John Ross review of novel "Enemies Foreign and Domestic"

Status
Not open for further replies.

John Ross

Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2003
Messages
534
Location
St. Louis
I have several complaints about most thriller novelists. First, their protagonists are too often 100% virtuous with no humanizing flaws. Second, the protagonists let their enemies live when you KNOW the bad guys are going to come back and murder their kids etc. Third, everything the government does (hi-tech weapons, military & police tactics, criminal investigations, etc.) functions flawlessly. Fourth, too many stories have all the brilliant thinking and brave actions done by government employees (Special Forces, policemen, Intelligence operatives, etc.) Lastly, some novels have a basic premise that is just not believable. (Clancy's RAINBOW SIX is a prime example.)

Novelist Matthew Bracken has avoided these sins almost entirely in his excellent debut novel ENEMIES FOREIGN AND DOMESTIC.

It is a challenge for any writer to come up with a plot that is at once plausible enough to have the reader accept it but also unlikely enough that it has not actually happened yet in real life. EFAD's dramatic concept is this: Wally Malvone, a lone mid-level ATF executive, engineers (with one accomplice) a long-range shooting into a football stadium and successfully arranges for an addled, destitute veteran to take the blame and be killed in the process.

Malvone does this because he needs an emergency that will encourage the President to embrace a plan he has put together: Forming a secret "hit squad" comprised of overaggressive ATF agents with disciplinary problems. This squad's duty is to be proactive: identify domestic terrorists ("militia members") and kill them during raids. The trial is in the media, when the cameras see the (planted) contraband retrieved from the slain terrorist's dwelling. Malvone wants to have this hit squad for the obvious reasons: funding, power, and prestige.

Naturally, some of the victims drawn into Malvone's web of treachery decide they have no choice but to fight back.

At each point in the storyline, as the good guys and bad guys acted and reacted, I kept asking myself if what was happening was plausible. How would *I* rewrite it to make it more believable? In some cases I thought that I would have had the parties react a bit differently, but I had to admit my alternate scenario was not necessarily more likely.

The fact is that when you get into the realm of serious, institutionalized government abuse of power in an environment with lots of resourceful, angry, well-armed people and the near-instant information flow of the Internet, you're in uncharted waters.

One critic said the female lead was an adolescent fantasy (21 yo, beautiful, motorcycle rider, expert shot, virgin) and I would have given her more edginess, but hey, a lot of readers like their heroes untainted.

Anyway, EFAD is an action-packed read, with most of the skill and creativity being demonstrated by the private sector, which is IMO 100% realistic.

Send a copy to your favorite Senator or Congressman...

EFAD is also good inspiration for me to get back to work on DETOUR, the sequel to UC. No promises, except there should be something in it to offend just about everyone.

JR
 
JR - Go ahead and offend us, but get DETOUR finished. I have only read UC about four (maybe five) times and it's time to move on. A sequel would be great.

Jim
 
John, thanks for the review.....it was the final encouragement that made me order the book. Good luck with DETOUR; I'll cross my fingers that I get a chance to purchase an autographed copy. I've published a fair bit of stuff myself, and know about the times that you get blocked and grit your teeth until blood runs out your ears!

Your stuff flows so well that it gives this reader the impression that it is easy for you to write. Get 'er done.....your readers are waiting.
 
My only gripe

is that I had to go to the chiropractor today to work out the kinks in my back/neck from reading the first 20 chapters online in one sitting. When the book gets here (any day now) I'm going to lay up on a few bags of ice and recover in bliss. Impressive reading, Matthew, and yay to a fellow High Roader's success!

Lupine
 
...with Hollywood running out of ideas (Brady Bunch movie, Flintstones live-action movie, movie about video games, etc), what are the chances of a movie adaptation of UC?

Is John Milius still directing?
 
UC a movie? Can I play Henry Bowman and pick my own Cindy?:D

I know, I know *kicks gravel* I have to play Ray. Darn type casting. *kicks more gravel*

Best wishes for Detour. Hope it drives them nuts.:cool:

BTW, if Detour gets made into a movie, will there be a role for a ruggedly handsome, suave, stunningly sophisicated, gun nut tilecrawler type?;)
 
hello john ross!

...I look forward to detours & being offended...

I may have to take the CCW class again, LOL! Hope all is well with you.
 
John,

I really liked the premise of UC, but thought the sex was unnecessary. Not offended ... just disappointed. I liked the book overall; just can't recommend it to most of my friends/family. Will still read Detour, though.

Best of luck.
 
The sex was fine. I don't understand the complaints - if it happens in real life (which sexual activity, both beautiful and ugly, does), it's fair game, especially with Mr. Ross' style (historical/speculative fiction).
 
Outstanding!

Good on yer, Matt! We're all waiting for the sequel!

And that goes for DETOUR as well. Thanks for this review, JR!
 
Good, humble review, John. Shows taste.

"The fact is that when you get into the realm of serious, institutionalized government abuse of power in an environment with lots of resourceful, angry, well-armed people and the near-instant information flow of the Internet, you're in uncharted waters."

Indeed & hope that never happens. :rolleyes: ;)

People are, sex happens, nature of the beast. Thought that UC reflected many of our foilbles ..... excellent read.

Ran through the 26 e-excerpts again a couple days ago of EF&D just to prime me for when my book actually does (hint ;) ) hit the mailbox.

Can't wait.

A sequel to UC? First I'd heard of it.

Good deal!
 
It's always amusing when people object to the very tame sex scenes in UC but say nothing about multiple murders, dismemberments, and feeding body parts to hogs...:rolleyes:

I absolutely LOVED Unintended Consequences. I wouldn't change anything...except to make it even longer. I am eagerly anticipating the sequel.
 
John Ross,

Thanks for the very generous review; I hope I will be able to meet you at the SHOT Show.

Now we all know the name of your next book, but nothing about it! Any hints? A thumbnail sketch of the first chapters?

I'm trying to imagine all of the semantic permutations of "Detour," but that one word is not much to go on!

Thanks again,

Matt Bracken
 
"Now we all know the name of your next book, but nothing about it! Any hints? A thumbnail sketch of the first chapters?"

Many said UC ended on an unreasonably optimistic note. These people assumed my message was "everything's fine now."

Wrong-o.

The implications of what happens at the end of UC are far-reaching and make for some VERY strange (and powerful) bedfellows. As in real life, the enemies of freedom don't just hang their heads in shame and crawl back under the rocks from which they slithered. MANY people have a huge vested interest in maintaining the status quo.

A dominant theme in DETOUR (as, to a lesser extent, in both UC and EFAD) is explored in Malcolm Gladwell's THE TIPPING POINT. This work of non-fiction explains how many trends, crazes, and other social phenomena should be looked at as epidemics. A small number of influential people can cause massive shifts (sometimes permanent) in general behavior. Our legislators should keep this in mind.

Not trying to be coy, but I'm not comfortable releasing any sample chapters until the book is done. Ask me at year-end.

JR
 
I read the first chapters of EFAD last weekend before an unwanted business trip to LA. I got the check off for the purchase on the way to the airport and am looking forward to reading the rest. I spoke with many people in LA and was amazed at the amount of blind trust they have in the government and police, as they are losing their basic freedoms to them.

I enjoyed UC greatly also.

I was wondering if either author received any threatening actions from the government.
 
"I was wondering if either author received any threatening actions from the government?"

Sort of. Go to http://www.freerepublic.com/forum/a39696d3b3c7b.htm for the letter my lawyer sent to the ATF concerning some efforts to intimidate my (now ex-) wife and also some book vendors. ATF’s official response was that they knew nothing about this, and that it must have been individuals acting on their own, without agency approval. This strikes me as a little far-fetched, that two agents would go out at 7:00 AM on their own time on an unapproved fishing expedition, but maybe that’s what happened.

No one has bothered me or my ex-wife since Jim Jeffries wrote the above letter.

JR
 
The sex was fine. I don't understand the complaints - if it happens in real life (which sexual activity, both beautiful and ugly, does), it's fair game, especially with Mr. Ross' style (historical/speculative fiction).

It's true that sex is a common part of life. So is diarrhea. Did they get equal exposure in the book?

(Please note, I'm not actually objecting to the sexual content, merely pointing out that the "it's natural" argument is flawed.)
 
YEAR END?!?! We have to wait until YEAR END!

Look who's talking!!!;)


While I didn't find the sex in UC to be offensive, it did prevent me from lending it out to certain family and friends. I can't wait for DETOUR. Thanks for updating us!
 
Last edited:
Razor, I don't understand. Who are your friends and family that they would be offended by a few short sex scenes in a book full of explicit accounts of (mostly premeditated) killings of government employees?

H.M., "very tame"... nice :)
 
Gotta love Atty James Jefferies letter to the ATF. BTW, welcome aboard Mr. Ross!
 
JR,

Thanks for the review. That does it - I'm going to buy the book. I was going to read enough chapters to decide for myself, but I don't care for reading a lot on the monitor.

Thanks again for UC, and I look forward to Detour.

520
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top