Man who accused Minneapolis police speaks out

Status
Not open for further replies.
MORE FOLLOWUP

Man who accused officers of assault denies he's an informant

A 25-year-old man who has accused two Minneapolis police officers of sexual assault denied Friday that he is a police informant and asked his friends to stay by his side.

Stephen Porter said that although he was approached in 1999 by a Minneapolis officer to work as an informant on a criminal case, he refused.

"I'm not an informant, never will be," he said Friday at a news conference.

The Star Tribune reported Friday that sources said that Porter was a confidential informant for Jeffrey Jindra. Porter has asserted that Jindra assaulted him by placing a toilet plunger handle up his rectum during a drug raid Monday.

The allegations stunned the city and heightened already strained relations between the Police Department and community members.

Arrest records kept by the department indicate that Porter has tried to help himself by offering several times to assist police, including once as recently as June 4. According to records of that drug arrest, Porter told police, "Gimme a break and I will get you some good buys." He wasn't charged in that incident on E. Franklin Avenue.

Spike Moss, vice president of The City Inc., an alternative education center on the North Side, lambasted the media Friday for reporting that Porter was a confidential informant for Jindra.

"Why would you participate in a setup to get him killed?" Moss asked.

Porter's accusation of sexual assault was made public Tuesday after Chief Robert Olson suspended Jindra and officer Todd Babekuhl and turned the case over to the FBI. On Friday, the FBI interviewed several officers involved in the raid.

Police Lt. Dale Barsness, who was with Porter at the Hennepin County Medical Center in Minneapolis when he was examined after the raid, said Friday that Porter hadn't complained about being in pain on Monday night.

A source familiar with the medical report filled out by a doctor who examined Porter at the hospital said that his injuries were consistent with the soreness and tenderness of the rectum that he had reported. Barsness said that he didn't see the exam report but that Porter wasn't acting "like he was in the least bit of pain."

"He was walking down the hall and jumping easily on and off gurneys," said Barsness, who talked with Porter for more than 45 minutes about sports and his hometown of Detroit.

After Barsness was told by a jail supervisor about Porter's allegation, he called Olson to "get him on board immediately." Olson said that he turned the case over to the FBI quickly based on a preliminary report that was on his desk before he arrived at work the next day.

Olson said Friday that the allegation was one of the most serious he's heard in his nine years as Minneapolis police chief. The allegation's credibility "wasn't just based on Porter's word," he said. He declined to say what else it was based on.

As the investigation continues, some community members have speculated that the allegation may have been copied from an Oct. 10 repeat episode of "Law & Order: Special Victims Unit" about a police officer who assaulted a drug dealer with a toilet plunger.

Even Olson said a "little voice inside me made me wonder if this guy," referring to Porter, "wasn't clever enough to work a scam after seeing the show." If he was a snitch, Olson said, he would know how to manipulate the system.

But Olson has made it clear that if the assault allegation is true, there would be criminal consequences.

"If this officer did these allegations, I'm going to put him in the penitentiary," he said Friday.

About 250 people attended a community meeting with Mayor R.T. Rybak on Friday night, venting frustration with leaders over police issues and the reports that Porter was an informant.

The sexual assault allegation has set off a series of news conferences by police and community activists. Porter spoke briefly at one held Friday at The City Inc. When he was asked about his medical condition and whether he's received treatment, Moss said that they wouldn't discuss Porter's medical history. Porter entered the news conference walking with a limp.

Porter said his friends no longer talk to him. He also said that he wants his friends to believe his word.

"Stick with me, I need you," he said.

In an interview before the news conference, the Rev. Randolph Staten of the Coalition of Black Churches said that naming Porter as an informant put him in danger and will inhibit other people from helping police to solve crimes.

Keith Ellison, Porter's attorney, said Friday night that his client is in hiding.

Star Tribune Editor Anders Gyllenhaal said, "When we learned that Stephen Porter had been a confidential informant, we understood that it was sensitive information. But we did not feel we'd be doing our job if we failed to include that along with everything else."

Scott Gillespie, Star Tribune managing editor, said the newspaper had multiple sources for its story and stands by its accuracy. He declined to talk about how the newspaper got the information that Porter was an informant.

Editors discussed the possible risk to Porter, including physical risk, Gillespie said.

Staten alleged that the Police Department had leaked the information that Porter was an informant. Department spokesman Ron Reier declined to respond to the comment. However, Sgt. John Delmonico, president of the Police Officers Federation of Minneapolis, challenged Staten to bring their complaint forward to the department to be investigated.

Porter acknowledged that he'd led a criminal lifestyle in the past but said that is over.

He has had four drug convictions and is waiting to be sentenced in connection with a cocaine possession arrest in January.

In another incident, on Bryant Avenue N. in July 1997, which led to a felony possession charge, Porter led police on a brief chase into a stranger's home. He was arrested with crack and cash, and on the way to jail, he offered to direct officers to a kilo of cocaine he had seen only 20 minutes earlier, records said.

One officer's report indicates that he told Porter not to make any statements about any drugs he had at the time, the report said. Porter pleaded guilty in that case and served a year in the Hennepin County workhouse.

"I'm no angel," Porter said. "What I did in my past is in my past."

Porter was arrested Monday after a drug raid at an apartment in the 2500 block of N. 3rd St. Because of information about potential gang activity, a high-risk entry team went in first and handcuffed everybody in the apartment.

Porter had been sitting on the porch but ran inside when he saw police. He was already in plastic handcuffs before Jindra, 43, and Babekuhl, 41, entered the apartment.

Drugs were found in a toilet, which was smashed open. No drugs were found on Porter, and he was later released from jail without charges. Babekuhl was one of two officers who drove him to jail.

A news release from The City Inc. said that Porter was given a full body-cavity search by the suspended officers. Jim Michels, Babekuhl's attorney, denied the allegation. An attorney for Jindra has also denied the assault allegation.

http://www.startribune.com/stories/462/4161455.html
 
UPDATE 1

Stephen Porter arrested in Minneapolis drug raid

Stephen Porter, who has said that a Minneapolis police officer sexually assaulted him during a drug raid last month, was arrested in another raid in north Minneapolis Wednesday night.

He is being held without bail in the Hennepin County jail on suspicion of narcotics and weapons violations. He was arrested during a raid in the 1700 block of Emerson Av. N. in the Near North neighborhood. No charges have been filed in Wednesday's search. Details of the case were not immediately released.

Keith Ellison, Porter's attorney, declined to comment.

Porter, 25, who was booked into the jail at 8:47 p.m. Wednesday, has accused officer Jeffrey Jindra of assaulting him by placing the handle of a toilet plunger up his rectum on Oct. 13 in north Minneapolis.

Jindra and officer Todd Babekuhl were placed on administrative leave pending the outcome of an investigation.

The officers have taken polygraph tests and have passed, their attorneys have said.

The FBI is investigating the case.

Porter was arrested Oct. 13 after a drug raid at an apartment in the 2500 block of N. 3rd St. Because of information about potential gang activity in that search, a high-risk entry team went in first and handcuffed everybody in the apartment.

The circumstances surrounding Wednesday's raid were not immediately available.

In the October search, drugs were found in a toilet, which was smashed open. No drugs were found on Porter, and he was later released from jail without charges.

Last month, Porter joined a group of protesters outside City Hall to demonstrate against alleged police brutality. While he said very little during the protest, he again denied being a confidential police informant, as reported in the Star Tribune.

When told about Porter's arrest late Wednesday, the Rev. Randolph Staten, cochairman of the Coalition of Black Churches, said he was disappointed.

But Staten, who has appeared alongside Porter since the allegation surfaced, added that Porter has repeatedly said he isn't perfect. Staten said that Wednesday's arrest doesn't diminish the allegation that he was assaulted.

"If he was doing something he shouldn't have been, that doesn't minimize what possibly happened to him," Staten said. "If he has done something now, that doesn't negate the overall broader issue that police brutality is a very serious, real active entity in Minneapolis. I hope that people don't somehow try to simplify this."

http://www.startribune.com/stories/467/4223141.html
 
UPDATE 2

Porter accuses different officer of earlier sexual assault

As Stephen C. Porter was being booked into jail after a drug raid Wednesday night, he accused a different police officer of sexually assaulting him during another drug raid last month, according to a statement of the accused officer in a document obtained Friday by the Star Tribune.

He accused Minneapolis officer Scott Creighton on Wednesday, but Porter had said earlier that officer Jeff Jindra was the one who assaulted him with a toilet plunger handle during the Oct. 13 drug raid. Creighton was also present at the earlier raid, according to the document.

The Rev. Randolph Staten, who has supported Porter, questioned the credibility of Creighton's statement: "It seems to me the police are making this up as they go."

Staten, president of the Coalition of Black Churches in the Twin Cities, said he visited Porter in jail this week and was aware of the accusation Porter made about Creighton. He said Porter's version of what was said differs from Creighton's statement in the document, though he would not disclose details of his conversation with Porter.

While Porter had earlier named Jindra as the officer who assaulted him, he repeatedly told jail employees Wednesday that he was afraid of Creighton, who had driven him to the jail after the raid at a duplex in the 1700 block of Emerson Av. N., the document said.

Porter, 25, was charged Friday with a third-degree felony count of possession of crack cocaine.

Another officer, Andrew Stender, saw Porter drop a baggie on the floor of a bathroom, according to the criminal complaint. The baggie contained 4.1 grams of crack, the complaint alleges, which has a street value in the Twin Cities of about $60 to $80, said Fourth Precinct Inspector Tim Dolan.

Creighton, 41, made his statement about Porter's latest allegation in a document that normally isn't made public until the case is closed. Supplemental reports are part of the investigative file. It is not clear what role the report has in this case.

According to the statement, which was given Wednesday:

Creighton walked over to Porter after he was in handcuffs on the bathroom floor and asked his name. Porter said, "Porter. You know, Stephen Porter." Creighton said he recognized Porter.

Later, in the jail booking area, Creighton said Porter looked at him and said a number of times, "I know you want to shoot me, don't you?" Creighton said he finally replied, "No, I just want to see you in prison."

After Creighton confirmed to Porter that he was one of the officers who booked him into jail after the raid last month, Porter started to yell at jail personnel, saying, "I'm scared, I'm afraid of this guy. Can't you get him out of here?"

The jail nurse asked Porter whether he had any injuries, and he said "they had kicked me in the head and face." Porter had told Creighton while they were still at the duplex, "You're the one who kicked me in the head."

The nurse stated that he was all right to be processed into jail. After that, Creighton alleges, Porter pointed at him and said, "He's the guy that used the plunger on me the last time. I'm scared of that guy."

Creighton requested that a sergeant report Porter's statements, and the sergeant said a report would be made by all the personnel present.

Porter has also accused Minneapolis officer Todd Babekuhl, 41, in connection with the reported Oct. 13 assault. Both officers have denied the allegations. Porter was jailed in the raid but later released without being charged.

The FBI is investigating Porter's initial allegation. Police Chief Robert Olson wouldn't confirm what was in Creighton's statement, but said all reports associated with Wednesday's raid have been given to the FBI. Jindra and Babekuhl, who have denied the allegation, have been on paid administrative leave since Oct. 14.

Jim Michels, who is representing Babekuhl, said Creighton's statement "confirms that Mr. Porter is not telling the truth about this and can't keep his story straight."

Staten said he was not going to disclose the details of what Porter said when they met this week. Keith Ellison, Porter's attorney in the alleged assault, declined to comment.

Staten said he was "absolutely disgusted with the Police Department's handling of this matter."

Said Staten: "I don't want to participate in this same unprofessional mess of trying this in the media . . . the way the police are doing."

Staten and other prominent figures in the Twin Cities black community have long been critical of what they believe is police misconduct. Asked about the latest charges that were filed on Friday against Porter, Staten said, "I don't trust the action, behavior or motivations of the police in this matter."

Police say Porter was not the intended target of Wednesday's raid. According to a search warrant made public Friday, a confidential informant told Mark Beaupre, a Minneapolis police officer, that crack was being sold out of the front door of the lower unit at the Emerson Av. address.

Besides Porter, one other person was charged, with fifth-degree felony drug possession.

Porter made his first appearance Friday in Hennepin County District Court on the drug charge from Wednesday's raid. During the brief appearance, Porter's attorney on the drug charge, Albert Goins, said his client has safety concerns inside the jail because of the publicity in the earlier case. He said Porter believes the new charge can't be substantiated.

http://www.startribune.com/stories/467/4227463.html
 
UPDATE 11-25-03

Stephen Porter says police violated plea agreement

A man who accused Minneapolis police of assaulting him with a toilet plunger now claims in court documents that police improperly asked him to be an informant after he'd pleaded guilty in a drug case.

Stephen C. Porter, 25, of Minneapolis, says police violated the plea agreement in a January drug case by trying to coerce him into being an informant and offering him probation. In a motion filed by his attorney on Monday, Porter asks to withdraw the plea he made Sept. 9 because of that alleged violation of the agreement.

Albert Goins, who is representing Porter on the drug charges, said Monday that he is still looking into the request for Porter to be an informant and more details about the motion will come out at a hearing Dec. 29 in Hennepin County District Court. The motion cites two drug raids this fall as harassment and abuse of Porter, including a raid Oct. 13 in the 2500 block of N. 3rd St. in which Porter claims he was sexually assaulted by officers.

After a raid Nov. 19 in the 1700 block of Emerson Av. N., Porter was charged with third-degree drug possession. Police said he had 4.1 grams of crack cocaine.

Minneapolis police spokesman Ron Reier declined to comment on the allegations in the court filing because Porter is the subject of ongoing investigations.

Reier did say that in general, informants come to the police, not the other way around. "It's not uncommon for a person being arrested to want to get out of it and ask 'What can I do?' " Reier said.

Porter has denied being an informant, saying he was approached by Minneapolis police in 1999 about being one but that he refused.

In September, Porter pleaded guilty to fifth-degree drug possession and agreed to a sentence of 2 1/2 years.

If he failed to show up for sentencing in January, he could receive a five-year prison term under the agreement. He was also required to remain law-abiding. The sentencing transcript made no mention of Porter being asked to serve as an informant. The sentencing was delayed to allow for the birth of a baby.

Goins said Monday that when a person enters a guilty plea, nobody involved in the plea can make a separate agreement.

Porter is being held in the Hennepin County jail without bail in the old case and $10,000 bail on the new charge.

http://www.startribune.com/stories/467/4231965.html
 
UPDATE 12-11

>Other related threads<
http://www.thehighroad.org/showthread.php?s=&threadid=46166&highlight=Stephen+Porter
http://www.thehighroad.org/showthread.php?s=&threadid=50885&highlight=Stephen+Porter
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

No protests as Stephen Porter is sentenced

Nearly two months ago, Stephen Porter was enveloped by advisers, attorneys and supporters. Amid cries of "no justice, no peace," he was the centerpiece of a rally against alleged police brutality. It seemed that whether they believed him or not, people found his explosive claim compelling: that two Minneapolis police officers had sexually assaulted him with the handle of a toilet plunger during a drug raid.

When Porter spoke publicly, he drew a crowd.

But on Wednesday, standing in a Hennepin County courtroom, Porter was very much alone. No advisers. No supporters. No family.

The 25-year-old, whose allegations of police abuse captured headlines and prompted a high-profile debate about police conduct, had only his attorney by his side as he was sentenced to three years and nine months in prison for fifth-degree drug possession.

The charge stemmed from a drug arrest in January. Earlier, Porter had tried to withdraw his guilty plea on the charge from January, but by Wednesday afternoon he had agreed to let his attorney, Albert Goins, drop the attempt.

Other than answering "yes" when Goins asked him a question during the brief hearing, Porter said nothing. And no one said anything about the incident that brought Porter into the news.

He was not charged in that raid in October. But he was charged in a Nov. 19 drug raid in Minneapolis. He pleaded guilty Wednesday to a charge of attempted third-degree possession in that case. He was sentenced to 2 1/2 years but will serve that sentence concurrently.

The resolution of the two cases came after extensive discussions Tuesday and Wednesday, Goins said.

To reach the decision in the Nov. 19 case, District Judge John Sommerville used a police report, tests showing that the confiscated drugs were crack cocaine and a criminal complaint.

The complaint said that while police were searching a home in the 1700 block of Emerson Av. N., they saw Porter standing in a bathroom closet. One officer saw Porter drop a bag of suspected crack. In the January case, Porter was in a stolen car that was stopped by police.

After he was in custody, police found a bag of crack cocaine hidden between his buttocks.

His conviction ostensibly will have no bearing on the continuing FBI investigation into his claims that police assaulted him. But Porter's credibility has taken some hits since his story about the alleged sex assault surfaced. Most recently police said that during his arrest last month, Porter identified officer Scott Creighton, a different officer from the original two he accused, as the one who allegedly assaulted him.

Last week in an interview in jail Porter disputed the police version. He said that Creighton was present at both the October and November raids and that he never identified Creighton as his assailant.

"He's making that up," Porter said.

Porter said that while he was being booked on Nov. 19, Creighton kept staring at him and telling him, "Man, I want to kill you so bad. I hope you go to prison for the rest of your life."

But in a supplemental police report, Porter is quoted as saying to Creighton, "I know you want to shoot me, don't you?" Creighton is quoted as responding, "No, I just want to see you in prison."

Now Porter is on his way to the state prison in St. Cloud. The Department of Corrections will determine where he will spend the rest of his sentence.

When Sommerville said toward the end of Wednesday's hearing, "Mr. Porter, is there anything you'd like to say?" Porter replied, "No."

Then he was taken from the courtroom to begin his sentence.

Porter said last week that he knew he would be going to prison, "no ifs, ands or buts about it." He said he was scared he might be hurt or killed there, largely because of a Star Tribune story quoting sources claiming that Porter was a police informant.

With time off for good behavior he could be out of prison in 2 1/2 years. But as he stared down how he will probably spend the next few years, Porter reflected on how alone he had become in a few short weeks. It was as though people "just want this to go away and they want me to go away with it," he said.

http://www.startribune.com/stories/467/4261236.html
 
Balog

I gets 'em where I finds 'em. That thing is everywhere out on the 'net. I could have put up this one
I%20smell%20BS.jpg
 
Minneapolis police officer accused of sexual assault returns to desk duty

A Minneapolis police officer has returned to desk duty after being on paid administrative leave over an allegation of sexual assault.

Todd Babekuhl, 42, had been on leave along with officer Jeff Jindra since the allegation by Stephen Porter was made public by Chief Robert Olson on Oct. 13.

Babekuhl went back to desk duty in the Fourth Precinct last week.

While the investigation by the FBI hasn't been completed, Olson was comfortable enough with the Police Department's internal investigation to allow Babekuhl to return, said department spokesman Ron Reier.

Jindra, 44, remains on leave.

"Things could change depending on the FBI's investigation," Reier said.

Sgt. John Delmonico, who is president of the police union, said he wasn't surprised that Babekuhl was back to work because of the many discrepancies in Porter's story.

Fred Bruno, Jindra's attorney, said he doesn't understand why Jindra hasn't been allowed to return to work.

"Jeff is a little bit confused, too," he said.

Porter alleged that he was sexually assaulted by Jindra with a toilet plunger handle during a drug raid in north Minneapolis.

It's not clear what role Babekuhl allegedly played in the assault. He drove Porter to the jail after the raid.

Both officers have denied the assault allegations.

Earlier this month, Porter, 25, was sentenced to three years and nine months in prison for fifth-degree drug possession stemming from a drug arrest in January. He will also serve a concurrent 2 1/2 year sentence for an attempted third-degree drug possession case in November.

http://www.startribune.com/stories/467/4288684.html
 
It seemed that whether they believed him or not, people found his explosive claim compelling:

Y'know that little sentence sums up a lot about what's wrong with America today: the truth does not matter, its what I believe that counts.:banghead:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top