Interesting Article: "Should I buy a gun?"

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Oct 21, 2005
Messages
2,796
.


Read the whole thing. Definitely gives you a look into how some people think.




http://www.elle.com/Life-Love/Society-Career-Power/Should-I-Buy-a-Gun



.
Should I Buy a Gun?


After falling victim to a string of traumatic crimes, Amanda Fortini considers a controversial means of protection

By Amanda Fortini | January 12, 2012


One afternoon four years ago, my then boyfriend strides into the den where I’m reading a book and shows me a gun. A metallic silver handgun still wrapped in its original plastic, it lies there, impotent, in a small metal lock box, but it terrifies me anyway. My boyfriend, who I’ll call R., lifts the top of the box gingerly, like he’s displaying a rare and delicate treasure, a Fabergé egg that might shatter if jostled. He wants me to know there’s a gun in the house. I wonder when he decided he needed it, where he bought it, whether he applied for a permit to render the thing legitimate. Is owning a gun in Los Angeles even legal? Then, growing irritated, I ask myself: How did he manage to do this without my knowledge?

I’d never seen an actual gun, except in the holsters of police officers. To my mind, guns were verboten, menacing, violent. They were unpredictable contraptions beloved of white supremacists or paranoid meth heads in creepy desert hideouts. My formative years were spent in Illinois, where gun control laws have long been some of the strictest in the nation. I lived in a middle-class suburb, where mall-going was the chief recreational pastime and there wasn’t a culture of hunting or shooting for sport.
.


.
 
Considering the venue, an upscale women's fashion magazine, I thought it was fairly well done and presented in a way that demystifies and de-demonizes gun ownership.
 
I thought the article was well-written. She admitted her own ignorance, but was honest about her feelings and her fears. Though, I thought the article to actually be more of a piece about a woman's voyage of self-discovery, with guns being but a pretext in a sense.
 
Thanks for posting this. My girlfriend has recently taken an interest in guns. I brought her shooting (pistol and skeet) for the first time a couple weeks ago. She was admittedly scared of guns before shooting and afterward, she expressed how handling guns and shooting them diminishes a lot of the perceived mystery surrounding them.

She is now signed up for a pistol course and asking me which guns I recommend for her first purchase :D

I've sent her this article to read because I think she can easily identify with it, including having a boyfriend who introduced her to her first firearm :eek:

I actually liked the tone of the article. Her disposition towards firearms slowly changes as she critically analyzes the benefits of firearm ownership and recognizes the actual culture of gun owners compared to the perceived culture manufactured by the media and other organizations.
 
I liked the article. My wife was really terrified of handguns and she is slowly losing that fear. Its not any easy thing and I agree with the last sentence of the article.
 
Decent enough article, but for those who don't read beyond the headline, I wish she didn't use the word "controversial".
 
Hmm, am I the only who read that to the very end (last 3-4 paragraphs)?

Now that she owns and carries a gun... SHE DOESN'T KEEP IT LOADED!!!

To me, that's like asking to become a statistic for "firearm owner that was unable to defend themselves with a gun." She doesn't mention how often she practices with the gun, but if I had to take a guess, it would be approximately 0 times a month.

I'm glad that she has had the strength of mind to overcome her upbringing and culture, but she needs to take the last few, stumbling steps along the tightrope.
 
^^^^
One day at a time, one day at a time.

I had the same reaction as the author when I fired a .357 for the first time. I think I even I used the same language. :)

ETA: A quick glance at the reader comments - they seem quite positive.
 
My wife would never finish this article... it just goes on and on before it ever even "gets to the point".. I almost didn't. That being said, I'm glad it was written. I'm also glad I didn't pay to read it.
 
The article was written very well. The only downside was that the adverts were quite distracting. I'll expand after the day's tasks are over.
 
.

I didn't agree with the comment:

“Every time I look at the gun, it scares me,” I tell my boyfriend, as I eye its insolent blackness, leering at me from the shelf next to my bed.

“It’s a gun,” he says. “It should.”


A guns a tool, just like a hammer or a screwdriver. It shouldn't scare you.
.
 
I thought it was an interesting article, until she got to the LCR. Let me tell you I've got a whole lot of guns the LCR being one of them and it is my least favorite to shoot. I can understand why she might not practice with it , I don't practice with mind either, and I'm not a small framed tiny boned female. There are so many other guns that would be more practical and she would shoot a lot more.
 
To my mind, guns were verboten, menacing, violent. They were unpredictable contraptions

That's pretty much the attitude I notice from most non-shooters. Basically they are scared of the unknown, which to me is a pretty basic instinct and fairly reasonable, but what bothers me is their reluctance to learn the small amount required to know that they are just quite well made machines, that operate predictably, and by being a disciplined person and following the four rules, they are absolutely safe.

EDIT TO ADD: And what is worse is the extremist non-shooter that, because shooters have the interest and the discipline to learn about firearms, take the attitude, and voice it among the community, that shooters are doing something wrong or immoral.

It doesn't take much thinking to know what kind of person objects to others being able to learn and make their own decisions...
 
Last edited:
I didn't agree with the comment:

Quote:
“Every time I look at the gun, it scares me,” I tell my boyfriend, as I eye its insolent blackness, leering at me from the shelf next to my bed.

“It’s a gun,” he says. “It should.”

A guns a tool, just like a hammer or a screwdriver. It shouldn't scare you.
.

Then substitute 'respect' for 'fear'. Y'all are are welcome to disagree with me, but I think that a healthy respect for anything that can hurt you is a good thing, whether it's a gun, a table saw, or a horse. I grew up around all three and I certainly don't fear them, but I do treat them with respect. Until we got married, my wife had never shot a gun and was definitely afraid of them. Now that she has, she doesn't particularly enjoy shooting (she's a singer and protects her hearing very carefully), but she's not scared of firearms anymore.
Although the article was more than a little melodramatic, I thought it was pretty even-handed, and the author has certainly made huge strides forward.

James
 
1) The writer is good.
2) She took something that was negative in her life and researched it. She came to an answer.
3) Her evolution is not complete. She will become more familiar with guns as time goes on.
4) GIVE HER A BREAK. This is the High Road, and some of the comments have been a lot less.
ll
 
.

I didn't agree with the comment:




A guns a tool, just like a hammer or a screwdriver. It shouldn't scare you.
.
I respectfully disagree. You should be scared poopless of a gun. The second you lose your fear of what a gun can do, you get careless and bad things are much more likely to happen. It's like working with electricity or explosives.
 
I respectfully disagree. You should be scared poopless of a gun. The second you lose your fear of what a gun can do, you get careless and bad things are much more likely to happen. It's like working with electricity or explosives.

Well, I'm not sure about "scared poopless". An earlier comment about "respecting" seems reasonable. But your comparison to electricity or explosives is right on in my opinion. I'm an EE and create a number of at-home projects and I always have to be vigilant about unplugging stuff as I'm debugging.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top