How Many Guns Are Enough ?

Status
Not open for further replies.
As I like shooting guns more than collecting guns, I'd reverse that equation and go with a safe full of guns in a room full of ammo. To my way of thinking, enough ammo to wear a gun out & maybe a couple rounds more is about the right balance.

Now there's a neat way of thinking about this!

Assuming an arbitrary number of rounds for this, say...50,000 for a nice round figure, that would mean a person like me would need $84,200 to cover the existing guns I have now, assuming current ammunition pricing and new-gun conditions.

Unless my math is off...might be, since I just scribbled this out on a postie.

:)
 
I always thought a 100 was a nice round number. I'm about half way there. Just nice to have a variety to choose from for shooting. And, when my other gun nut buddies visit, it's nice to share new purchases, and shoot
 
thats really more of a financial/budgeting question than a 'maximum allowable amount' question for me - answer being inventory is fluid and the skys the limit.
 
Not a fan of having a lot of stuff laying around. If I have more guns than I have time to shoot regularly and stay competent with, then I have too many guns. Usually that number hovers at 3-4 pieces.

.22 bolt rifle
.357 magnum service revolver
12g pump
semiauto centerfire rifle

That covers 95% of everything I'll ever need a gun to do so it's enough for me. if I was a multimillionaire my answer would be the same.
 
I agree with the OP. As the years pass, and the collection grows larger and larger it begins to get tough keeping up with all the necessary maintenance.
 
glock doctor said:
it begins to get tough keeping up with all the necessary maintenance

I'm still trying to figure out what kind of "necessary maintenance" do you have to do on guns that you aren't shooting?

Oldest gun that I can personally attest to it's maintenance over it's entire lifetime is a blued Marlin single-shot bolt action .22 that I bought new in the early 1960's from JM Fields (old department store) for the princely sum of $9.

It was used by me and my friends for untold thousands of rounds, sat in the back of a closet for decades, used by my kids for untold thousands of rounds, then has sat in the back of a gunsafe for more decades.

Maintenance over the last 50 years has consisted of wiping it off with whatever gun oil was lying around after shooting it, before it went back into the closet or safe, sometimes for literally decades at a time before it was touched again.

Bluing and wood still looks almost new (couple of scuffs in the wood, some bluing wear on the bolt knob and bolt), last time it was fired it still shot like new.

I have several 1st generation Colt SAA's (over 100 years old) sitting in the safe that I inherited in the early 90's and have since then been sitting there for over 20 years. I can't attest to what was done to them before I received them, but I haven't done anything to them since I received them and they still look exactly like they did when I put them in the safe.

What additional maintenance should I be doing?
 
Last edited:
Well Rounded Basic Collection

Not a fan of having a lot of stuff laying around. If I have more guns than I have time to shoot regularly and stay competent with, then I have too many guns. Usually that number hovers at 3-4 pieces.

.22 bolt rifle
.357 magnum service revolver
12g pump
semiauto centerfire rifle

That covers 95% of everything I'll ever need a gun to do so it's enough for me. if I was a multimillionaire my answer would be the same.
Looks like you nailed down the essentials well, and have a good variety to cover almost any situation. Congrats !:)

I have the same basic aim as you do, but have not been able to limit myself rationally, due to obsessive / compulsive disorder (or that's what I like to call it).:D
 
Not a fan of having a lot of stuff laying around. If I have more guns than I have time to shoot regularly and stay competent with, then I have too many guns. Usually that number hovers at 3-4 pieces.

.22 bolt rifle
.357 magnum service revolver
12g pump
semiauto centerfire rifle

That covers 95% of everything I'll ever need a gun to do so it's enough for me. if I was a multimillionaire my answer would be the same.

I felt this way for a long time. Several years, I guess.

I even thought my very first gun was going to be it, like it was the only gun I was ever going to buy and I had to get this purchase right. Some of you may have been there once, too.

Then I got a CCW and a little better salary. You combine that with sustained interest and boards like this... you might find yourself buying beyond that core 4 or 5.



I'm pretty satisfied right now, so I keep a small core roster of items easily available and the rest are in storage. My "small core roster" equals out to your 4 or 5, plus a couple more nice-to-haves. But I could pare it down to the 4 you list. It will be very nice to be able to basically "restore" this small core roster if I fall victim to burglary in a jiffy and not miss a beat. That is one big advantage of buying items beyond that "core".
 
Originally Posted By45_Auto
What additional maintenance should I be doing?

There's a lot of things that need regular checking:

If you're preserving your guns with oil then the actions should be periodically broken down, taken apart, and wiped with kerosene. Why? Oil will eventually congeal; and congealed oil has a tendency to become acidic and attack metal.

If, over time, you've used several different oils, or CLP's to preserve your guns then cleaning off, both, the inside and the outside your guns becomes even more important. Why? Because not all gun cleaning chemicals get along well together.

If you use desiccant in order to keep the air dry, it has to be regularly checked, dried out, and changed. If you're using a heating rod I'd suggest touching it, at least, once a month in order to make sure it's still working. (Rods have a way of becoming unplugged, too; so this is another thing you have to watch out for.)

It's, also, a good idea to wipe out the bore, at least, once every two or three years, as well. Perhaps because used bores will slowly leach out firing residue, they benefit from being wiped out with a good solvent and then reoiled every three or four months during the first year they're placed in storage.

I'm getting older; and I OWNED far more guns than any one gunman should, perhaps, be entitled to. During the past 3 or 5 years I've been slowly selling them off. Know what? I've been getting really excellent prices for guns that are as old as thirty years! Several buyers have, also, remarked about the extraordinary good condition of the guns I've sold them.

I have to think the prices I've received are, at least, a partial result of the constant attention I always paid to my guns and, especially, during those periods of time when they were in storage. I'll only leave a gun (or knife) pretty much alone AFTER it's been repeatedly cleaned during the first year that I put it away; AND after the exterior has been treated with either Carnauba wax, or (nowadays) FrogLube paste.

Just because a gun has been cleaned after firing, oiled down, and put away doesn't mean that it's going to, indefinitely, stay that way. Rust and a sluggish action can be insidious. People seem to love getting their hands on one of my guns; well, there are reasons. Reasons that I find myself willing to pay less and less attention to as the years continue to pass.

Now, because I'm not checking, wiping down, and, 'purging' the actions as often as I used to, I find myself using: waxes, FrogLube, desiccants, dry rods, and (lately) silicone-treated, 'gun socks' to help me ignore what's left of my formerly large collection of guns and knives for longer periods of time.

(I'm, now, down to the last couple of dozen really nice pieces; and I've got a lifetime of experience behind me in, both, gunsmithing and gun maintenance that says guns never take COMPLETE care of themselves. Two or three years of, 'just sitting there' are sure to turn up something that you really don't want to either see or feel.) ;)
 
Approx. twenty two can be far too many.
Seven guns which belong to a friend are being stored for a while, next to my modest collection.

His Beretta 9mm is ok, but doesn't "grab me", neither do his Colt AR-15, or Beretta shotguns (I don't use any of them). If his guns were certain classic WW2-Korean era milsurps, they would have much more appeal.
 
Looks like you nailed down the essentials well, and have a good variety to cover almost any situation. Congrats !:)

I have the same basic aim as you do, but have not been able to limit myself rationally, due to obsessive / compulsive disorder (or that's what I like to call it).:D
Oh there are definitely more pieces that I want. A Ruger 10/22 and S&W 36 Chief's Special come to mind. It's just that in the absence of time to learn how to shoot new guns well, my hobby money is better spent on ammo to improve skills with my current guns.

Anyway, we all determine our own level of "need".
 
Gun Master said:
How Many Guns Are Enough ?

Depends on who's deciding. The question makes about as much sense as:

How much money is enough?
How many children are enough?
How many pets are enough?
How many vehicles are enough?
etc, etc, etc.

It will truly be a sad state of affairs when someone else gets to answer those questions for you.
 
Choosing Enough

Oh there are definitely more pieces that I want. A Ruger 10/22 and S&W 36 Chief's Special come to mind. It's just that in the absence of time to learn how to shoot new guns well, my hobby money is better spent on ammo to improve skills with my current guns.

Anyway, we all determine our own level of "need".
Good choices.

The answer to the original question depends on the individual's : wants, needs, and resources (money).:)
 
I always figured that I would have too many guns when the wife started to complain. So far she isn't complaining.

I always liked to have 22 versions of pistols that I shot for competitions, so I have a bunch of 22s.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top