• You are using the old Black Responsive theme. We have installed a new dark theme for you, called UI.X. This will work better with the new upgrade of our software. You can select it at the bottom of any page.

Lyman "Quick Slick"... save your money

Col. Harrumph

Member
Joined
Mar 7, 2015
Messages
1,280
Location
New Hampshire
What a disappointment. This stuff actually increases friction. My plan for today was to resize some .41 mags but if I hadn't stopped the press stroke early it would have been stuck case city.

Pic from Lyman's web site:
Screenshot from 2023-12-19 10-22-11.png
 
What a disappointment. This stuff actually increases friction. My plan for today was to resize some .41 mags but if I hadn't stopped the press stroke early it would have been stuck case city.

Pic from Lyman's web site:
View attachment 1185175
Never used Quick Slick but have used One Shot. Learned early on you have to spray 360 degrees and in a downward direction to get some in the case mouth (unless you graphite the mouth with a q-tip). Also learned you have to let the spray completely dry before sizing.
As I said, no experience with QS so YMMV.
 
Last edited:
The only things I've used are Imperial and 10:1 isopropyl alcohol and lanolin mix. I haven't had a stuck case using either one. I typically run the brass in my ultrasonic and then tumble in walnut with Flitz afterward to get as much of the lube off and out of the cases before I prime them.
 
One Shot works well for straight walled pistol but not so good for rifle. At least for me anyway. When I worked as a machinist our upper management bought some Pam to try on our cutting tools in an effort in the attempt to lengthen tool life. It didn't work.
PAM cooking spray is a coating, not a lubricant. It’s designed to stick to metal and fill in all of the scratches and gaps that food starches and proteins will grab onto when they get hot enough to contract before breaking down. It’s designed to stick to metal, not food.
 
After years of my bad-mouthing Hornady 1-Shot, I finally bought a can . . . .(and read the directions).
Light coating/allowed to actually dry for a minute or two, it's the slickest thing out there.

From 357, 44Mag, 350L, 450Bush, 50 BeoWOOF, 500S&M* all the way up to the usual suspects of
300SAV, 308, 30-06, and 300 & 458 WinMags.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
I also have (and for 50 years used) Lyman and/or RCBS case lube, and later Imperial wax.
Still have both... but on the shelf for "odd moments".
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Just sayin' 🙃






* a Freudian spelling slip if there ever was one :neener:
 
Last edited:
I put a couple of drops of olive oil on my lube pad. I use olive oil because we cook with it. No reason to buy 2 different oils.
Indeed. The sheer number of things that do work out there make me marvel at the ones who can’t make a dedicated product function.

*cough* anyone who’s complained about OneShot *cough*

Please excuse my curmudgeon-ness. I’ve taken to have to duct tape the twin’s drawers on and I’m not pleased about it…
 
I put a couple of drops of olive oil on my lube pad. I use olive oil because we cook with it. No reason to buy 2 different oils.
My wife likes coconut oil for some reason or another. It reminded me of lanolin, so for shoots and grins I made some test spray case lube with it dissolved in Iso-heet. I was surprised to find it works quite well.
 
PAM cooking spray is a coating, not a lubricant. It’s designed to stick to metal and fill in all of the scratches and gaps that food starches and proteins will grab onto when they get hot enough to contract before breaking down. It’s designed to stick to metal, not food.
The main ingredients of PAM are vegetable oils, with canola oil being the predominant one and the only one in the OG PAM. Liquified petroleum gas blend is the propellant, soy lecithin is an emulsifier to help it deal with water. Canola oil is an OK lube, it has been used in industrial settings, especially steam ship engines.
PAM's Safety Data Sheet:
 
The main ingredients of PAM are vegetable oils, with canola oil being the predominant one and the only one in the OG PAM. Liquified petroleum gas blend is the propellant, soy lecithin is an emulsifier to help it deal with water. Canola oil is an OK lube, it has been used in industrial settings, especially steam ship engines.
PAM's Safety Data Sheet:
So…. You’re saying PAM is a lubricant, not a non-stick cooking spray.
Interesting.

Do you. All day, every day. 👍
 
So…. You’re saying PAM is a lubricant, not a non-stick cooking spray.
Interesting.

Do you. All day, every day. 👍
No, I didn't say it wouldn't function as a non-stick coating.
It does both, through the formation of a boundary layer.
Put it in a pan and viola; a non-stick coating. Put it between your fingers and rub; a lube. Any fat or oil will do that - lard, butter, olive oil, etc. (Motor oil would work in a pan as well, just don't eat the results; some are better at one function over the other.)
 
The main ingredients of PAM are vegetable oils, with canola oil being the predominant one and the only one in the OG PAM. Liquified petroleum gas blend is the propellant, soy lecithin is an emulsifier to help it deal with water. Canola oil is an OK lube, it has been used in industrial settings, especially steam ship engines.
PAM's Safety Data Sheet:
And don’t you know there are a lot of steamship engines out there:) I thought they used whale blubber?
 
And don’t you know there are a lot of steamship engines out there:) I thought they used whale blubber?
Nuclear ship and sub engines are steam engines, the water heated by Mr. Burns' favorite material, though I seriously doubt they use any vegetable oils. For the cost of a modern nuclear ship, as a taxpayer, I hope they're using synthetic. :)
After whaling went out of vogue, our ancestors tried all kinds of stuff to replace the oils from the poor critters. Sperm (whale) oil is fantastic for sewing machines and watches and was used in ATF, or so I've read. I don't think I've ever seen any but my grandfather probably had some in his garage.
 
Nuclear ship and sub engines are steam engines, the water heated by Mr. Burns' favorite material, though I seriously doubt they use any vegetable oils. For the cost of a modern nuclear ship, as a taxpayer, I hope they're using synthetic. :)
After whaling went out of vogue, our ancestors tried all kinds of stuff to replace the oils from the poor critters. Sperm (whale) oil is fantastic for sewing machines and watches and was used in ATF, or so I've read. I don't think I've ever seen any but my grandfather probably had some in his garage.
Yes. Civilian employee of NAVSEA for several years somewhat familiar with and have been aboard a number of nuclear powered and other naval vessels.

I was of course jokingly reacting to “steamship” engines, not steam ship engines.
 
I just wanted to get the Simpsons reference in there. :)
Went right by me but I do get it now:)

I can also say the smartest people I’ve ever met worked in naval reactors at NAVSEA (SEA 08) and its counterpart at the DOE (NNSA). Or at least they knew how to play that role perfectly regardless of whether they were really the smartest.

Don’t know what lubricant they used but I’ll wager it was among the most expensive on earth.
 
Just asking cause when olive oil gets rancid it also has an objectionable odor. Well, objectionable to me anyway.
You're not alone in that; fats and oils breaking down into the fatty acids and glycerol is part of rotting and decay, the smell of which most people don't like.
 
Back
Top