Determining Group Size
Coming in to the discussion a bit late, but it seems there is some confusion about group size measurement here. Our games are mostly all based on 5 shot groups fired at 50 or 100 yards. This does not lend itself especially well to caliper measuements since nobody's calipers can check 5 axes at once and make any sense of it.
The official method used in our Nationals uses a graduated ring gauge, basically a set of scribed circles on a clear acetate sheet. The ring gauge is set on the target, and moved around to include (cover) the outer edges of all the holes within a ring of whatever diameter it takes, and then the judges measure a single hole or figure in the diameter of the slug reported to have been used, and deduct that from the size of the "group ring".
What you have left is the group size, adjusted for the size of the slug used.
There is no point to judging any competition based on the size of a plate needed to "cover" all the shots, because then nobody firing a large bore gun could ever compete and win against somebody firing a .22, even if the big bore guy was a better shot.
Any more than 2 rounds, you have to use a circular gauge, and to mean anything in accepted competition "group size" has to refer to center distance among the shots measured, not some nonsense like "covered all the holes with my thumb" or whatever.
Everybody is welcome to agree, argue, P&M all they want, but if you are going to play in any of the serious benchrest competitions, whether its ours (American SlugShooting Association,
www.slugshooting.com) or NRA, or ISP, or any of the rest, all are judged the same way.
An exception is when the contest is limited to a single caliber, where you can rank shooters according to what "covers" their group of shots.
To be meaningful outside that single contest, the actual score should still deduct the bullet diameter if the scores are to be compared to other contests with other size projectiles.
After all, the Ruger 22 guy with a 5 shot group covered by a 3" disk at 100 yards should not be seen as a better shooter than a guy shooting a 12 gauge slug gun at the same target whose shots are "Covered" by a 3 1/2" disk, and actually is grouping tighter than Mr. 22, once the size of the bullets is factored in.
Of course everyone is welcome to enter our contests and find out how good they really are, when the results get judged correctly.............