Mouse-Gun Shoot-off!

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Oct 23, 2016
Messages
1,578
After all of the .32 S&W long and 9mm tests the Clear Ballistics gel block was looking pretty sad, and as I was contemplating this it occurred to me to wonder what kind of results I would get if I shot it with Mini-Mouse. This is the miniature .22 Short derringer I made in June. I use CCI Low-Noise Subsonic ammo in it, because ballistically it's a pretty good analog of the original black-powder .22 Rimfire introduced by S&W in the 1850's.

battle-of-the-mouse-guns
MjM4vvp.jpg
Normally I shoot over a chronograph into gel covered with four layers of denim, but frankly if I was far enough away to use the chronograph I wasn't sure I could hit the 4x4 end of the gel block; with a 1-3/8" barrel and no sights accuracy isn't this gun's strong suit. Pointing at the denim-covered block from about one foot away I cocked the hammer and squeezed the trigger.
4ahXVIc.jpg S2HD6ME.jpg
The bullet penetrated 6-3/4" and tumbled twice, once in the middle of the wound track and once just before coming to rest. Dangerous, even potentially deadly, but not something you'd want to bet your life on. That's OK, this tiny gun was made for fun and as a curiosity.

This got me thinking. How would a mouse-gun actually intended for self-defense perform? I happen to have some lying around, and some ammo of different types, so why not give it a try? I rounded up the usual suspects and gave it a go.
pqI6O6b.jpg
These are the Colt Junior in .25 ACP, the Seecamp LWS32 in .32 ACP, the S&W Escort in .22LR and the aforementioned Mini-Mouse.


First up was Linda's Colt Junior in .25 ACP. The load I had come up with is a 58gr. hard-cast flat point from Rim Rock. OK, it's supposed to be a 55gr., but every one I have weighed has been right around 58, so I'm gonna call it what it is. These were loaded over 1.1gr of Red Dot with a CCI300 primer. The load clocked 646 fps. for 54 ft./lbs, and penetrated a solid 12-1/2". Not bad at all. The bullet did rotate 180 degrees and came to rest base-first, which may be what caused the slight curve in the wound-track.
Fkbcwd6.jpg

The Seecamp was next, and it only uses hollow-point ammunition, not because they will expand, but because Winchester Silvertips was the only commercial ammo short enough for the magazine when this gun was designed. The load I use is a 60gr. XTP over 2.6gr. Universal with a Federal #100 Primer . From this gun's 2″ barrel this is good for an average of 727fps. and 70 ft./lbs. The bullet is not expected to expand, and it didn't. It did penetrate 11" of gel before stopping right at the edge of the gel on the bottom.
WiktQSG.jpg

Last was the S&W Escort, a weird gun based on a Belgian .380 pocket pistol from 1908. Kinda' large for a mouse gun, and holds only five rounds of .22 LR in it's magazine... but it's hilariously accurate and fun to shoot. I can get decent groups at 25 yards with this thing, and close range mag-dumps are a hoot. The ammo used was Sears House Brand ammunition made in the 1970's. I inherited bricks of this stuff when my Uncle Jim passed a few years back, and it has proven ultra-reliable and very accurate.
uWjZBPD.jpg
I fired this from ten feet over the chronograph and four layers of denim over the block of gel. Unfortunately I did not get a velocity reading. There were so many wound tracks crisscrossing the block at this point the only way I could locate the bullet was to literally tear the bock into sections until I found the bullet, then reassemble the block to see how deep it went. That turned out to be right about 8-3/8", and the bullet came to rest backwards.
P4N20Cu.jpg
High-velocity ammo would no doubt fare better, but the only HV ammo I had on hand were some CCI Stingers. This gun doesn't like those, so I just stuck with the standard-velocity stuff.

So there you have it, for what it's worth. Perhaps this will be helpful in estimating the performance of your own mouse-guns. Anyway, it was fun. Now it's time to wash the block, tear it into tiny pieces and melt it down to re-cast it. Mybe next time I'll try some factory FMC bullets in the .25 and some HV stuff in the .22... if I don't shoot the block up pursuing the next wild hare that goes racing through my brain...
 
I always liked the Escort; it was the basis for the 422/622. The .25 actually penetrated the furthest. Kind of surprising.

That surprised me too. I also suspect that given it's flat point, very hard lead and high sectional density it would be a lot less likely to deflect off bone than standard .25 ACP rounds.
 
Side by side comparison of .25 ACP ball and .22 LR HV will be interesting. I can't count the times I have heard "Why a .25 is not as powerful as a .22." A .22 rifle, maybe; a .22 pocket pistol will be a different story.
My Dad carried a M61 for a while. I don't even remember what he traded it for.
 
Side by side comparison of .25 ACP ball and .22 LR HV will be interesting. I can't count the times I have heard "Why a .25 is not as powerful as a .22." A .22 rifle, maybe; a .22 pocket pistol will be a different story.
My Dad carried a M61 for a while. I don't even remember what he traded it for.

I've heard worse. People saying .380 ACP is worse than a .22 for defense.
 
MTP, several years ago I did some really informal penetration testing with two of my mouse guns. A Beretta Bobcat and NAA Guardian, in .22LR and .32 ACP respectively.

I shot into a stack of dry and taped together phone books at near contact distance. The FMJ .32 ACP doubled the penetration of the fastest .22LR I tried. And the FMJ ammo didn't deform. Of course, mammals aren't made of phone books the last time I checked.

View attachment 937271

View attachment 937272

View attachment 937273
 
After all of the .32 S&W long and 9mm tests the Clear Ballistics gel block was looking pretty sad, and as I was contemplating this it occurred to me to wonder what kind of results I would get if I shot it with Mini-Mouse. This is the miniature .22 Short derringer I made in June. I use CCI Low-Noise Subsonic ammo in it, because ballistically it's a pretty good analog of the original black-powder .22 Rimfire introduced by S&W in the 1850's.

battle-of-the-mouse-guns
View attachment 936772
Normally I shoot over a chronograph into gel covered with four layers of denim, but frankly if I was far enough away to use the chronograph I wasn't sure I could hit the 4x4 end of the gel block; with a 1-3/8" barrel and no sights accuracy isn't this gun's strong suit. Pointing at the denim-covered block from about one foot away I cocked the hammer and squeezed the trigger.
View attachment 936773 View attachment 936774
The bullet penetrated 6-3/4" and tumbled twice, once in the middle of the wound track and once just before coming to rest. Dangerous, even potentially deadly, but not something you'd want to bet your life on. That's OK, this tiny gun was made for fun and as a curiosity.

This got me thinking. How would a mouse-gun actually intended for self-defense perform? I happen to have some lying around, and some ammo of different types, so why not give it a try? I rounded up the usual suspects and gave it a go.
View attachment 936775
These are the Colt Junior in .25 ACP, the Seecamp LWS32 in .32 ACP, the S&W Escort in .22LR and the aforementioned Mini-Mouse.


First up was Linda's Colt Junior in .25 ACP. The load I had come up with is a 58gr. hard-cast flat point from Rim Rock. OK, it's supposed to be a 55gr., but every one I have weighed has been right around 58, so I'm gonna call it what it is. These were loaded over 1.1gr of Red Dot with a CCI300 primer. The load clocked 646 fps. for 54 ft./lbs, and penetrated a solid 12-1/2". Not bad at all. The bullet did rotate 180 degrees and came to rest base-first, which may be what caused the slight curve in the wound-track.
View attachment 936776

The Seecamp was next, and it only uses hollow-point ammunition, not because they will expand, but because Winchester Silvertips was the only commercial ammo short enough for the magazine when this gun was designed. The load I use is a 60gr. XTP over 2.6gr. Universal with a Federal #100 Primer . From this gun's 2″ barrel this is good for an average of 727fps. and 70 ft./lbs. The bullet is not expected to expand, and it didn't. It did penetrate 11" of gel before stopping right at the edge of the gel on the bottom.
View attachment 936777

Last was the S&W Escort, a weird gun based on a Belgian .380 pocket pistol from 1908. Kinda' large for a mouse gun, and holds only five rounds of .22 LR in it's magazine... but it's hilariously accurate and fun to shoot. I can get decent groups at 25 yards with this thing, and close range mag-dumps are a hoot. The ammo used was Sears House Brand ammunition made in the 1970's. I inherited bricks of this stuff when my Uncle Jim passed a few years back, and it has proven ultra-reliable and very accurate.
View attachment 936778
I fired this from ten feet over the chronograph and four layers of denim over the block of gel. Unfortunately I did not get a velocity reading. There were so many wound tracks crisscrossing the block at this point the only way I could locate the bullet was to literally tear the bock into sections until I found the bullet, then reassemble the block to see how deep it went. That turned out to be right about 8-3/8", and the bullet came to rest backwards.
View attachment 936779
High-velocity ammo would no doubt fare better, but the only HV ammo I had on hand were some CCI Stingers. This gun doesn't like those, so I just stuck with the standard-velocity stuff.

So there you have it, for what it's worth. Perhaps this will be helpful in estimating the performance of your own mouse-guns. Anyway, it was fun. Now it's time to wash the block, tear it into tiny pieces and melt it down to re-cast it. Mybe next time I'll try some factory FMC bullets in the .25 and some HV stuff in the .22... if I don't shoot the block up pursuing the next wild hare that goes racing through my brain...

I love your collection of rodents. Thanks for the post.
 
Nothing has been able to change my mine after shooting it.

The Beretta .25 auto holds about 9 rounds and can do a mag dump in split seconds.

I have been able to keep a magazine ful into a 4" plate at arms [ grabbing ] distance.

I cannot imagine that not being a stopper for long enough to disengage or take out a primary.
 
MTP, several years ago I did some really informal penetration testing with two of my mouse guns. A Beretta Bobcat and NAA Guardian, in .22LR and .32 ACP respectively.

I shot into a stack of dry and taped together phone books at near contact distance. The FMJ .32 ACP doubled the penetration of the fastest .22LR I tried. And the FMJ ammo didn't deform. Of course, mammals aren't made of phone books the last time I checked.

View attachment 937271

View attachment 937272

View attachment 937273
Nice thoraxic shot on the lawyer on the right......
 
Tinker

Love your mousegun review! I use to have quite a collection of those diminutive sidearms but over the years I divested myself of them all, save for a Baby Browning I happened upon some years back. Still have a soft spot for the Astra Cub/Firecat, the Beretta Model 950BS, and the Beretta Model 20.
cKxXMLp.jpg
 
Some over the years :
I have many more. The smallest is a tiny Reck West German made .22LR tip down barrel that I took off the grips, It is like Tinker's home made without grips . Made for last ditch stuff. I had knife pistols and pen guns but they were contraband NFA items and disposed of them , didn't want to risk the rest of my collection for them :( I have half a dozen derringers now : .22lr, .22 mag a.38 S&W .38 spl. and .357 Mag were made in Germany 50 years+ ago and various branded. I have a Uberti made Maverick .45 LC pictured I used to use in SASS side matches and a Original Waco American Derringer Corp .38 Spl. stainless one I use currently in SASS.
022_zps6f04271e.jpg From 1oclock , clockwise : Astra Cub .22 short , Uberti Maverick .45 Colt, HS A101 .22mag,Colt 1908 .25 S&W I frame Terrier .38 S&W, Colt Junior .25 ACP and center Browning Baby Lightweight in .25acp. . I have lots of others.
 
I always liked the Escort; it was the basis for the 422/622. The .25 actually penetrated the furthest. Kind of surprising.
Not to me, it was designed by John Moses Browning, allegedly because he couldn't get .22 rimfire to feed reliably enough in such a small gun. The need for adaquate penetration above all else was well known back then.
 
Don't think the 22 short isn't deadly. A girl I knew spent 5 years in prison for loaning another girl a 22 short derringer to use against a customer in a topless bar. The mother of the girl I knew owned the topless bar and she was a dancer in her mothers bar. Another dancer had a problem with one of the customers so she loaned her the 22 short pistol.

The other girl walked up to the problem customer and shot him dead center in the chest where he immediately dropped to the floor graveyard dead. The shooter got life in prison and for her part in loaning the gun and having a gun in the bar in the first place she spent 5 years in the hoosegow. Nothing beats shot placement and just having a gun.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top