The highest quality dot sight I've looked through was a Vortex. The glass was unimpressive. I think they don't care as much because of the market they are catering too.I agree with “it depends”, you don’t need or want a 6-20x if a long shot would be 100 yds. That said an 8 MOA reddot would be all but useless at 400.
It’s a battle between target acquisition speed and precision, not right or wrong.
How about a 60 yard comparison,
View attachment 832047
View attachment 832049
View attachment 832048
And you are holding you revolver wrong handed sir.