know it all gunshop jerk

Status
Not open for further replies.

kBob

Member
Joined
Jun 11, 2006
Messages
6,459
Location
North Central Florida
OK. it was me.

I just hope I was not wrong. Likely still a jerk but hopefully not wrong.

Yesterday I had a few minutes and as it happened was passing by a pawn shop I have made a purchase from in the past and not felt scalped.

Mayber forty handguns in there which I initially ignored and hit the open racks in search of a cheap break action single shot shotgun. Found a H&R 12ga. for $85 plus and a same same 20 that had some sort of pistol gripped boxy plastic stock on it with storage compartment for $125.

Nothing blew my skirts up, except a late model 67 Winchester single shot .22 (Bulkier stock with the take down screw inletted rather than sticking out) so as long as I was there I figured I look at the handguns.

Pretty much standard pawn shop fare......until I came across a Walther P5. Now I was never that impresses with the messed up P-38k from when the Polezi in Hessia had them but it was interesting to see one in a little small town pawn shop with glowing neon "GUNS" sign in the window.

Odd, the PP next to it had adjustable sights but no exteneded barrel. That's really odd it has an external slide stop. Wait a minute! there was a Walther PPS right there in "Smallville". Not bad looking. Perhaps sock drawer carry since it was new did not seem worn much internally from what I could see.

Ulm (antler) 1976 proof and marked 9x18 on the slide.

This is were my inner know it all made its prescence known. The tag was marked "9 MAK" under caliber.

I felt compelled to tell the shop person I felt this was an error. When I looked at these guns all those decades ago in Germany I was told that they used a cartridge called the 9mm Ultra by some and 9 mm Special Police by others and that it was a 18 mm case in length. This same 9x18 mm designation is often used to describe the 9mm Makerov. My understanding is that the two rounds ARE NOT INTERCHANGABELE or at least not in both directions. I was told that the Ultra used your basic 9mm .354-355 bullet while the Makerov used a 9.3 mm bullet of .365-368 diameter and necessarily a larger case mouth.

The shop person got a little huffy over it and another customer made a comment about a "gunshop know it all".

SO I have to know.....was I wrong? Will the PPS marked 9x18 function safely with MAK ammo?

I did not comment that I personally though $800 was a bit of a high price on a commercially failed gun using unobtainium for ammo. I did take the oppertunity to handle it again and be reminded of how neat it felt to do so in the way back and marvel that the German Polezi of the time could not see the value of them over a .32 PP with FMJ ammo. Today they are too big for what they offer but they were sleek neat and hard to beat in the Euro police market of the day.....except no on bought them.

Unless you guys tell me different I hope no one buys this one and tried to shoot 9Mak in it either.

-kBob
 
You were right- 9x18mm Mak and 9x18mm Ultra are two different cartridges and DO NOT interchange, especially with Mak ammo in Ultra chambered gun direction. The proprietor is an idiot.
 
Not that it'll make a difference to you but, Fiocchi still loads 9x18Ultra. Midway and Sportsmansguide both carry it.

To make the weapon viable you'd have to buy a couple, three thousand rounds to store.

But, if you want it enough. :)

Oh, and Georgia Arms loads it too.

http://www.georgia-arms.com/9x18-ultra-auto-1/
 
Last edited:
kBob, your post got my interest. So I looked up on Ammoguide to compare and read the info.

Quotes are copied from Ammoguide.

9mm Ultra (9x18)
The 9mm Ultra was designed in 1936 for the German Air Force, but was never officially adopted.

Seeking more firepower than the .32 and .380 Auto pistols they historically carried, the West German Police adopted the 9mm Ultra in 1972 when Walther designed the PP Super specifically for them. Accordingly, the 9mm Ultra is also sometimes referred to as the 9mm Police. German law enforcement have since discontinued use of the 9mm Ultra, opting for full-power 9mm Luger handguns, but many 9mm Ultra handguns have found their way to America. The Sig-Sauer P230 and the Benelli B76 would also come to support the 9mm Ultra.

The appeal of the round is that it packs more punch than the .380 Auto, but is still suitable for use in handguns smaller than required by the higher-pressure 9mm Luger. On the downside, factory ammunition may be difficult to locate in the U.S., as no American manufacturer loads the 9mm Ultra. However, Dynamit Nobel and Fiocci do produce factory ammunition.

The 9mm Ultra can nominally propel a 123 grain bullet at approximately 1000 fps.

9x18 Makarov
When Nikolai Federovich Makarov conceived his pistol, he ignored the specifications for a 7.62 or 9mm caliber, and built it around a new cartridge, the 9x18 Makarov.

Some speculate that the 9x18 Makarov was simply an adaptation of the German pre-WWII 9mm Ultra. However, there are important differences between the two. The 9mm Ultra is simply a lengthened version of the tapered 9mm Kurz (.380 ACP) with a standard 9mm (.356") bullet. The 9x18 Makarov uses a nearly cylindrical case and 9.2 mm (.363"-.365") bullet. The result is a cartridge that offers performance nearing the 9mm Parabellum in a simple blow-back pistol.

The 9x18 Makarov is neither a high accuracy cartridge, nor one with tremendous knock-down power. It is a medium performance cartridge built for simplicity, reliability, and adequate stopping power in a service pistol.

My understanding, which is limited, the Mak was mainly a Warsaw Bloc cartridge. I would find it rather odd for Walther to make a gun chambered for the Mak back in the Cold War.
 
kBob

You had it right; it's the other two there who didn't know any better. I remember seeing quite a few of these PP Supers back in the day but decided I really didn't want to add another hard to find ammo for gun to the collection.
 
You were right. It's lonely at the top.

"People who think they know everything are a great annoyance to those of us who do."

-Isaac Asimov


I would have been tempted to make him a bet. If he could remove the slide (for safety) and manually chamber a 9mm Makarov round I'd give him $1,000 for it. If not he either apologizes, or sells it to you for $400, or gives you a couple of boxes of 9mm....or whatever.

Can't lose. If it really was a factory Mak chambering it would be one rare bird.

Surely there must be some case one could make 9mm Ultra cases from. 38 Super maybe?
 
Without a doubt one of the hardest lessons I have ever learned in my life is when to keep my mouth shut. People don't want to hear advice from random strangers. I wouldn't have said a word.
 
It seems like to me that the gun would be marked ULTRA somewhere like on the barrel hood. Otherwise how will the user know the correct round to use?

Sounds like the O.P. needs to revisit the gun shop and see if a 9 MAK cartridge will drop into the chamber.
 
Looking around.
9x18mm Ultra designed 1936, introduced in the Walther PP Super for West German Police about 1972-1973.
9x18mm Makarov designed 1946, produced 1951 on.
I surmise the PP was not marked Ultra simply because 9mm Makarov ammo was not in circulation in 1970s West Germany, especially among West German police.

BTW. You can get a good bargain on a Pistolet Marakova if the owner has been disgruntled with the way it shoots with .380 ACP (and pistol is actually 9mm Makarov caliber).
 
BSA1 said:
Sounds like the O.P. needs to revisit the gun shop and see if a 9 MAK cartridge will drop into the chamber.

Do you think they're going to let him load the gun in the store?
 
The old Makarov site had a dimensioned drawing of several cases in the 9mm family.

If their dimensions were correct, the 1970s 9mm Police is not the same as the 1930s 9mm Ultra. They are probably in tolerance overlap so if you want to shoot up rare Ultra ammo in your Police or want to be able to shoot your extremely rare Walther Ultra with fresh ammo, you can give it a try.

Found it, see drawing now at:
http://www.defensivecarry.com/forum...7082-9mm-makarov-luger-largo.html#post1305462
 
I think you did right. If it was labeled for the wrong cartridge it's wrong. I would have told them. You may have saved someone from buying it and ending up not getting what they thought they were. Besides they may have purposely mislabeled it so it would move.
 
Know It All?

I too have learned my lesson. Keep my mouth shut & opinions to my self.


No one wants anything from a stranger. This grasshopper has learned that lesson too-at last.

Most of the time these folks simply ignore you-thereby making you feel like a fool. You are fortunate that the pawnbroker owner was a stand up guy.
 
Last edited:
Well got called by daughters school ( no problem actually) and so was driving by again this AM.

Stopped by the pawn shop and the actual owned was in.

He was concerned with my suggestions. Went on line himself. Then thanked me profussely for the correction.

He pulled the gun for remarking and as it was a consignment piece called the actual gun owner to have a discussion with him.

He was VERY pleased I had been a busy body and encouraged me to drop by with such information any time.

Looked at a Reising .22 while there but all I wanted to do was fondle it. I commented that I almost never buy anything and he again encouraged me to waste his time with such as the Walther PPS and Ultra info.

Nice guy for a pawn broker actually.

-kBob
 
kBob

Good job with the follow-up visit! Way to stick to your guns (in a manner of speaking). Nice to know your input was actually appreciated by the store owner.
 
It says something good about the pawnshop owner that he appreciates good advice. So many people resent advice of any kind.

I am not altogether sure a Makarov cartridge will go into battery in a 9 x 18 Ultra pistol. I have no way to find out by practical test, since neither I nor my acquaintances have Ultras. The idea in both was to get a little more out of the blowback pistol without making the gun look like a Hi Point. (Not that there's anything wrong with that... ;) )
 
Well after looking at a bunch of brass dimensions, making brass is gonna be tough due to the (rebated) rim diameter of the 9mm Ultra. One would have to either modify the extractor some or turn rims down on a lathe. If the extractor fit is sloppy there might be something that would work. 9mm Steyr comes closest. Like that's easy to find. I guess it's easier than 9mm Ultra...

This is one gun that would be a pain to feed.
 
The old Makarov site had a dimensioned drawing of several cases in the 9mm family.

If their dimensions were correct, the 1970s 9mm Police is not the same as the 1930s 9mm Ultra. They are probably in tolerance overlap so if you want to shoot up rare Ultra ammo in your Police or want to be able to shoot your extremely rare Walther Ultra with fresh ammo, you can give it a try.

Found it, see drawing now at:
http://www.defensivecarry.com/forum...7082-9mm-makarov-luger-largo.html#post1305462
Thanks for the link to that .JPG
 
The owner of the LGS hates when I point out errors on the gun tags, because he usually fills them out. He doesn't get calibers wrong, though just model #'s -usually lists milsurps as Model <barrel date here> i.e. Mosin M38 listed as an M42. :rolleyes:
 
Yes this guys shop is pretty good. He has one of the best Faux Fitz Special Colt revolvers I have ever seen and he displays it on an official Colt Letter explaining it is fake.

Weird for a pawn shop.

He does have som eof the usual crap but among the cheap zinc autos is a sad worn finished Beretta 1934 with artificial Mother of Pearl grips. Stuff like that.

Now that I went ahead with an AR build he has Andersen lowers in shop for $65. Some of his prices seem high as any pawn broker might try for and others look reasonable.

-kBob
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top