My first thread here on the High Road.

Status
Not open for further replies.

tattedupboy

Member
Joined
Jun 8, 2008
Messages
9
This is about an interesting encounter I had at work the other day.

While I was at work Saturday (I am a security officer), one of the customers was a guy I know (I have tutored him at my other job) who owns his own security company. We immediately struck up a conversation and I then noticed his sidearm, which was not in a holster, but rather, just stuffed butt forward inside the waistband of his pants at approximately the 5 o'clock position.

I commented on it, saying that carrying that way with a round in the pipe is unsafe. He responded that he has never carried a handgun in a holster and that he has been carrying this way for 20 years and has never had a problem. He also told me that the weapon he was carrying, a Sig Sauer (he did not say which model it was), cost $1,500 and had a safety, so there was absolutely no chance of an unintentional discharge, according to him.

When I explained to him that safeties can and do fail and that carrying this way was dangerous due to the fact that there was nothing covering the trigger, he said that everyone has their preferences and that this was his. He also hinted that his twenty years of experience compared to my relative youth (I'm in my 20s) meant that I was in no position to tell him what is or is not safe or effective. He went on to say that holsters slow his draw, to which I responded that the purpose of a holster was to provide the desirable balance of speed of draw and safety, and that it takes practice, (which I have had plenty of with the Level III Serpa I just purchased for my Glock 22) for someone to be able to draw quickly from their duty holster.

He told me that if SHTF, he is prepared to kill if necessary, something I found to be rather curious, due to the fact that his sidearm was butt forward at the five o'clock position; think about it, how in the world is this a fast draw? The scenario he presented was that if someone came into my site shooting, my holstered handgun would put me at a disadvantage compared to his unholstered one. I responded that this would be the case whether the guard's handgun was holstered or not.

Lastly, I asked him if any of the security companies he had worked for in the past had a problem with him carrying his handguns this way, and he told me no. I could only think to myself, "Inf**kingcredible. How in the world does any security company worth its reputation allow its guards to walk around carrying their firearms this way?"

Overall, I can't quite say that this was a learning experience, but I can say that it is frightening that there are actually people out there, both security guards and ordinary people, who carry loaded guns unholstered either in their pockets or in the waistbands of their pants. It's a shame that I'm 20 years (give or take) this gentleman's junior, yet I know far more about proper security protocol and safely carrying guns than he does.
 
Ok, you're better than him.

Gotcha.

Some people aren't the best at what they think they are. Age doesn't always coincide with experience/knowledge.

There's no point in trying to point out his flaws or challenge him really, you know what you know, he knows what he knows.
 
Better get used to it son. I have know many LEO’s and other so called professionals who violated every safe handling rule in the book and even had unintentional discharges while on duty or engaged in their jobs. I have seen a great respect for firearms and a great disregard also. Please understand I do not condone their actions it is just an unfortunate condition that comes with the everyday use. Just like any other tool of any trade. Many years ago I was witness to a Seattle detective handing his hastily emptied S&W model 36 to his 5 year old son to play with. The boy stuck the revolver into his father’s crotch and managed to pull the trigger. The detective just laughed and made some silly comment. He was involved in a conversation with another off duty officer in a store that I was working at. Another was the discharge of a pistol taken off an unlicensed civilian. This pistol was being shown me and to 2 other officers in an unmarked unit when the one in the back, holding it, discharged it into the transmission and killed the car. I was sitting in the front on the passenger side. They both laughed, the poor officer that had signed out the car and had seized the pistol and I didn’t. That incident taught me first-hand to be very careful around any “professional” holding a loaded gun.
 
I always wondered what happened to Gecko 45. Anyway anybody that believes that an AD ''can not happen'' is almost virtually certain to have one. Maybe after he blows his tool box off he will give it some more serious thought. Waist band carry is just a bad idea. There are tons of holsters that allow faster draw than that.
 
Mexican carry isn't how I roll, but if the gun's got a manual safety, I think it can potentially be done safely. As for his claims of speed, many are a legend in their own mind. That said, I've never shot with the guy so it's hard to say for sure either way.
 
Just goes to show you can't fix stupid.

The guy's probably never even heard of a competition speed holster. I saw a nice on the other day when I met with a local guy to make a new gun belt for me.
 
He responded that he has never carried a handgun in a holster and that he has been carrying this way for 20 years and has never had a problem.
:scrutiny:

Sounds like a pretty good track record. Ultimately, it is on him. The responsibility is his not yours. If he has a discharge, he deals with it. I wouldn't take offense that he didn't rush out and buy a holster based on your advice. ;)
 
I have carried a 1911 crossdraw in my britches with no holster more than any other way. No, it's not the best way in the world, but facts are facts.
 
not a fan of this guys carrying methods. Sad to say that all it takes is one accident for himself or someone else to get hurt. You did your job you informed him of what the potential was along with your take on it. Thats all you can do.


Oh and welcome to THR
 
Another kid that knows it all...What a surprise. I suppose all those guys who use a clipdraw are unsafe idiots too? Oh well, I happen to think the Glock is an inherently unsafe design specifically because it is not safe to carry without a holster, and I wouldn't have one. However, I don't call those who use 'em unsafe...
 
I suppose all those guys who use a clipdraw are unsafe idiots too?

Don't know if I'd call them (clipdraw users) idiots, but I can think of better ways to carry than just a clip on the side of the gun. "Mexican carry" is screaming aloud for problems- that the guy in question hasn't had any either speaks to tremendous luck or to the guy's disregarding of times he's dropped his weapon as "problems." If it is indeed a $1500 Sig he either overpaid or he is indeed an idiot for hauling around a high dollar gun in a manner which would make it extremely vulnerable to damage.

If you intend to carry a gun, you really need to ensure that it will stay under your control (meaning on your person). That means spending another $100-200 on a decent belt and holster.
 
He probably thought that since he is older than you he has more wisdom. You even said he hinted at that. You should tell him that wisdom does not come from age, it comes with expierence.
 
I actually like butt forward at 5:00ish (although I use a holster). It just fits well. I can't understand why it would be any slower a draw, you just rotate your hand as you move forward.
 
Inf**kingcredible <--- as a new member, it might be good for you to read the rules...


As for the mall.. security guard who carries in his pants, yes their are people out there who think this is safe, and those same people eventually shoot themselves in their mommy/daddy button... they use a holster after this experience.
 
I always wondered what happened to Gecko 45.

I don't think Gecko45 is a mall security guard or security guard of any type.

I think he is just a professional joker, or one of the regulars on Glocktalk, AR15 or HK trying to stir up some fun.
 
Wasn't there an article by Dan Walsh where someone drew like that and castrated himself.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top