Looking for 20 G auto for new female shooter.

Status
Not open for further replies.

wardog

Member
Joined
Sep 9, 2003
Messages
673
Location
Colorado
I'm looking for a 20 G auto to introduce a new female shooter to some informal clay busting.

I've been thinking about either an O/U or an Auto for a 2 shot (got a double thrower) capability, .410, and 20G. I'm thinking auto for the lower recoil compared to the O/U. I'm thinking 20 G because I hear the .410's are harder to hit with. I've never shot a .410, so this is just what I've heard.

Under consideration:
Remington 11-87 Sportsman Youth Synthetic. 21" barrel. 6.5 lbs. MSRP $684 should be around $525 from my local FFL.

Beretta 391 Youth. 24" barrel. 5.9lbs. MSRP $1050, s/b less than $800 from my local FFL.
(I have a 391 Sporting in 12 G and love it.)

A buddy has a CZ (made by Huglu) auto in 12 G that works very well. They made em in 20 G, but apparently not anymore. They were about $300. Going to keep my eye open at the shows for one.

Remington had a LT-20 1100 Youth, but it looks like they're discontinued.

I am going to keep my eye out for a used 1100 20 too, but I may not find one in the time frame I'm looking for.

So, on to the questions:

1. Will the 11-87 reliably feed/extract light target loads?
2. Is the 391 worth the extra dough?
3. Am I missing any other contenders?
4. Should I reconsider the .410?
 
So, on to the questions:
1. Will the 11-87 reliably feed/extract light target loads?
2. Is the 391 worth the extra dough?
3. Am I missing any other contenders?
4. Should I reconsider the .410?

1. Probably but the 1100 definitely will.
2. Yes
3. Boy are you ever....see below
4. No, it is harder to hit with

What you are missing is the 28 gauge. If it's for clay targets only then it's the best choice. Recoil is light and it gets the job done on targets in a way the .410 never will. IMHO, the 28 hits as well as the 20. The Remington 1100 Sporting 28 gauge comes with a 14" length of pull and usually fits most women. If not it can be cut down an inch or so.

The 20 gauges that I've tried frequently seem to recoil about as much as most 12s (if not more) due to the lighter gun weight. I've fired the 1100 Sporting in both 12 and 20 and there isn't much difference.

The only drawback is 28 gauge ammo is more expensive than the 12 or 20. Although the .410 is also pricey, about the same as the 28 gauge.

I instruct at an clay target shoot held by a group of women each year at a private club and the 28 gauge reigns supreme for teaching the ladies.
 
PJR is correct, and mirrors my experiences.

Winchester 1400 is probably the softest shooting semi.
I have used this in 20 ga to instruct many new shooters , especially ladies.
Gun fit being important - I only mention this as sometimes these can be had for a steal of deal and a great something to have available in the choices for new students to use.

28 ga
28 gauge reigns supreme for teaching the ladies.

Agree, and my preferred gauge to teach anyone -be they Male, Female, Big or Little.
 
Almost all the spoting clays women I've talked to shoot a 12 Ga. While the 20 has less recoil they are also lighter so felt recoil is the same. Felt recoil is very dependant on shotgun fit , make sure the gun fits her especially LOP.
 
SM is going to jump for joy
but for very new shooters, 28 ga.
It throws a better pattern than a 20ga with pretty much zero recoil.
Ammo is spendy, but that's why you reload. :)

The problem with semi-auto's for new shooters is they are confusing. Where's the shell, what happened, etc. Too many things to think about. Get an O/U and it's much simpler, safer for everyone else too. She'll get used to the recoil, we all do. Don't do more than 50/75 birds the first time (only if she's going good)

Get the stock fitted, most stocks are WAYYYY too long for most women which makes the recoil hurt (plus they are cut wrong in back, most women have a bit of a blossoming in the area where the bottom of the butt hits, if you know what I mean. That hurts when that is all that is hitting. Fit is key.
 
charles daly

i just sold a charles daly to a guy for just the same reason to get a female started in shooting. the daly was new cost about him $235 and if she DOESN'T like shooting he isnt out much
and go with a wood stock. to me (a 6ft male 220#) a synthetic beats the crap out of me compared to a wood stock
my 2 cents
fog
 
Thanks for the replies. I hadn't really thought about the 28 G. After looking at shotshell prices at Natchez I think it's a fair trade off. (I don't reload yet)

So, Remington 1100 Sporting 28, MSRP $1020, or CZ Redhead (O/U) 28G MSRP$866, or Charles Daly Field Hunter 28 G MSRP$442 or Dehaan (O/U) U1/U2 $700-$1000.

http://www.remington.com/products/firearms/shotguns/model_1100/model_1100_sporting_28_specs.asp

http://www.cz-usa.com/product_detail.php?id=55

http://www.charlesdaly.com/HTML/Details/dynamic_details.asp?ModLink=CDGK3222

http://www.dhshotguns.com/Over_and_Unders.html


That Charles Daly is looking pretty tempting. Anyone have one in 28G? Do they reliably feed/eject target loads? Is the action on these simply a copy of the 1100 or 11-87?

Any other 28 G's I should be looking at in the $1000 or under price range?

Thanks again!
 
I like used guns.

Gun fit is that important, especially for ladies, they are built different.

mete is correct in the 12 being used by a LOT of ladies, with Proper Gun fit, and the loadings today, especially in a gas gun - less percieved recoil.

Double Ears are the key in less percieved in addition to Gun fit.

Used also means the ability to find Used stocks for a good price. Now it takes no time to change a wood buttstock. No problem to contour heel, toe, and the inside radius , we are tweaking the fit. Heck the lady finds she shoots "that gun" all she has to do is buy herself a used one if she wants and swap stocks with the one trained and practiced with. No biggie to refinish "pretty".

-
Semis : 1100s in 28ga are just too sweet.

Pumps : 870 in 28ga. I have ladies that want to learn the pump gun, allows them to transition to 20 ga or 12 ga for Serious Use. Skeet, to me, is a great training field. Low 8 is a Tueller drill with shotgun for instance.

O/U : Ruger Red Label, SKB, Citori...just have to look for Used. Gunstocks from say Boyds can be found, or custom ordered. There are places one can find extra Stocks, IIRC one lady found one thru Orvis, and another called and LLBean Shooting School directed her somewhere ( I forget).

SxS: Larry for instance is Using a used Bakail 28 ga - well when his wife lets him use it that is :p

Nothing wrong with new, just I personally am honest in function over pretty and up front with the ladies.
I know they want Pretty. Once we get the fit, form and basics, using a used , not so pretty gun - maybe one I stuck a pc of Moleskin on, whatever - I remind them we can find a Pretty gun, with these measurements.

Ladies, kids understand this.

Heck we tweaked the fit on a single shot .22 rifle for a kid, used gun, extra stock, and painted the thing Teal Blue recently.

She shot it "not pretty" and she admits she likes the wood and blue...just some "adopted uncle" - commented how pretty she looked in Teal Blue, and shared stories about custom guns being colors, and showed her the pics of hso's /madmikes pretty daughters with a pink and purple rifles.

Yep, she looks great in Teal Blue - shoots Teal Blue real well too. :D

She is reading, inquiring about refinishing the wood stock for later on.

I , like many here, keep it real simple, and go back over steps , add a new something, then go back again, add another...

Depending on student - and I have had some that went thru a trauma involving a firearm - I use primer only hulls.

Heck learning to load, unload, how the gun works, "hearing" and "feeling" a shell "go off" is great. Nothing wrong in my opinon if the student shoots nothing but primer hulls at moving targets.
Allows them to put together all the lessons so far on stance, mounting gun, hold points, aquiring, swing, follow thru ...etc, and pulling the trigger.
No recoil.
Waste of primer and targets?
Nope. Investment in student has no price tag.

Heck we have loaded up 500 hulls, with nothing but primers.
We show the ladies, kids how the shell is made - part of early lesson on understanding all this Art & Science

Not uncommon to have ladies deprime - reprime their own. Kids help, they want to shoot one "they did".

Whole package deal to me.

Heck to me, some of the best lessons do not involve a shotgun.

One student showed up and "Hey, I got this thing at a yard sale for $22, now what the heck do I do now?"

MEC single stage reloader , with 12 and 20 parts, bushings, bushings...she did real well...

We cleaned up this dusty , rusty , smelly MEC and had a ball doing it .

I mean ladies and kids all involved.

Oh the first target busted with a shell made all by yourself , on your very own reloader is so cool.
Only fitting I shoot her hat - right? :p

"You shot my hat, you ain't supposed to do that until I shoot a straight!" < hand on hip, giving me a funny look - other ladies snickering>

" Darling, you shot one and broke one - that is a straight" - I replied

"Well yeah, that makes sense" - other ladies had to shoot the hat too.

And Folks wonder why I stay in trouble...
 
Price a Big Deal?

Hmmm, reason I ask here, is I splurged years ago and bought the wife a Beretta A303 in 20 Gauge (I had more money than sense then). Wow! Nice gun!

A couple of thoughts here - assuming your lady's fairly petite compared to you and has less experience with shotguns: 20gauge pump "youth guns" can kick pretty hard, hard enough my little boy (10 years old) hates 'em. I've shot it and understand why. The wife's auto, though, is a joy to shoot, and 20 gauge will bust way more clays than a .410 any way you slice it. If you belong to a range that has a trap club you might go hang out there and see what the ladies are shooting, or take her to a gun show or something and start looking at pre-owned autos. The Beretta is a real dream of a gun, though spendy, and I'm sure a Rem 1100 with the proper stock could do something for her better than an 870 Youth in the same gauge. What one of the other posters said about women being built different (thank you, God :D ) nailed it. Shorter pull is the start of it and that's not the whole deal. You and I might do better with an ill fitting stock, but don't do that to your lady or your little son 'cause dealing with recoil is a big deal with small and relatively inexperienced shooters. I'd definitely take her to a gun show or a big shop where she could at least shoulder a big bunch of 'em just shopping around. Good luck - if your lady's shooting with you she might be a keeper. :evil:
 
The problem with semi-auto's for new shooters is they are confusing. Where's the shell, what happened, etc. Too many things to think about. Get an O/U and it's much simpler, safer for everyone else too.
I don't disagree however there is another part of me that thinks learning on a semi-auto with it's more complicated manual of arms and requirement to pay closer attention to muzzle direction has some merit.

A few years ago I introduced a friend into the shooting sports and he used a spare o/u that I had at the time. My plan was to eventually sell this gun to him at a very attractive price (for him) to keep him in the shooting sports.

Instead he bought a tarted up semi-automatic. He was a complete hazard with it. So much so that I refused ever to shoot with him again. If he'd stuck with the o/u he'd have been fine.

While the benefits of an o/u are indisputable, learning to shoot on a semi-automatic is like learning to drive on a standard. Once you accomplish the task then you can drive anything.
 
Thanks again for the replies. Keep em coming. Some background, she has never shot a gun, but is up for it. I do plan on starting with .22's and working from there. I guess I'm just looking for something light and light recoiling for her first time with clays. I'll also use it for other people just getting started in clays. I'm really leaning towards 28G, probably a semi auto due to lower recoil.
 
The lightest recoiling auto you will ever find is the old Winchester Model 50. Recoil is substantially less than an 1100. You can usually get them off GunsAmerica for around $300.

Tony
 
PJR and I have not shared anything via PM or Email that I can recall in regard to teaching new shooters.
I have sensed from his postings and replies - and his latest post seems to indicate we are very similar in attitude and approach.

Applies to some other members here. All that said to set up the fact -

New shooter , one that has never shot a shotgun, and in my case, having chosen to assist with ladies that have been traumatized in some way by a firearm

BB Gun.

IF one has read, or reads Brister's Book, That is how I start out.

My Mentors and Elders did this before Brister had written and his work published.

I'm also a Fuddy-Duddy on preferring to instruct handguns with a Revolver, and for Rifles - a .22 single shot.

Even Seasoned Shooters that have had detached retinas, or surgeries.

Scary, flat scary even a for "big old guy" to shoulder a firearm after having a detached retina repaired, and doctor confirms healed.

Overwhelming.

I mean there is a bunch of stuff one must do to fire a firearm - just the safety portion alone, then we add the correct basic fundamentals on how to shoot "that platform".

Don't buy a gun.

I get fussed at often when I suggest this. Reason being I do not want someone buying a gun:

1. NOT getting the correct basic Safety down pat ,
2. Getting a gun that does NOT fit them, therefore leading to being uncomfortable from:
(a) not being able to reach controls ,
(b) gun hurts due to recoil and as a result gets turned off on shooting , low self esteem or anything.
3. Too much of their "senses" invested in the material firearm and "senses" not being available to learn safety and correct basic fundamentals.

I have seen seasoned shooters, take a O/U someone has gotten, come out to the range and folks want to shoot it. They load 2 , called for a bird...
And Flinch, Jerk, get bumfuzzled and could NOT get the gun to fire.

Automatic Safety.

Yep, seasoned shooters, and they "know" all this gun stuff, they even a own a O/U, may be the same exact gun ...closed the gun, automatic safety kicked on and as I said, jerk, flinch,
Seen them miss once they "Oh yeah, this one has the automatic safety" and having to "add" one more thing to do, messed up concentration.

Heck I've seasoned shooters not be able to shoot a single shot shotgun. Call for bird and the hammer still down. :)

To ME - part of assisting/ instructing a student is to Allow the Student to Teach ME.

Example: Too many years ago a lady wanted to shoot My Citori just to get a feel of a O/U. She had been attacked, and beaten up, and we were still taking easy steps to digest all this gun stuff. Started her a Red Ryder BB Gun, one all she did was uses safety and slap trigger, I cocked the gun, I did not want to add anything else - I mean I keep this simple and baby steps- and fun.

I let her shoot a primer only .410 downrange [not going to try to hit anything, just work the gun and slap trigger]. Bottom barrel explained why shell inserted into bottom barrel.
Fine.
Live shell, bottom barrel and shoot downrange.
Explained how recoil reset the trigger for second barrel. She "Instructed ME".

"Okay, let me have live shell for bottom barrel and a primer only for top. That way the gun will fire, I can feel "recoil reset" and pop off the primer for top barrel".

Great Idea! Exactly what I did. I did not have automatic safeties on my guns.
She ended up shooting live .410 shell just downrange. Confidence level very high, she had fun, she had learned, had "instructed me" on how to assist her.

"Your gun stock is too long, and while a nice [Pretty] gun, I cannot shoot it because it does not fit me...".

Great! All this stuff we had worked on up to this point had been built upon, instilled, and part of her human computer. She did not want to try and hit a target, not even a stationary one - she KNEW the gun did not fit her, was not going to shoot where she pointed and did not want her brain seeing a miss and having that in the brain.

She was hitting targets with a gun that fit her, familar with, and comfortable with.

She just wanted to shoot a Pretty Gun with Gold trigger and "cute shells".

Heck a lot of my instructing was done with borrowed guns. Folks I hung with did this. I loaned out used guns, the extra stocks, recoil pads and whatnot for them to assist family, friends or for someone to hunt with.

On some of the "kids" days or "Stuff and Shoot" [Read : Invite family friends , kids and we gonna eat, and shoot for fun].

We had .410 single shot shotguns out the wa-zoo. I mean some brought as many as 10. Buckets of .410 shells. All we shot for fun.

Stick play money or "business cards" in balloons, tin cans...and kids, adults having a ball.

Funny, we got the ladies back on something they had pulled with us.

One card in a tin can suspended on a string said " New Shoes"

"I won a pair of shoes! "

She sure did - we had a bunch of plastic doll shoes [about 1" - 1 1/2" ] this meant they won. :D

I mean funny- ladies wearing these shoes on a string around necks , talking shoes, wanting to "try on" other ladies shoes...
"Boy we can get a bunch of these shoes in a closet..."
Daughters running around in "Mom's" or "Sister's " shoes....

Oh yeah we guys snuck up and started snagged these doll shoes off from around necks and put them on and ran out to shoot...

Ya know - I always thought shooting in "heels" would be a problem - didn't bother me none. :neener:
 
New Shooter?

Well, another guy's opinion. A different angle from SM, not a disagreement.

I'm of the school of thought that says new shooters react well with something they can have fun with. I break in shooters with a 10/22. I do have boltguns but they're not as much fun. I know, you're going to jump on me on safety, but hear me out - I break in shooters AFTER the safety lesson and am ONE on ONE at the range for hours with it. I literally stand over 'em close enough to seize the weapon if I need to and don't let anybody else distract me or my shooter. I've been teaching shooters for maybe 30 years and the only one I've had do something stupid did it with a bolt action single shot, so go figure. I was a rifle coach for some years and yes, all things considered, I'll agree they're safer to train with bolt action singles. Problem is nobody want to own one. If they got a 10/22 for Christmas, that's where they want to start. First thing I show them is the safety; second, how to lock the bolt OPEN.

Anyway, by all means, I wouldn't start with anything bigger than a .22. Down side with bb guns is they're hard to hit with, and that can discourage a new shooter. They like to be able to actually hit a target. For the same reason, I usually start either with a dot sight or a scope. NOT that they shouldn't be using irons, mind you, but it's easier to get them hooked on shootinig if all they have to do is lay the crosshairs or dot on the target to make something happen. All the technical stuff (outside of SAFETY over and over) can come later.

By all means, books and videos are great, don't see a down side to that, just sharing my experience of what works. Not that the Army always does right, either, but we had a lot of recruits in my units who'd never touched a firearm in their lives start with M16s and 20-round mags.

Whichever way you go, two real points: First (always) SAFETY from the start, and Second, start out a new shooter with something tame so it isn't scary. Be kind to your newbie.
 
Beretta has a nice 3901 Target for small shooters now. List $898.

http://www.berettausa.com/product/sp...ion_target.cfm

How tall is said female shooter? Does she really need a short LOP?

Also, I'm not sure that shooting doubles is the first priority.

Yeah, I like the looks of the 3901, but it doesn't come in 28 G. She's about
5' 6". I don't think she'll need an extraordinary short LOP. And no, double is not the first priority, but I'd rather get one to grow into instead of out of.

I have a game plan for training worked out, and thanks for the additional suggestions, they're a big help.

I'd like to get something I can shoot a little too. It won't just be for her and other newbies.

I guess what I'm looking for now is advice on a 28 G. Probably semi auto. I'll keep my eyes open for used ones, but I don't know if I'll find one in time. I don't like the Ruger Red Labels for some reason, I don't know why.

So, Remington 1100 Sporting 28, MSRP $1020, or CZ Redhead (O/U) 28G MSRP$866, or Charles Daly Field Hunter 28 G MSRP$442 or Dehaan (O/U) U1/U2 $700-$1000.

http://www.remington.com/products/fi...g_28_specs.asp

http://www.cz-usa.com/product_detail.php?id=55

http://www.charlesdaly.com/HTML/Deta...dLink=CDGK3222

http://www.dhshotguns.com/Over_and_Unders.html


That Charles Daly is looking pretty tempting. Anyone have one in 28G? Do they reliably feed/eject target loads? Is the action on these simply a copy of the 1100 or 11-87?

Any other 28 G's I should be looking at in the $1000 or under price range?

Thanks again!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top