier crime was not so easily identifiable like being Jewish. Many others suffered the same fate as "political prisoners". It is easy to see it was wrong when it included cultural or racial lines, but if you take that out of the equation it would be much harder to see it for what it was. What if all had been charged with a crime, and were not of a specific race or culture? What if they just all believed in a different form of government, or thought it was okay to have arms, or lived a certain lifestyle?
Many others were killed in the same way, but we focus on the Jews because that is the easiest persecuted group to show the policies of the Nazi were evil. Otherwise you would have to judge it on an individual basis. Because working criminal prisoners hard, and being low on supplies like food in war times for them would otherwise not have been such an obvious crime. Executing prisoners for treason or other crimes, instead of for being Jews would not have been so obviously wrong for outsiders to judge. Had they never been conquered many would never have known, and it could have been covered up, just a rumor to fade away by some conspiracy nuts. In fact in Western Germany it was considered just that at the time, some conspiracy theory exagerating events.

Most Germans, most German soldiers, and even many of the Nazis were unaware of the nature of the camps or what went on there. Just like you don't even know what goes on at a federal super max facility in this country unless the media is given a tour. Outside of the Gestapo, and the SS the actual details were not widespread. The only publicized camps were very lush detention facilities, the name of the most famous of such escapes me, but it was more of a resort for criminals. Many Germans never knew more than just general persecution was going on.

Stalin killed many more, yet it was not done to a specific persecuted group in a country that would be overthrown and therefore its secrets reveled for others to judge and punish. Only the sheer volumes of people killed in fact even bring attention to it. If he had just killed several million less it might not even have been noticed. He used secret police, most victims were guilty of a crime, even if it was a BS crime, it was a legitimate crime against the soviet legislation. So most vanished without notice or publicity, and they were after all criminals so it deserved little attention. They didn't storm down the streets rounding people up causing them to fight back or unify, they just plucked them out of society in the middle of the night with Homeland Securi..., erm I mean the Main Directorate of State Security.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Main_Directorate_for_State_Security_(USSR) (you can look up many other references of them)
Had it not been done on such a massive scale it would have likely never have been recorded for history.
 
Last edited:
Again, far-off times and places. I can't think of a realistic situation in which I'd be forced to dig myself a defensive fighting position and repel waves of attackers here and now.

There's always another Revolution, but I wouldn't call that appropriate fodder for RKBA posters - not if they're intended for fence-sitters and antis, anyway.
 
I agree that it is not the ideal approach for furthering understanding and support of RKBA for fence sitters. More obvious threats to a typical person's safety like a criminal intending violence, or a being a victim experiencing it firsthand is likely to persuade fence sitters.
Yet you never know what the future holds.
 
In my lifetime

During just my short lifetime the Bill of Rights has been rendered meaningless, the police have become a military force, the courts and justice system a mockery of themselves worse than during slavery and more people are in prison than any other country on the planet. I've got plenty of credit limit on my credit card, the bills are paid and the house is warm tonight....but I'm not mistaking that for being free.
 
You're right, it's not as if there are a bunch of Chinese or North Koreans who'd give their left arm to be able to express what you just wrote outside their own minds.

We may not be as free as we were in those first hopeful years, but we still have our basic freedoms, at least Constitutionally.
 
"...just because it hasn't happened yet."

"...I think that genocide in the US is a wee bit far-fetched."

Hmmm, have you asked any American with a heritage that includes Shoshone, Iroquois, Cherokee, Shawnee, Sioux, Apache, Nez Perce, etc.?

My own heritage has a history of suffering from genocide and attempted genocide in Kirtland, OH, Crooked River, MO, Haun's Mill, MO, Farr West, MO, Liberty, MO, Carthage, IL, Nauvoo, IL, Deseret Territory (present day Nevada, Wyoming and Utah); all perpetrated by state and federal authorities right here in the USA!

Ever heard of someone named John Moses Browning? He shared my same heritage. In fact, it was his father, Jonathan Browning, that stopped the attempted genocide in Nauvoo, IL by providing and improvising arms for the intended victims, including improvising cannon from steamboat smokeshafts. Perhaps some of JMB's enthusiasm for inventing and making firearms came from the heritage of his father stopping the genocidal pogram in Nauvoo,IL? If Jonathan Browning had not been able to provide and improvise the defensive arms, he would probably have been exterminated, thus preventing JMB from ever being born.

So that was long ago, and we are now more civilized? Well, a review of the 20th Century shows a century drenched in the blood of victims of genocide. What was the first major genocide of that bloody century? Was it the Jews in Nazi Germany? Was it the Ukranians and Kulaks in Stalin's Russia? Was it the Christian Armenians in Turkey? No, it wasn't any of those, the first major genocide of that bloody century was in the Phillipine Islands, perpetrated by the US Army during the Phillipine Insurrection of 1898-1902 on orders of Presidents Taft and Roosevelt. Mark Twain claimed there were a million victims of that genocide, mostly civilians including many women and children. Reliable sources I've seen indicate there were at least a quarter million victims, and yes, most of them were civilians of all ages and both sexes, not guerilla fighters.

"...hasn't happened yet." "...wee bit far-fetched." Indeed!
 
I love the idea and the image, but I'll make a third vote for The Bald Guy's text. That hits home best to me.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top