In San Fran, in a car, surrounded by mob of bicyclists...

Status
Not open for further replies.

Bubbles

Member
Joined
Apr 26, 2004
Messages
3,148
Location
Eastern Panhandle of West Virginia
WWYD?

http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/artic...ve/2007/04/04/BAGF7P12RN23.DTL&type=printable

Minivan's rude introduction to Critical Smash
Phillip Matier, Andrew Ross

Wednesday, April 4, 2007


It was supposed to be a birthday night out for the kids in San Francisco, but instead turned into a Critical Mass horror show -- complete with a pummeled car, a smashed rear window and little children screaming in terror.

The spontaneous Critical Mass bike rides, in which thousands of free-spirited cyclists roam the city, have been a fixture on the last Friday night of the month since the early 1990s. But even bike-weary cops, who have seen their share of traffic disturbances and minor skirmishes, weren't prepared for what happened during the latest exercise of pedal power.

Here's the story:

Susan Ferrando, her husband, their two children and three preteens had come to San Francisco from Redwood City to celebrate the birthday of Ferrando's 11-year-old daughter. They went to Japantown, where they enjoyed shopping and taking in the blooming cherry blossoms.

Things took a turn for the worse at about 9 p.m., when the family was leaving Japantown -- just as the party of about 3,000 bikers was winding down its monthly red-lights-be-damned ride through the city.

Suddenly, Ferrando said, her car was surrounded by hundreds of cyclists.

Not being from San Francisco, Ferrando thought she might have inadvertently crossed paths with a bicycle race and couldn't figure out why the police, who she had just passed, hadn't warned her.

Confusion, however, quickly turned to terror, she said, when the swarming cyclists began wildly circling around and then running into the sides of her Toyota van.

Filled with panic, Ferrando said, she started inching forward until coming to a stop at Post and Gough streets, where she was surrounded by bikers on all sides.

A biker in front blocked her as another biker began pounding on the windshield. Another was pounding on her window. Another pounded the other side.

"It seemed like they were using their bikes as weapons,'' Ferrando said. One of the bikers then threw his bike -- shattering the rear window and terrifying the young girls inside.

All the while, Ferrando was screaming, "There are children in this car! There are children in this car!"

She had the presence of mind to dial 911 on her cell phone -- and within minutes, the squad of motorcycle cops who were assigned to keep an eye on the ride descended on the scene.

The cyclists were loudly demanding that Ferrando be arrested for hit and run.

According to police, Ferrando had allegedly tapped one of the cyclists' tires.

When the alleged bicycle victim was approached, however, he said he wasn't hurt. He also refused to give his name or any other information.

Then, after a few swear words, the alleged victim took off on his bike while the rest of the crowd continued to yell at both the cops and the van.

Sgt. Ed Callejas -- the lead cop on the scene and a veteran of Critical Mass rides since their inception -- said he'd never seen anything like it before.

"I've seen the bikes swarm cars, and scratch them as they go by. I've seen guys get out of their cars and start fighting with the bikers, but if you had seen the faces on those little girls in tears,'' Callejas said. "All I could do was apologize for what they had been through."

The sergeant suggested that Ferrando write a letter to the mayor.

Estimated damage to the car: $5,300.

For Callejas and other cops assigned to the bike ride, Critical Mass has long been a study in contradictions.

For starters, San Francisco is a "green" city, and bike riding is about as green as you can get -- yet residents and commuters complain endlessly about getting trapped in the rides.

The city tries to ignore the unplanned rides, but there are always cops on hand to monitor the gatherings, even though any kind of traffic planning is impossible because no route is announced.

And even though the rides are held every month, Critical Mass has no organized leadership -- so no one can be held accountable for the group's actions.

In 1997, then-Mayor Willie Brown tried to control the rides. The result was anarchy and mass arrests.

Since then, the rides have shrunk in size. The city's generally hands-off attitude leaves cops as little more than bystanders.

"We sit there and they just go right through the red lights,'' Sgt. Callejas said. "What else can we do? Arrest one rider while 500 keep going?

"The only way to control this is through a massive effort by police and the Sheriff's Department,'' he said.

As for reaction from City Hall, Mayor Gavin Newsom said such acts of violence -- if true -- "only serve to undermine the worthwhile message of Critical Mass, which is to raise the awareness of bike transportation issues."

The mayor also said that -- if the charges are grounded -- he expected the attackers to be "punished to the greatest extent of the law."

Riiight.
 
I have participated in Critical Mass rides, as have some of my friends. I think they're a valuable tool to raise awareness of bicycle transport issues.

That said, this woman should have slammed on the gas the moment the first window broke. If she runs over a few people, so what. Her kids are in danger.

:fire:
 
Sure, it's easy to say 'hit the gas'.

But in a group like that, you're going to run down a lot of people who aren't directly involved in the mob action. Those would be 'innocents'.

Also, what happens when you've got a few corpses under the car and you get hung up on them? You think the mob is going to quit their attack?

What would I do? If I could make a getaway while only running over bad guys and their co-conspirators (everyone in a gang shares the culpability), yeah, I'd run over the thugs in a heartbeat.

However, given the numbers of innocents around on the other side of those rioting thugs, I'd probably done as this woman did: Call 911 and pray they arrive in time. In the meantime, some people would probably be getting shot if they persisted in the attack.

John
 
Classic leftist mob mentality - agree with us, or we will hurt you!

I think slowly driving out of there would have worked - slow enough to ensure they get out of your way, and to not inadvertently run over someone. I'd have the hazards on and be honking the horn.

Of course, rule #1 to avoid conflict is to not be there, ergo I wouldn't visit SF in the first place.
 
@Templar223

And the culpability for those hit that weren't involved in threatening the woman lies with those threatening the woman. Simple.

And being in SF, the woman did not have the option of a CCW, so she is forced to use the only weapon she could - her car.
 
As for reaction from City Hall, Mayor Gavin Newsom said such acts of violence -- if true -- "only serve to undermine the worthwhile message of Critical Mass, which is to raise the awareness of bike transportation issues."

Can there be a Critical Mass gunowners event in which thousands of armed
law-abiding gunowners march down the streets of SF after applying for a city
parade permit
in order to raise the awareness of safe and responsible gun
ownership? Mr Mayor, that would be a worthwhile message, too?

Oh wait, this is SF, CA....
 
But in a group like that, you're going to run down a lot of people who aren't directly involved in the mob action. Those would be 'innocents'.

There are no innocents in a mob. Except in the eyes of "the law" and the jury of twelve postal employees who would try you.

BTW, how do you quote posts here at THR? I don't see a quote button.
 
And being in SF, the woman did not have the option of a CCW, so she is forced to use the only weapon she could - her car.

Which of course, is the much more powerful weapon anyway.

Fudd, AFAIK, quote is disabled on THR to save server resources and bandwidth. You just have to cut and paste what you want manually.
 
And being in SF, the woman did not have the option of a CCW
CCW isn't illegal in San Francisco. I have no idea how many permits, if any, are issued in her home county. But is she was from, say, Placer County, and had a permit, it would be legal for to carry in SF.
 
If I had my kids in the car and somebody smashed in a window, I'd lay on the horn and I'm moving out and God help anyone in the path.
Be a hell of a legal mess to clean up later though!

Once again we see the 'effectiveness' of centralized law enforcement. The cops sure were there to help in that crisis situation weren't they.
 
"We sit there and they just go right through the red lights,'' Sgt. Callejas said. "What else can we do? Arrest one rider while 500 keep going?

"The only way to control this is through a massive effort by police and the Sheriff's Department,'' he said.

As for reaction from City Hall, Mayor Gavin Newsom said such acts of violence -- if true -- "only serve to undermine the worthwhile message of Critical Mass, which is to raise the awareness of bike transportation issues."

I can't image a worse job than an SF cop.

You have:

1) A mayor more interested in his (ex-) campaign manager's wife than he is in addressing mass-insurrection on SF streets.

2) A city council that is more interested in ending the scourge of plastic grocery bags than the plague of murders going on in the western addition. Oh, I stand corrected, they tried to address the crime problem by introducing a referendum to ban law-abiding citizens from owning handguns. :barf:

3) The chief, Heather Fong who could only be chief in SF. A stiff wind could knock her over, but she's always dressed like shes out on the street, shoulder mike and all.

4) The police commision. Suffice it to say that if you're involved in a shooting, do you want your fate to be partly decided by a person who can't quite figure out if he's male or female?

5) An outright acceptance of public nuisance crimes: panhandling, defecating on the street, etc.

I could go on, but why bother?

It's just no surprise that events like what was described above occur in San Fransicko.
 
CCW isn't illegal in San Francisco. I have no idea how many permits, if any, are issued in her home county. But is she was from, say, Placer County, and had a permit, it would be legal for to carry in SF.

I can tell you one person who has one: Diane "Turn'em all in Mr. & Mrs. America" Feinswein.
 
jlbraun said:
I have participated in Critical Mass rides, as have some of my friends. I think they're a valuable tool to raise awareness of bicycle transport issues.

You gotta be kidding me. Critical Mass has never been anything more than a bunch of self-righteous hooligans trying to screw with the Friday get-out-of-town commute out of a sense of purely malicious spite.

Roads were built for motor vehicles. Deal with it.
 
Mabey it is just that I am from a "non-progressive" part of the NW, but around here we learn that bicyclists are part of traffic and subject to the same rules. If someone runs a red light and gets hit by another car, they are at fault. If these Critical Mass are running red lights and one of them gets killed they've got no one to blame but themselves.

I am all for bicycle commuters and I slow down and try not to crowd them, but they have to follow the same rules of the road like everyone else.

Also, If a mob of people is surrounding my car and pounding on it, I am going to assume that they mean to harm me and I will get away by any means possible. If I did "hit and run" one of them, then they can get my license plate number and file a report like a sane person.
 
I apologize to all who have participated "lawfully" in the Critical Mass rides but there is a problem with that ride. It is that it has lost touch with the real reason for it's being which is to raise awareness of alternative transportation (bicycle) support by the City of San Francisco and nationwide. Unfortunately, it has turned into a way for a bunch of fringe wackos who only want to protest in their extreem way by violent acts to get on the street in a total mass way to do un-rest. Granted not all who participate are this way but more and more like described are joining the ranks of those who are in it for the good of it.

Almost every time this ride takes place there are skirmishes from both sides where a traffic conflict leads to beatings or even death. There were also up to a point and probably still incidents of police brutallity or at least over zealous police making arrest that they shouldn't. At best this ride is not thought out and sanctioned enough to be taking place with as many riders as have been showing up for it. I rememebr the first arrest were for no parade license.


This ride could be a good thing to, and I hate to use such a hippie term, "raise awareness" for their cause, but the problem with it remains far too often that the planning and execution of the ride is not thought out enough by the participants or the city.

I saw a documentary made by the event coordinator and it made the participants, cops, and organizer look like a bunch of foolish kids fighting over something on the playground.


If the organizers would actually work with the city and be somewhat self policing when no LEO are available at a possible incident, it could be a good thing. But it doesn't work that way yet. To address what the lady should have done is kind of moot as well because she probably did all she could and didn;t just gun it and end up killing someone. A mass pf people surrounding your car is sacrry and would be hard to respond to for anyone, evenb a well trained person.
 
Fudd, AFAIK, quote is disabled on THR to save server resources and bandwidth. You just have to cut and paste what you want manually.

Thanks AJ Dual, I overlooked the caption balloon icon :eek:
 
This ride could be a good thing to, and I hate to use such a hippie term, "raise awareness" for their cause,

No, frankly, there is no need to raise awareness. Everyone knows about bicycles, walking, the bus and Bart. The MSM in the Bay Area is always bombarding us with non-car transportation stories, which go into overdrive (pardon the pun) during Spare the Air days. People drive, despite the cost, because it gets you where you are going twice as fast as any other way, and you won't arrive to work soaking wet when it rains, which you will get if you bicycle to work. And despite traffic accidents, I was late to work or going home while taking Bart about fifty times more often than when I drive, and I don't have to deal with fights, pick pockets, crazed lunatics, the sick people hacking and coughing, and junkies passing out in the middle of the walkway on the train.

As someone already mentioned, the be-all and end-all of self-defense in S.F. is don't go there.
 
Eh, I was in Critical Mass back in my more leftie days. I don't do it much anymore, and I don't know what the movement is like now.

I just ride my bike to work every day, that's all. I've had to put a dent in one door with my foot because the lady was trying to merge into me. Yes, it was her fault, yes, she apologized, yes, she was OK with me kicking her door.

To keep this gun related, if I were packed into a crowd with nowhere to go and people started breaking my windows with hard objects, I'm telling other people in the car to get down and cover their ears because the gun's coming out. I've seen a few videos of "youths" rioting and breaking windows on cars and trying to carjack people, and I've decided if I'm in that situation I'm either running people over or shooting.
 
I was late to work or going home while taking Bart about fifty times more often than when I drive, and I don't have to deal with fights, pick pockets, crazed lunatics, the sick people hacking and coughing, and junkies passing out in the middle of the walkway on the train.

Heh, sounds like my ride on the Washington DC metro. We recently had someone write a great comment on it that went like this...

We can never get used to our commute because it changes daily. Commuting mimics the best techniques of torture: Something bad will happen every day but you can never predict just how bad it will get or what form it will take.
 
I almost got caught up in...

one of those rides, about 50 bikes. I was sitting at a red light when it turned green and I proceeded across the intersection. While in the intersection, I noticed a bunch of bikes bearing down on me from the side so I hit the gas. Seeing my full size 4x4 pickup only has a 6 cylinder engine, the response was not too swift. About 10 of the riders went down and a bunch followed me down the street making threatening gestures. Luckily, the next light was green so I was able to drive away from the situation. I guess they expected me to give up my right of way for their running a red light. I was armed too......in the case posted above, I would have hit the gas and escaped. But, you will never catch me in california either. It is not hard for me to make the choice, my life or theirs.....chris3
 
no problem

"We sit there and they just go right through the red lights,'' Sgt. Callejas said. "What else can we do? Arrest one rider while 500 keep going?

Spike strips

Post a notice that unauthorized bike a***ole mobs will be spike stripped and assume responsibility for their own safety.:evil:
 
"We sit there and they just go right through the red lights,'' Sgt. Callejas said. "What else can we do? Arrest one rider while 500 keep going?
Stretch a steel cable between the trailer hitches of a couple of patrol cars? :evil:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top